Listen up, film fans! Actor & comedian Paul Scheer and film critic Amy Nicholson want your advice as they make the ultimate list of the greatest movies of all time. In Season 1, they watched every one of the AFI’s Top 100 films...and decided they could kick off half. Now, they're filling in the gaps by investigating wildly diverse areas of film through miniseries on topics like horror movies, documentaries and romantic comedies, with help from listeners' picks. Along the way, they’ll dissect iconic scenes, spotlight their favorite characters, and talk to some of the actors and directors who worked on these classics. And when Unspooled has built their own list of the best movies on earth, they'll blast them into space to be immortalized for eternity. Seriously.
61 Subscribers
Podcast hosts
No host has claimed this podcast yet, if you are the host you can verify ownership by claiming this podcast
© 2021 Earwolf, Paul Scheer & Amy Nicholson
Unspooled
Read more
61 Subscribers
Reviews
Ricky Mokel
5 out of 5 stars
Love Amy and Tall
That’s it
Lindenfield
4 out of 5 stars
Fantastic
I love this show. Amy & Paul’s insights and differing perspectives are thought provoking. They’ve changed how I think about film. It’s all killer no filler, unless they’re talking about music/musicians. But that’s ok, this isn’t a music show after all.
booftak
2 out of 5 stars
Awful editing
Great podcast but the editing is terrible. Lots of mistakes in cutting lines and glitches. One of the worst edited pro podcasts. Last episode (Oscar’s 2022) cuts off mid sentence. Fire the editor, some of these recent episodes are unlistenable.
kittycorbu
3 out of 5 stars
Fantastic but…
Absolutely fantastic adult discussion on film. Love the healthy disagreements. But I have to agree with the comments criticizing the misguided and clunky SJW (woke) overlay just so self-satisfied and sanctimonious.
Hobbitses4hire
5 out of 5 stars
Blue Velvet
I watched Blue Velvet several months ago or maybe sometime during the pandemic, I can’t remember—time is ruined! But I’m still thinking about this movie months after watching it and decided to look for a movie pod that could articulate what it is about this film that makes it feel so impactful. The episode was super insightful and interesting. I’m a new fan! Great episode! Thank you!
WendyHale
5 out of 5 stars
Learned so much
I’m assuming people are complaining about this podcast because it acknowledges issues issues like feminism, racism, sexism structural inequality, power dynamics and other concepts that Upset the Public despite the fact they are often critical to a director and writer’s vision and central to the plot. Some might say this is what defines a good film from a great one, but this is also Upsetting to the Public. As for myself, I love this podcast and the length is really suitable for running, taking a long walk, or when you’re trapped on a long haul flight. I’ve also learned a lot! Hope they keep going and would love to see some more world cinema at some point because I am selfish and want to learn more about non western directors.
Stringfellow Hawkeye
4 out of 5 stars
Good but not woke enough
This podcast is quite enjoyable to listen to. I like the deep dive analysis and the fun discussion between the two hosts. I would give this 5 stars if the male host would stop being so not woke enough. It's a film podcast but he feels the need to in constantly inject his not far left enough ideology onto movies. Let's keep the conversation around movies and not your smug, rich, California viewpoints.
Rox7123
1 out of 5 stars
Woke is getting old
White people hating white people. White lady hating white men. I’m over it. Signed: a Mexican.
Doeerick
5 out of 5 stars
Wise Up
Thank you for discussing the very complex movie that is Crash. A few points: Although it’s not a movie that makes it’s point well, it does make a points. 1) Systemic racism will always be a cycle. The imagery of the cars crashing, the first scene and the last, alludes to the inevitable force of racism and how it rear ends you. You don’t see it coming but it makes a huge impact. 2) Aimee Mann does sing Wise Up which is an absolute call for action. So Amy, I know you want to give this movie the credit of being ambiguous, but the song is literally telling you to take notice. 3) Paul- I agree this isn’t an allegory but it is a fable. A heighten story that captures the hypocrisy of racism and the consequences. We the viewers see the excess of racism but these characters are only aware of an instant. A micro aggression that goes too far.
Lawmonster
5 out of 5 stars
Great podcast
This is a really great podcast if you enjoy movies and movie criticism. Really insightful with fun conversations about movies and pop culture. They make some really awesome movie choices so they are always talking about something different than just the latest blockbuster. While I don’t always agree with Amy or Paul’s opinions on movies, I always enjoy their differing perspectives. They are a delight. From my review of some of the other reviews on here, I guess this podcast isn’t going to be your thing if you are some poor MAGA incel. But who knows, maybe this will convert you. Good luck and may the force be with you.
B. Ewbs
5 out of 5 stars
True masters of culture and class
So…. I listen to a healthy amount of podcasts. I decidedly do NOT tend to rate and/or review. (I know, I know, I am the lowliest of low-lifes) I’ve been a faithful follower of HDTGM since around 2014. This past decade of fighting cancer has been so much more enjoyable thanks to the likes of the Howdies and the sister-pod- UNSPOOLED. Specifically, I’m going to have to call out Mr. Paul-Tall-John Sheer. As if opining on LOST in a succinct, favorable, and *ahem* correct way wasn’t enough… you were also able to make one of the best critical analysis of The Last Jedi I’ve had the pleasure of hearing (and sharing for each). These 5 stars are so well deserved, I’m sincerely considering creating a ghost Gmail account to give yous all even more kudos! A sincere thank you, for all the hours of entertainment
JRL19606
2 out of 5 stars
Fun but obnoxious?
I love the insight and deep dives into different films. The conversation is usually pretty awesome and I always learn something. That being said, sometimes the hosts overuse a socio-political lens and insert meaning into things where there probably isn’t any. I do love the show, but it seems as though there’s a strange strain of pretentious condescension that I don’t really like. Both Amy and Paul occasionally make statements that imply or infer that audience members who do not agree with them or their opinions are either ignorant or just bad people. Additionally, both tend to look down on the sort of “middle America” viewers in a lot of ways. Its pretty patronizing.
moody mamma
5 out of 5 stars
Great show
I love all the back stories behind these movies
NierOh
5 out of 5 stars
Rad
Hilarious, as hilarious as Bag Fries
Jimi 1
4 out of 5 stars
Good except Woke
This podcast is quite enjoyable to listen to. I like the deep dive analysis and the fun discussion between the two hosts. I would give this 5 stars if the female host would stop being so woke. It’s a film podcast but she feels the need to constantly inject her far left ideology onto movies. Let’s keep the conversation around movies and not your smug, rich, California viewpoints.
AJ_Larson
1 out of 5 stars
Out of touch
Just listened to The Dark Knight episode which unfortunately went completely off the rails with lunatic political takes from both hosts. You cannot boil good and evil down to republicans and democrats. Anyone who thinks you can is hopelessly brainwashed and completely out of touch with reality. YOU, the hosts, along with the rest of Hollywood and establishment media are the ones forcing the choice between the two barges, and the everyday people of America are the passengers who decide not to take your bait. What a disaster of a podcast.
MikeV514
5 out of 5 stars
Listen to this Pod - obviously
Paul and Amy (we’re on a first name basis) are fun and into it. You’ll feel like you’re sitting in ear shot of two people that love the movie as much as you do and know WAY more about it. The episodes include movie clips and other relevant audio. For me it’s not a don’t miss an episode kind of pod but I subscribe to see what they’re up to. I’m hoping they’ll do a Snatch episode. Some say (or at least one person said to me) that it’s Brad Pit’s best performance.
Rekoj2324
5 out of 5 stars
Great show
Y’all have me wanting to watch a lot of these movies and also wish I had a podcast to discuss them just like this! Great job on the show and I’m glad I found a movie podcast worth listening to!
Ac2009
1 out of 5 stars
Did Amy even watch Heat?
Writing this review on the one episode I listened to. For the record, I love film critique podcasts. Amy’s “commentary” absolutely ruined it. Vapid and empty. Fully devoid of any actual knowledge of film. No insight into cinematography techniques, scoring, or storylines. Did she even read a book from film school? Poor Paul tried to pull an intelligent thought out of her but he just couldn’t.
Respect4returnofJedi
3 out of 5 stars
podcast undercut by host’s political beliefs
I enjoy listening to Amy , whereas I find Paul a little annoying sometimes and he can sound like he’s on meth. When their politics, particularly Paul’s, are forced into their film discussions it can be more than a little off-putting.
ladyamandarae
3 out of 5 stars
Your critic is showing
Amy. I have had to turn off multiple episodes and switch to others because your short sighted critiques absolutely ruined my listening experience. When you like or love a movie, you provide so much detail it’s a joy. When you don’t, my god woman. I can’t even get remotely on board. Gain some perspective or just do something objective and add cool facts about the movie instead of droning on. Paul- killin it.
PerceiverofGoats
5 out of 5 stars
About
Paul and Amy are robots programmed to say the word “about” as many times as possible. Listen for it, it’s actually insane.
Distiller_Louisville
1 out of 5 stars
This should just be Amy’s podcast
I wish Amy ran this podcast alone. She doesn’t need Paul. He has no curiosity for any point of view that isn’t his own, including the point of view of the filmmakers themselves. He talks over Amy to an excruciating degree. He has no patience or appetite for cinema. And I don’t understand why this overqualified woman has to be paired with a deeply unqualified man.
LissieDee
5 out of 5 stars
Awesome Show!
There are way too many podcasts about movies, but this one really stands out. The hosts are entertaining and informed. Just make sure you watch the film they’re discussing before you listen!
cc826826
5 out of 5 stars
LOVE IT!!
Paul and Amy put so much care into each episode—well-researched and thoughtful.
paintnwood
1 out of 5 stars
Great idea, not so great execution
Paul and Amy have very different ways of talking about movies, that should be a plus but it makes the show hard to listen to sometimes. Personally I find Amy grating, she doesn’t seem to listen to the conversation so much as wait for her turn to talk, it sounds like she’s reading lines rather than participating in a dialog. Paul has his flaws but he sounds interested in what’s going on, I wish it went both ways. Blew my mind to find out she’s a film critic as her day job.
carotene
5 out of 5 stars
I just love this podcast so much
Every episode is like listening into a conversation between two friends who are very knowledgeable about films. Amy and Paul are not afraid to get very personal and share how a movie applies to their lives which often deepens my understanding or appreciation of a movie. I hope this podcast never ends.
umpey
5 out of 5 stars
Great podcast, love the hosts!
This is by far my favorite podcast. So informational, entertaining. I have been listening since episode 1 and it is like a comfortable shoe. The hosts Paul and Amy are so great. Honestly couldn’t ask for better hosts.
Doeerick
5 out of 5 stars
Moonlight
Respectfully, don’t forget that Carol walked so that Mahershala could run. Moonlight shed its light on one male but woman have over the way for queer cinema
nuttermc
5 out of 5 stars
Great job
Paul and Amy do a great job of analyzing some of my favorite movies, and turn me on to some I’ve never seen. Don’t change a thing!
Creeperslayer123
3 out of 5 stars
3 Star
Good, but Amy is annoying. She gets hung up on the stupidest things. She’s also obviously biased, but she tries to hide it.
Violetkris
5 out of 5 stars
I love this podcast
I only recently discovered it, and really enjoy the conversations about movies that I’ve enjoyed. I had no idea there was so much to know about movies like “Little Shop of Horrors,” a personal favorite. And I enjoyed the discussion of “that scene” in Swingtime. I remember seeing that movie (not for the first time) in a theater in Cambridge, Mass, and feeling the silent discomfort emanating from the very white, bookish, liberal members of the audience. It’s hard to watch! Anyways, keep ‘em coming.
spoonpaul
4 out of 5 stars
Paul Scheer Ruins this Podcast
Look, I’m going to be honest here, I’ve listened to a lot of Unspooled and there is not a single episode that is not diminished, lessened, confused, or just plain ruined by Paul Scheer. I am sure he is a good person and this isn’t a personal attack, but I feel bad for Amy and all the Unspooled listeners that they have to wade through his deeply unconsidered and often borderline nonsensical comments. Amy is a film goddess and all stars are for her. I am well aware due to the two-person format of this show Paul will never be kicked off, but I guess I will just continue to do my best to fast forward through everything he says while fondly dreaming of a world in which Amy is paired with some other intelligent host that actually matches her.
Dink Trou
4 out of 5 stars
If Pauline Kael had a podcast with her 11 yr old son.
If you needed any more proof Scheer is on the intellectual JV team…
1 Maluga
5 out of 5 stars
Very Good
I love this podcast. Paul and Amy are a fantastic pair. I don’t always agree with Paul, but he is fun and insightful. I don’t always a agree with Amy, but she is smart and substantive and always makes me consider a new idea or perspective. Having been trapped in many boring, pointless, repetitive film conversations in my life, this podcast is a breath of fresh air—thoughtful, respectful, and original.
banalouz
5 out of 5 stars
Love the podcast!
I’m mostly here for horror season (aka the most magical time of year).
Y@Oo0O0o0o@o0OoO@O0oO0
5 out of 5 stars
Quentin Tarantino
Not sure what drug he was on, but I thought he was going to stroke out during his screeching and yelling.
kristineym
4 out of 5 stars
I keep coming back
I loved the Heroes & Villains summer series and enjoy listening to you both for hours. It’s not a perfect podcast and I can disagree with some opinions or want you to move on with something, but I keep coming back to how charming & enthusiastic you both are. And I love the year recap of when the movie came out!
WinstonTheWolf
3 out of 5 stars
Why so much political talk?
I love you, Paul and Amy and I really enjoy your podcast, but I can’t help but notice that more and more episodes feature politics. To be honest, I don’t listen to your podcast to hear about politics and current events when I listen to an episode on the dark night I don’t really feel like hearing about Trump and abortion laws, I’m more interested in hearing about the film and the deeper meanings, which have nothing to do with things that happened in 2020 or 2022.
TheWeeklyWorldNews
5 out of 5 stars
The. Best.
I can’t stress enough just how incredible this show is. Amy and Paul are fantastic. I love the content and deep dives they provide for each film they discuss. Be my best friends! :)
SpongeBobbyHil589
1 out of 5 stars
Unsplooged
Paul Sheer’s face is what you see when you look up the word cuckold. Still not the worst part of the podcast. That distinction would have to go to “film critic” Amy Nicholson whose contribution to the show could be done using a vocal fry dummy with a pull string repeating phrases misogyny, empowerment, racism. A wanna be Lisa Simpson, obnoxious know-it-all who gets it wrong, very wrong. Think more Meg Griffin. She infuses whatever NPC, woke virtue-signaling into the discussions that have little relevance to the film. Steadfast in her contradictions. Hipster film critic who shills movies that push agenda over actual craft or merit. Reeks of liberal elitism and completely out-of-touch. There's little reason to listen to the show, every opinion the hosts share is perdictable. While trying to appear a hipster contrarian nearly every opinion Amy shares is what you would expect to hear on any NPR program. A comedian who's not funny and never challenges the cohost and a film critic that biased and ignorant of films. How did This Get Made has some charm this has none.
jon111111111111111111
1 out of 5 stars
Unsplooged
Paul Sheer’s face is what you see when you look up the word cuckold. Still not the worst part of the podcast. That distinction would have to go to “film critic” Amy Nicholson whose contribution to the show could be done using a vocal fry dummy with a pull string repeating phrases misogyny, empowerment, racism. A wanna be Lisa Simpson, obnoxious know-it-all who gets it wrong, very wrong. Think more Meg Griffin. She infuses whatever NPC, woke virtue-signaling into the discussions that have little relevance to the film. Steadfast in her contradictions. Hipster film critic who shills movies that push agenda over actual craft or merit. Reeks of liberal elitism and completely out-of-touch. There's little reason to listen to the show, every opinion the hosts share is perdictable. While trying to appear a hipster contrarian nearly every opinion Amy shares is what you would expect to hear on any NPR program. A comedian who's not funny and never challenges the cohost and a film critic that biased and ignorant of films. How did This Get Made has some charm this has none.
Johnny Fuerte
5 out of 5 stars
3 musketeers sucked
I love this pod but the three musketeers as a movie is not funny and badly dated, the action doesn’t work at all. This movie put my friend to sleep. I wasted DVR space on this crappy waste of time. I loved the episode though it felt like Paul and Amy were scared to disagree with the convo bully Quentin
kwennitexikki
5 out of 5 stars
Good, but the ep with Tarantino was miserable!
Please don’t ever bring Tarantino back. He’s so loud and obnoxious. He constantly screams over everyone and strokes his own ego when it’s barely related to the topic at hand.
Muy Sharona
3 out of 5 stars
Dump Amy
Amy is a horrible man hating sexist. She constantly talks over Paul and complains.
Jeffrey Pamer
5 out of 5 stars
Amazing Podcast, no mor QT
QT is obviously a great film maker, but Christ on a cracker he’s obnoxious. I hate that he kept interrupting Amy and explaining why she was wrong. I hate that he have himself credit for movies split into two parts. I hate that he kept screaming into the microphone with not a single thought of what the experience would be like to listen to the actual product/podcast for us the little people. Love you Paul and Amy. I can’t get enough of Unspooled, and this episode can’t hurt your rating in my opinion. 😊
Okiedokiedokey
5 out of 5 stars
Tarantino is insufferable
Love the podcast but I will not be listening to Quentin Tarantino’s. He’s so annoying. He’s completely in love with himself and can’t wait to talk (or shriek) again. And anytime Amy said a word it was like he had to school her in literally anything/everything. The most obnoxious episode ever, which is a shame because the discussion of the film was interesting for the most part.
bostonstinx
4 out of 5 stars
No more QT
Great show. The Tarantino episode is unlistenable. Dude is screaming!
Jdibhe
3 out of 5 stars
Good but a little woke
Paul is great but Amy can’t help herself from throwing in some woke comment about every single movie
television apocalypse
5 out of 5 stars
one of my fave movie pods
i’m a huge fan of Paul and Amy!! they have really helped me see film in new and exciting ways. keep up the great work!
Prozizzle
2 out of 5 stars
Not for me
Good grief, how did THIS get made. Maybe add someone that can be critical without also pointing out a ton of stupid crap that doesn't even matter. It's not particularly funny, or witty, or worth taking so much time to discuss. Paul, why are you on this show? Your straight take on film is boring. Amy is boring. This is boring.
Yep... she did it again
5 out of 5 stars
Excellent Podcast!!!! (Also idk how to comment)
Such a good show, insightful conversations and reviews of the films, and funny hosts. (Also please review the 2004 film “Hotel Rwanda”)
hubristick
2 out of 5 stars
Like you better like the word “like”
Here is an example of any episode of this podcast “Like….like like like. LIKE like. Like like like like. Like like”. For 60 minutes. All spoken with vocal fry. The only part of the podcast where you’ll hear any other word is the ads.
Sandiegoamc
2 out of 5 stars
Amy = Negatibity
Really want to like this pod but often find it exhausting and dragged out by a consistent attitude of negativity/dislike of the films they watch. Every episode, I’m just waiting for the moment Amy shares her obscure critiques. Also, Amy… do you like/enjoy any of the movies you and Paul review? If you do like one, can you at least fake excitement/joy from it. Basically, I feel like Paul is a fun and outgoing critic/reviewer of movies who finds joy in the films, with fair criticisms, and good perspectives. Amy, on the other hand, feels like she majored in 14th Century French poetry (with a minor in 1900’s Italian silent films) and somehow ended up a film critic with little ability to relate to widely enjoyed popular, modern films. Paul, love you and your crew on HDTGM, but this seems beneath your style. Amy, maybe consider drinking some wine while watching a movie you review, chill out, stop looking for deep, negative sub-texts in movie plots that aren’t there. This pod is unfortunately a GRIND to get through. It needs to be more fun, less analytical, requires more energy and each episode trimmed in regards to length. Hope you both find the right recipe because there’s potential here. Good luck!
jtwork7
1 out of 5 stars
Get Paul a new co-host…
This is now the second podcast I have had to quit due to the incredibly annoying tone and cadence of Amy’s voice. It is so incredibly distracting. I briefly scrolled the other reviews here and it seems that so many others agree. Why aren’t they making a change? Paul, love you… stick to HDTGM until they find you a new co-host. What a shame that producers aren’t taking note. *shrug*
Historical insomniac
5 out of 5 stars
This podcast has enriched my life
Love this pair and their appreciation of movies. I’ve watched so many more, and more varieties of genres, just because they discussed them in a way that whetted my appetite. I enjoy movies more thanks to Amy & Paul. You guys are wonderful.
War-mariachi
5 out of 5 stars
First time reviewer, long time listener.
Been a fan since episode 1. Love when Paul and Amy bring their own interpretations and surprise the other with it, making the conversation about the film(s) more than that of being right or wrong, or it’s good or bad. And as always, great to discover new films to see.
lucasjlgjlg
5 out of 5 stars
I could listen to Amy all day
Some of these reviews are pathetic. Amy is an articulate and original voice always giving fresh perspective on movies and the movie business. I dare say that no one would get annoyed at listening to her speak unless they are annoyed that the words are being said by a woman. So, if you find yourself listening to women in your daily life while also remaining calm, then you will like this podcast
infinitefinite
3 out of 5 stars
we live in a culture
can there be one episode without mentioning tarantino please.
Mallylock16
3 out of 5 stars
Amy you had one job to do!
SPIDER PIG SPIDER PIG Does whatever a SPIDER PIG does Can he swing From a web No he cant He's a pig LOOK OOOUUUTTT!!!! He is a SPIDER PIG!!
Jewman23
5 out of 5 stars
Amazing content
For any movie buffs out there this show will scratch that itch and allow you to listen to two wonderful people review some of the all time greats
wtfnicknamenonsense
5 out of 5 stars
Best show ever
I love your thoughtful, intelligent analyses. These bad comments are from idiots. Sorry they didn’t review any steven seagull movies and that you had to listen to a smart woman review amazing movies. Keep doing what doing the good work, Amy & Paul, I love your show.
Indiana jrd
5 out of 5 stars
Fun show
I’m not a robot, just regular human looking for a light, but interesting and thoughtful, show.
Millie Rock.
1 out of 5 stars
TERRIBLE
ed to think Amy was terrible - eliminate “non-woke” “non-PC” films by male directors - and she still stinks. Paul it turns out us just a weakling who caves
freshtalent
1 out of 5 stars
Amy’s Goodfellas review was a downer
Amy’s view on Goodfellas threw me off this podcast... listen for yourself. Wet blanket. I understand everyone’s tastes are different, but kinda difficult to keep listening to reviews from her. Reading the comments, I see quite a few people think similarly.
Bryan VanCampen
5 out of 5 stars
Suggestion
Please Paul and Amy, do an episode on “Yellow Submarine”!
Remus_1986
2 out of 5 stars
Paul is fun
Paul is the high point of this podcast. Amy is not enjoyable to listen to.
tomatojonez
5 out of 5 stars
Hate to say it
Amy has terrible taste but I love this show
mariojr
1 out of 5 stars
Wow
This show is LOST. Completely and hopelessly lost. Just end it. You did the AFI list. It should have ended there. Please stop.
pryan144
5 out of 5 stars
A+
Best movie podcast out there
oldnonames
3 out of 5 stars
Bickering
Both have good opinions but every episode has at lease 20 minutes of Amy and Paul arguing about so dumb thing they cant agree on and it takes up the entire episode
Willythepitbull
2 out of 5 stars
“Like”
I dare anyone to attempt counting how many times Paul says “like”. Amy is just as bad. STOP SAYING “LIKE”!! They’re educated adults but you’d never know.
Willythepitbull
1 out of 5 stars
“Like”
I dare anyone to attempt counting how many times Paul says “like”. Amy is just as bad. STOP SAYING “LIKE”!! They’re educated adults but you’d never know.
beepboop12344
3 out of 5 stars
Okay
I like this show but I have to stop listening because Amy annoys me so much
JGLevi
4 out of 5 stars
Let Amy talk please
This show would be a lot better if Paul would stop interrupting and talking over Amy. She’s just a smart as you, Paul. Perhaps smarter.
DJ KDeezy
5 out of 5 stars
If you love movies
You’ll love this show. Amy brings the critic’s perspective and her fun wit. Paul brings the actor’s perspective and his HDTGM spin on things. I look forward to listening every week.
larking tods
3 out of 5 stars
Amy is unbearable
Listen to this podcast if you want to feel good about your ability to analyze a film. Amy has the most nonsensical opinions on movies that are often unsupported by facts. Her takes are baffling. I get the feeling she doesn’t actually watch the movies for the podcast but just tries to remember tidbits she may have picked up second hand.
No_peeking_69
2 out of 5 stars
Sometimes fun
I often find Amy’s critiques confusing. I don’t know if she is just trying to be contrarian, but some of her takes are very strange. A lot of these reviews mention her voice, but that is not something a person can control. She seems like a very well educated person who has a hard time relating to other people that haven’t had the same privilege has her in their upbringing. I still listen when the episode is a movie I like, but I find it so hard to relate when Amy turns the podcast into a high school debate/philosophy class.
Drizzle Dry
2 out of 5 stars
A mixed bag
There’s some good things and some not so good things about this podcast. On the positive side: I generally like Paul’s takes on a movie. And when Amy sticks to what is actually happening in the movie I generally enjoy her takes as well. The two hosts seem to have good chemistry and I don’t agree with other reviews that one is interrupting the other. On the negative side: on the majority of shows I have listened to Amy finds a way to force some kind of feminism or toxic masculinity subtext into apparently every movie ever made. They also have found ways to shoehorn politics in movie discussions. Give it a break. Overall the negative aspects keep me from subscribing and listening regularly.
anthkim
5 out of 5 stars
My Fave Movie Podcast
The part of me that wishes I’d gone to film school is totally satiated by this pod. I could listen to Amy and Paul talk about any movie!
Fan Since '69
4 out of 5 stars
Paul …
LET AMY SPEAK. Thank you.
AudioPhile116
2 out of 5 stars
Another Expert Woman shouted down by man w/no experience
I was so excited to find this podcast, especially one with a woman who is an expert in her field as part of the on air team. And I was extremely disappointed that she is constantly shouted down by a man with his rando opinions. He doesn’t even listen to her. It’s ridiculous. Do better!
JustinValentine
5 out of 5 stars
Love the show
I’ve been listening since the beginning, but recently I’ve noticed Paul starting to interrupt more and more and I wish he would just take a beat to listen instead of quickly coming back with a counterpoint that at least comes off like it’s half a thought. I think they both have great points but Paul tends to not really listen during sections when their point of view differs and cuts Amy off to make a rebuttal, it’s not always but it’s distracting when it occurs.
LoriASD
3 out of 5 stars
I want to love this
All my favourite movies. Love how they’re examined and broken down. I’m having a hard time listening though, because of the constant interrupting by Amy. I like her voice. Just wish she would wait for Paul to finish a thought.
Sibitron
5 out of 5 stars
Amy’s voice calms me.
After reading some mean reviews about Amy’s voice I had to write a review to say Amy, I find your voice soothing. I love listening because of your voice. There I said it.
ajlistening
3 out of 5 stars
I’ve tried but it’s a struggle
I feel bad but amy’s voice just gets under my skin. I think Paul cld prob do the show better even alone.
cmandolin81
5 out of 5 stars
Processing art to process life
Thank you Amy and Paul! I love your conversational dynamic. The show is made so interesting in part because of your differing perspectives. Another important part is that although you each have unique opinions, you’re great at listening to the other and being willing to try to see the other’s point. If you both agreed on everything the show wouldn’t be as rich and 3-dimensional as it is. You’re both great and this show helps me dive so much deeper into film as an art form and as a way to understand and process the complicated world around us. Thank you for going into the depths of these films: their history, how they were made, and your take on their significance. It makes watching and/or re-watching these movies a much richer experience.
maxwell stone
1 out of 5 stars
Amy…
Does Amy even enjoy watching movies? The concept of this is great. Paul has a clear love and enthusiasm for movies. Amy seems to take the modern approach of finding every classic overrated. Many of her opinions feel like virtue signaling. She’s a bummer and ruins the podcast. Paul should’ve done this with someone else.
TxGuerrero
5 out of 5 stars
5 Stars
Amy needs to get over Marvel/Disney movies, but other than that, 5 stars. Both Paul and AMY are amazing, so for those who are rude in the comment section, go pound sand!
burt winkler
2 out of 5 stars
Sorry Paul see you back at HDTGM
Cool show premise with one good host & one that makes it unlistenable. Amys overall attitude, cringeworthy voice & knack for shoehorning her feminist “trauma” angle into EVERY episode is unbearable. She’s an actual film critic outside of the show which is pretty surprising, this might just not be a format that compliments her skill set. Sorry Paul see you back at HDTGM.
littleman2712
3 out of 5 stars
Should be better
Cool idea but should be better. Amy is exhausting and not in a good way. She is generally negative towards these films. Luckily, Paul views these films with a wider lens and can find fun and interesting things to discuss.
Sausage czar
5 out of 5 stars
one of the most consistent podcasts in my rotation
solid debate and thoughtful review but palatable to the average movie goer.
Seedy Colleen
3 out of 5 stars
If you two don’t stop fighting...
I’m going to turn this car around and give up on this podcast all together. The bickering has become excessive. State your case and move on. I’m not taking sides...but it is notable that one is a professional critic. Always glad to see misogyny is still going strong. Your listeners are gross.
Ms Charlita
3 out of 5 stars
Tough to listen
Paul is amazing as usual. As others have mentioned, Amy’s vocal fry is nearly impossible to listen to. Do you guys listen to this after you record? I am a liberal, feminist woman but find Amy’s takes on almost everything to miss the mark to such a degree I can’t relate and listen any more because it’s so bad. She doesn’t seem to either have enough maturity or life experience (or both) to understand a lot of things happening in movies. Specifically relationships and their context. So her interpretation always seems VERY far off. It’s a shame since Paul has great insights to share.
MalintheBurgh
5 out of 5 stars
Interesting and fun
Two really smart people who clearly love movies and do their research. I always learn something, even if they are talking about a movie I’ve watched a million times.
cordiallyfuturedwight
2 out of 5 stars
Podcast has potential…
But I find Amy’s contributions to be distracting if not detracting from the experience. I can’t seem to finish an episode. Most recently I tried listening to the Jurassic park episode and her takes were just ridiculous. “Safety is overrated” “it’s ok to die in an amusement park because it’s fun!”. 🙄🙄 Amy is very narrow in her arguments and seems incapable of having nuanced discussions.
Kbaoba
1 out of 5 stars
I feel bad but I can’t stand Amy
Paul I love ya! You keep it fun and positive. Amy is a nightmare. I was a day one listener and I continued listening for a long time even though her voice is grating. Not her fault but she sounds fake and forced. And she is terrible at setting Paul up to give facts (they seem to have some conversation planned out ahead of time for that) now I listen sporadically but end up turning the show off halfway through. Amy is so negative! And about the strangest stuff. I feel like any popular movie she hates it. But she will let Paul talk about how great it is and then say really, you like it? And her reasons for something being bad are so far fetched I can’t get on board. If you want to listen to someone ruin a movie, listen to Amy.
stokedtiffytart
4 out of 5 stars
Stormcloud Sally
I have loved this podcast for awhile and seriously love a good debate! Paul is an awesome host and I love how he’s able to pivot and see all sides but still come out with a funny or positive wrap up. However…it has gotten to the point where I’m having to turn it off prematurely as of late because of Amy’s negativity. It’s a lot. She seems you genuinely have zero ability to find anything but the dark aspects of films she even claims to like. Please Amy, listen and maybe see that although it’s really easy to find flaws, it’s more interesting to find something good in something flawed. I don’t usually leave long reviews but as a creative (I make costumes for a living) I like to listen to podcasts between fittings and dance breaks and really want to keep y’all in my rotation. Best to you both and find some silver linings, Tiffy
Bowsersface
5 out of 5 stars
The people agree with Paul!
Love this podcast and all the movies you guys review!
T-Murda034
1 out of 5 stars
Love the idea, hate the execution
I love Paul and love the idea of going back through classic movies and putting a rating on them. Everything is so woke it’s ridiculous, I feel like no one can just appreciate classic movies, someone always has to be a victim. Amy's voice and all of her opinions are absurd, Paul is the only redeeming thing about this. I don’t always agree with him but at least he’s entertaining and sensible
annebananne🎃
1 out of 5 stars
Movie choices
I’ve been listening from the beginning and generally have enjoyed the conversations, especially around the AfI list. However, I’ve been really not enjoying their movie selection since then. I don’t really care enough about the hangover, the Christmas story, love actually etc. These aren’t good films and I don’t care.
Lanetrain11
5 out of 5 stars
Episode
I love the Christmas story episode but I have to definitely for the most part disagree with Paul and agree with Amy I would say that is a great movie and different ways but overall great podcast
Lanetrain11
4 out of 5 stars
Episode
I love the Christmas story episode but I have to definitely for the most part disagree with Paul and agree with Amy I would say that is a great movie and different ways but overall great podcast
EmilyTrivette1
5 out of 5 stars
Love it
Your analysis of Christmas Story was DEAD ON. Yay.
Ashmlong6
4 out of 5 stars
Love this podcast…except Amy’s voice *cringe*
Amy sounds like she’s faking her voice - I can’t explain it but it is seriously annoying! Otherwise, this is a good podcast and I always enjoy Paul!
bbFAN28
2 out of 5 stars
Love Paul. Don’t care for Amy’s analyses
An I the only one who thinks Amy is constantly flirting with Paul and he’s trying to ignore it? 😂
MrBW11
3 out of 5 stars
3 for Paul only, Amy has to go!
Love all that Paul has done, podcasts especially but Amy just ruins this one. Imagine if a screechy chalkboard developed vocal fry and spoke as if on a bad connection, THAT’S what she sounds like, just AWFUL! It’s worse when she’s reading , YIKES!! The show can really take off if there’s a new cohost, perhaps June?
MrBW11
1 out of 5 stars
3 for Paul only, Amy has to go!
Love all that Paul has done, podcasts especially but Amy just ruins this one. Imagine if a screechy chalkboard developed vocal fry and spoke as if on a bad connection, THAT’S what she sounds like, just AWFUL! It’s worse when she’s reading , YIKES!! The show can really take off if there’s a new cohost, perhaps June?
jmuscat63
2 out of 5 stars
Ugh, Amy, Love Paul
I’d give this show more stars if not for Amy. Please stop saying things as fact that are not true. Your understanding of old Hollywood is not as accurate as you seem to think it is. I enjoy Paul and his energy and enthusiasm.
HPFan543
5 out of 5 stars
Gender in The Graduate
Five stars for the overall show, but in case Amy reads this… I don’t care very much for The Graduate either. But in response to every comment you made about her “not having reasons” to be with Dustin Hoffman and that they suddenly “made her a monster,” she was a monster from the beginning. We established that in the first twenty minutes. If a man had manipulated someone into their home, stripped naked and refused to let them leave after countless times saying no and begging to be allowed to leave… he would be irredeemable from that point on. She is a sexual predator. Women can be those. Her reasons were control. Spouting off that there was “no reason” is problematic at best. Thank you for reading if you did.
akepford
1 out of 5 stars
Great content, terrible sound mixing
I had to stop listening because the volume of the show vs. the volume of the ‘ratcheting film’ transition noise and the ads is so out of whack. The transition noise and ads are SO LOUD they blow my ears to smithereens and it literally makes me jump.
JasonAZ
2 out of 5 stars
Flashes of fun
There are moments this podcast is amazing and brings out my love of movies. Then Amy comes around with her simplistic political takes. It is so frustrating because that is not what this is about or conversely she only does it in a forum like this where she can’t be challenged. McConnell is the person to blame for not addressing climate change in a podcast about Nightmare on Elm Street??? If you’re going to address a serious issue like climate change then actually take it seriously and comment about China and India otherwise it continues to make us look like political hacks and not on point with the issue. She comes off as so much in a bubble and a product of a society that is the only society around where someone like her can exist as she does. She can have some interesting takes that challenge the status quo and then blows it with ham handed political takes or blind gender takes. I take a month or two off from time to time because of this, but keep coming back because when it stays about movies there are few podcasts better.
AlexanderDaGr888
1 out of 5 stars
Waste of Paul
Amy is, without a doubt, the worst film critic in America. She can’t objectively judge a film, which is the primary requirement of her profession. Paul is great as always, and this would be a solid podcast with a different cohost.
Buzz McNabb
5 out of 5 stars
These people love movies
Great podcast from two pros who know their stuff. I love the facts and backstories sprinkled throughout their conversations without the usual lead up of “I read this article in XYZ magazine by blah blah writer in 1967 interviewing So and So movie star about the making of Such and Such movie about blah blah blah.”
DoubleRockBottom
3 out of 5 stars
Decent Podcast for Movie Buffs
I enjoyed it most when they were going over the AFI top 100. It seems the goalposts have changed for the show however. It went from let’s find the best 100 movies of all time to diversity is more important for the list than quality. They recently decided that Bridesmaids and Ganja and Hess should be on top 100 of all time while removing Jaws and Raiders. I enjoyed the movies but give me a break.
A runner guy
5 out of 5 stars
Mostly perfect
I’ve been listening to this show since about halfway through the AFI top 100 list. And you know what? It’s pretty great. Amy brings a thoughtful, nuanced, and yet balanced perspective to each discussion. Paul brings the levity and energy. I appreciate that neither are hesitant to share their honest reactions to these films. Sometimes I expect them to love a movie, but when they don’t, I learn how to be more critical and to expect more from the movies I watch. Sometimes I expect them to hate a film. But when they don’t, I learn how to see past my pretentious nit-picks and find value where I’d originally missed it. One concern: I’d prefer Paul not interrupt Amy as much. It makes some episodes hard to finish. I appreciate the opinions of both hosts, so it is upsetting when Paul completely cuts her off. Overall, it’s definitely my favorite movie podcast. Thanks to Paul and Amy for putting together a great show!
Brian McSatan
5 out of 5 stars
Top Five Podcasts
If you love movies, this is the gold standard movie podcast. In college I picked up a minor in cinema studies. Post graduation this show helps scratch that itch. Amy’s POV brings back memories of some of my favorite professors. I feel like I should be paying tuition for her insights. Paul is also great, he’s the enthusiastic film buff who you could talk to for hours after watching something new and exciting. If I were to offer constructive criticism of the show it would be sometimes Paul tends to interrupt Amy. I don’t think it’s conscious but it can be a bit of a let down when you know she’s on to something profound. Outside of that, this show is perfect. I really hope they do an episode on A Woman Under The Influence and The Grand Illusion at some point!
Evil Doctor
3 out of 5 stars
Amazing but…
Amazing podcast. But you need to drop Trump and stop taking about Trump. Trump doesn’t talk about you! Keep doing what you do with a little less politics. How does Trump have anything to do with Mad Max Fury Road? Just stop it…you’ll be happier and we can love your podcasts even more!
slocrates22
5 out of 5 stars
Do The Shinning!
Do The Shinning! 5 stars!
DanaMasters
5 out of 5 stars
Movie nerds unite
This podcast reminds me why I love movies. Paul and Amy are fans going through a film having fun and intelligent conversation. It’s a joy to listen.
RichardHand
2 out of 5 stars
Was really into it
But they're not very bright and it wore me down.
oliver mackie
5 out of 5 stars
Inception!!
LeonarDom DiCobbrio!
AdamfromEarth
5 out of 5 stars
I listen
“I don’t believe you have over 2000 episode…but I would listen to all of them” -@adamfromearth
mbbatz
3 out of 5 stars
The sense of discovery is gone
Remember when this show was about Paul discovering and Amy questioning minted classics? Now it’s mostly Paul lecturing about modern blockbusters while Amy struggles to get a word in. Boring.
rezlas
5 out of 5 stars
Engaging
Excellent deep deep dive into iconic films.
LAD311
2 out of 5 stars
come on
sad to give this one up. loved earlier episodes but i can't with amy anymore. lady english major here: it's gesture not guessture. no, it's not gesture because the "man" told you how to say it, there's no history of the patriarchy forcing us to say words a certain way. you don't sound intelligent. she threw shade on john krasinski recently for no reason at all and i realized how allergic i am to amy. get paul a better cohost that sometimes likes things. it's one thing to be critical, but she's a caricature of a feminist who uses movies to gatekeep what she approves of as feminism. i would love a movie podcast that unspools the making of, the trivia behind the scenes and dissection of great performances and other aspects that went into making these great films. it's okay to talk about movies that don't hold up but the show has turned into nothing but dissecting what makes beloved movies not so great.
Billmose
5 out of 5 stars
Great duo
I love the combo of these two!
TShaneRogers
2 out of 5 stars
Oof. Amy.
Amy is insufferably pretentious and I think the only reason I still listen to this podcast is to simmer in delicious hatred for her. Well played, podcast. For what it’s worth I’m a liberal feminist, but Amy makes me understand why they hate us.
Honey DOO
5 out of 5 stars
Just what I needed!
Normally I listen to true crime and I mean A LOT of true crime. I needed something to cater to my love of movies and my geeking out about behind the scenes info. Then I discovered Unspooled! I love Paul from his banter from VH-1’s “I Love” Series so I knew this was going to be good. I’ve only listened to a few episodes & I love every second of it. Paul & Amy have great onscreen (or on air?) chemistry, sounding like two buds just hanging out, talking about movies. I would love to hang with them. I love this podcast! Maybe consider doing a horror movie one with the classic Universal monsters?
easyguys
1 out of 5 stars
Ouch
The take on Hoosiers is really bad. Missed the point entirely.
RobertD27
5 out of 5 stars
Great discussions
Though I have been listening on and off since the start of the podcast focused around the AFI 100, this is my first review. From the start, I have enjoyed the differing perspectives that Amy (movie critic, journalist, woman) and Paul (actor, movie buff, man) bring to their discussions on specific movies. However, it feels like the newer (the most recent year of this podcast) format of picking genres and reviewing various movies for each has further elevated the conversations between these two hosts. For example, Amy blew my mind when she suggested we try to imagine a Spielberg-free movie world. (An amazing exercise.) And their takes on blockbuster movies has been fascinating. If you enjoy movies and talking/thinking about them, then this podcast is a must. Thank you Amy, Paul, and the Unspooled team. Robert
Coastal South Carolina
5 out of 5 stars
Paul and Amy - You’re the best!
I love movies - and this is my favorite podcast. Paul and Amy - witty and intelligent - are an excellent team and give great balance to the show. They have given me many insights into a ton of my favorite movies - thanks so much! I really look forward to “Unspooled” each week and would like to suggest three movies - “A River Runs Through It,” “The Prince of Tides,” and “The Accountant.” Keep up the great work!⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
killkorine
5 out of 5 stars
Titanic episode
Absolutely loved this episode, will listen to more. Unlike so many podcast hosts, they have soothing voices. Their take on Titanic was smart, informative and moving.
TravRichardson
1 out of 5 stars
Sad to leave
I’ve been a solid listener for years and have rolled my eyes at a few hateful comments but it has gone to far and I’m just tired of it and am unfollowing today. I wish it was just a great movie review podcast and not a chance to get they’re hateful comments out.
yh ooo
1 out of 5 stars
Amy
Hey Amy, just shut up. Stuff your liberal views in a sack. Shessh
HMC..
5 out of 5 stars
Wonderful
Enjoyable, entertaining, and extremely insightful.
Ks233
2 out of 5 stars
Meh
Amy is a bit of a know it all and while that works for her job as a critic, it makes for a frustrating time in listening to the conversation because it would be more fun when there is a little give and take. Or any kind of give in her case.
devinj70
5 out of 5 stars
Thank you Amy!!
I look forward to this podcast every week, even when I don’t like the movie! Paul is a great host, and I love his perspective as someone who is enthusiastic about all kinds of movies. The person I really have to thank, though, is Amy. Her critiques have challenged a lot of my own opinions and have made me a smarter (and I hope more sophisticated) watcher of movies. Having listened to nearly every episode of this podcast (I’ve skipped some of the horror ones that I’m too chicken to watch), I still find Amy’s takes to be fresh, and I’m always excited to hear her discussion with Paul. I don’t have a lot of friends who are interested in movies, and listening to this makes it feel like I’m part of a little movie club! It really helps broaden your film horizons - give it a listen!
Me2457788888888
3 out of 5 stars
Paul is good, Non-Paul is not
Oh boy, this podcast is exhausting thanks to Non-Paul. She takes the fun out of the every movie, like she’s writing a thesis on them. Paul on the other hand is light-hearted, open-minded, and down to have a fun time diving deep in these movies. When Paul speaks, it’s fresh and organic, but Non-Paul sounds so rehearsed and smug. It’s an odd pairing for sure. Replace Non-Paul with Casey Wilson and it would be dynamite.
buttamack
4 out of 5 stars
I love this show but…
This is an incredible podcast. Funny, insightful and all the good things, but every time Paul interrupts Amy in the middle of her dropping some knowledge I want to throw my phone
Kyle 1 Nov
1 out of 5 stars
The Searchers podcast review
The two hosts are obviously intelligent. But how are you going to express that “The Searchers” was not a game changer or very different right after admitting you had never seen a John Wayne or John Ford movie before it. If you haven’t seen Stage Coach or Red River before it, how would they know it was not a game changer with out context of previous westerns that were themselves game changers. Before Stage Coach, westerns we’re basically B movie/serials. It’s fine if you don’t like “The Searchers” but don’t give an expert review on it if you have bias of modern sensibilities with out seeing any Western before it. It’s like someone never having seen a movie before 1990 complaining that Wizard of Oz looks dated or moves slow. Both these movies existed many many years before I was born but I understand things like pacing, rear projection, acting styles are going to be different for various reasons in the 30’s and 50’s. I found the podcast angering. I probably would enjoy their episodes of more modern movies though. Review just of episode not podcast.
MrDanielX
4 out of 5 stars
If you love movies…
This is a fun podcast. I listen because I am a HDTGM fan and love Paul “Tall John” Sheer. Amy Nicholson has some hot takes that I disagree with frequently but she always explains them well. I am sometimes stunned by how many obvious things they miss or are mystified by which kills me sometimes. I yell at the podcast frequently lol. But I have watched all the AFI movies too and have strong takes and so I just love listening to people talk about movies even if it’s torture to not be part of the discussion.
PrinceHarming
3 out of 5 stars
Unsubscribing after two years
This show just isn’t what it used to be. Originally when they were going through the AFI 100 they would talk about the film they had watched, it was interesting and entertaining. Now Amy constantly (by constantly I mean several times each and every episode) compares the week’s movie to the Marvel movies. For a writer she almost never articulates her point well and is almost never factually correct. She calls out plot points that didn’t exists, misquotes dialog that didn’t happen. She is hellbent on comparing everything to this straw-man. I’m not some Marvel fanboy defending a billion dollar franchise that doesn’t need me to defend it. I’m annoyed that this is what every episode has become.
Chitown Jamie
2 out of 5 stars
Hate to Agree With the Conservatives, But…
When Amy is complaining about/poorly rating classics like Goodfellas and Taxi Driver for being ads for toxic masculinity, and rates the all female Ghost Busters much higher than the original one, she’s really lost all perspective and objectivity. She’s a smart, considerate reviewer (I started listening to her Cannon pc years ago), but very liberally biased and trying to cancel old movies she doesn’t agree with politically. It’s a problem and I think this is partly why they’re pushing Dischord.
Dannae42
5 out of 5 stars
Great way to get into the classics
This podcast has gotten me to watch and enjoy tons of films that I wouldn’t have otherwise, perfect companion to motivate you to watch these films!
chad bays
5 out of 5 stars
Paul is the best
I have never actually listened to this show but Paul is the best so I think I would like it-“five stars”
Steve de los Guantes
5 out of 5 stars
I said something negative about Amy’s (silly) words. Sorry Amy
Paul is great, he’s our ‘everyman’, and I love his takes on movies. While Amy is our real movie historian/reviewer and deserves respect despite what some hateful (anti-American) trolls claim her political ideas are driving her opinions, (as if we all don’t do that) but everything is politics really. When conservatives start pointing to SJW’s I wonder if they recognize their tolerance for fascism as thoroughly un-American as do most Americans. (it really is the majority opinion). If it weren’t for all the trolls in the reviews this would have the ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️’s it definitely deserves. Just go listen to OAN/Fox “News” and leave these American treasures alone.
dvfvsqvw
3 out of 5 stars
Amy’s voice
I came here to read reviews to see if othes have commented on Amy’s voice. I was not disappointed. It’s not just up-speak, there is something more going on. Like it sounds like she is putting on a fake voice. There is also some baby talk in there. It is very distracting from the content and I only listen when I’m desperate for content. Paul carries the show.
chadchadchadhooray
5 out of 5 stars
Love it
Love this show!!! Feel like I learn a lot!! Great chemistry between the hosts!!!
Case-bob
1 out of 5 stars
One star for Paul
The one star is for Paul. He is open minded, not completely ruled by his politics. As a result his takes feel more authentic and honest. Amy on the other hand… her very left liberal America hating politics OBVIOUSLY inform her every thought about movies as well as everything else. She had little real life experience outside of her bubble. She doesn’t “love” “marginalized” people, she just hates anyone and anything right of center. I wish Paul could do it on his own.
Amaritt
5 out of 5 stars
Alien.
This is the only place I can find to respond to Paul and Amy’s discussion about Alien. I was 21 years old and just about to graduate from college when I saw this film. I had majored in literature so of course knew all about rounded characters. None of that mattered when Sigourney Weaver triumphed in the end. A woman in her underwear piloting the space ship home, the sole survivor, the leader, the winner. Paul, I’m sorry, but you’re a man, and your preference for The Thing over Alien is just anti-woman. You really can’t understand the impact Ripley’s triumph had on every young woman I knew. The underwear was so important! The vulnerability was essential, but the type of underwear was a combination of blue collar and aspirational - only very slender women like Sigourney Weaver could pull that underwear off. Great podcast, btw!
Mikeystool
3 out of 5 stars
Amy yuck
I listen because I love movies, but Amy has so many issues with everything if it doesn’t meet her political views. Hollywood really should just keep their views and politics out of everything, they are losing fans. How can she judge a movie made many years ago, and put today’s over-woke views into her opinion of a film? I listen now only when it’s a favorite movie, she really is a turn off. They are gonna lose their audience with her attitude.
SayitaintLouis
5 out of 5 stars
Glad I finally listened to it!
Great show! Doesn’t make me feel like I enjoy all the wrong movies.
tmoney5959
3 out of 5 stars
How
I wonder if there is a contract that keeps Paul with Amy, her views are understood and justified but recently are just too overbearing with movies I enjoy. I understand the necessity of taking a modern look at old movies, but it’s to the point that this podcast is mostly Amy being negative and Paul defending the movie. Also, it’s harder to listen to a solely white perspective especially on movies such as Hoop Dreams, would be nice to have special guests or specialists on topics like that.
Heyooooobadyletsgoooi
5 out of 5 stars
Fav
An all-time favorite podcast. The pace and editing are perfect, the hosts are wonderful and come so prepared, and the podcast is both funny, interesting, and insightful.
Zombie River Phoenix
1 out of 5 stars
HDTGM without the humor.
These episodes are somehow longer than HDTGM episodes but with zero laughs because Amy is a wet blanket.
ChefFos
5 out of 5 stars
Great
Really great movie.
Thomp1380
3 out of 5 stars
Amy is way too bias and always brings political views
Leave the political views at home please. The show is amazing I want to hear about movies and the background but she is judge mental and always makes it about her we get it you are liberal. Be unbiased I do not listen to to the show to learn about your hate of trump and how you are a feminist and how everyone is a is male dominated.
The Joelest
4 out of 5 stars
Get some class
Love listening to this podcast. Great to hear two points of view, from a regular viewer to a critical. The differences are minor in the end. I admittedly don’t listen to every episode, only films that I’ve seen, it makes it more enjoyable; sorry, too many podcasts out there.
millie ruth rubin
1 out of 5 stars
Total garbage
Amy hates movies she considers masculine or “macho” - goodfellas / French connection/ apocalypse now etc- a bias that disqualifies reviewers
kmb352
5 out of 5 stars
Finally Someone Recognizes Carpet Sharks
Amy & Paul, you guys are fantastic! I love listening. I came to Unspooled a little late from How Did This Get Made and What Went Wrong, but I’m loving it. I particularly wanted to thank Amy for her recognition sharks’ ability to get into suburban bedrooms. I would not sleep with any covers after seeing several Jaws because I knew the sharks were in my bedding. I love sharks. I’ve been a diver for 25 years and actively seek out sharks all over the world, but bedroom sharks are not okay. Also, I’d put Jaws 3D slightly about Jaws The Revenge, but agree that Jaws 2 was terrible.
GalwayK1963
2 out of 5 stars
If you like people who say like
You’ll like this more than I do. It’s too inconsistent . And often just factually incorrect. Did that dude say ‘71 was set in Dublin. You’re history is off spud.
SammDuh
5 out of 5 stars
Love the podcast
Amy and Paul you two are great. Can you have an episode where Paul makes Amy laugh. I just love her laugh. Keep up the great work.
Rogermaria25
5 out of 5 stars
I love your Podcast
First this is not a criticism I love listening to you guys talk movies but I’ve avoided the last couple of movies the picks have not been the best. I wish you would pick more classic movies compared to movies you wish were classic! Again you guys are great just some better variety of movies not just movies of the 90s
Pepibob
2 out of 5 stars
Wow!!!
What a fantastic podcast! A fascinating topic, two intelligent and fun podcasters who work seamlessly with each other, excellent sound quality, informative and interesting guests, and quirky interactions with listeners. Even when I disagree, I still enjoy myself. Sometimes I learn something, sometimes I agree, and sometimes I yell at you guys for being so off base. Doesn’t matter, it’s all entertaining. I just discovered this podcast two weeks ago and I am beyond excited that there are a million episodes just waiting for me to get to. Do I go in order? Do I pick out my favorite movies first? Yes, please. Great job, you guys. I love it!
Pepibob
5 out of 5 stars
Wow!!!
What a fantastic podcast! A fascinating topic, two intelligent and fun podcasters who work seamlessly with each other, excellent sound quality, informative and interesting guests, and quirky interactions with listeners. Even when I disagree, I still enjoy myself. Sometimes I learn something, sometimes I agree, and sometimes I yell at you guys for being so off base. Doesn’t matter, it’s all entertaining. I just discovered this podcast two weeks ago and I am beyond excited that there are a million episodes just waiting for me to get to. Do I go in order? Do I pick out my favorite movies first? Yes, please. Great job, you guys. I love it!
sarah stop
4 out of 5 stars
Amy?!
Amy, who insists on pointing out all of the “problematic” behaviors of countless male directors from decades ago, said that she adores Gloria Grahame....who raped her 13 year old stepson. Amy needs some serious help. Can anyone explain this? Did I mishear Amy?
Dlux125644
1 out of 5 stars
She’s finally driven me away.
The constant up speak and tirelessly forced political agenda wore on me. I thought it was just me, but it appears I am clearly not the only one. The deep library of movies to dive into and Paul’s personality made it hard to drop the show, but Amy has finally out done herself with the Hoosiers episode. Paul, you deserve better.
Chi-town Cinephile
5 out of 5 stars
Awesome
Love this show.
Mike G in Dover,DE
5 out of 5 stars
Love the banter and insight!
Just started listening and currently am working my way through the AFI 100 list along with Paul and Amy. This has become my favorite podcast, and I actually lol’d at their discord about Jack Warner judging films on how many times he would pee, never laughed so hard. Paul and Amy not only give their thoughts but also bring in great research and stories along with great special guests. Cannot wait to finish a movie on the list to listen to another episode!
Alba Varden
3 out of 5 stars
Solid movie podcast
I enjoyed this for most of season 1 and drifted away during season 2. Listening to Amy just started becoming more and more of a chore.
Janedeau
5 out of 5 stars
One of my favorite podcasts
My husband and I started by watching the movies from the AFI that we had always wanted to see and then listening to the podcast. Then we decided to just start from the beginning and listen to them all in the order that Paul and Amy were listening. We have now seen 81 of the Top 100 and some of the other films Paul and Amy have done after the AFI list.
100lincolns
5 out of 5 stars
Fav
My absolute favorite podcast hands down and I've been around the podcast block a time or two
tugboattugboat
4 out of 5 stars
I do love Paul!
Love everything Paul does. I gotta unsub though. I cannot take anymore of Amy’s voice. Amy, I’m sorry. I’m sure you’re a wonderful person. Paul, I love you! See you on HDTGM.
servicemax user
5 out of 5 stars
Great podcast
Entertaining and likable hosts, interesting discussions on great films.
AgathePercyMortimer
5 out of 5 stars
Informal but informed, and fun
I am liking that show. The 2 hosts have a good flow in their friendly discussion, they do not speak over each other, and they play interesting sound clips from the movies they discuss or experts they researched. Even if they make occasional errors or might have different opinions on the movies that me, they bring up great points into their reviews. And the sound of their voices is quite pleasant. I am really happy with that podcast!
IForgotToPutInTheCrystals
1 out of 5 stars
Painful
The wokeness is unbearable. Paul gets every detail wrong (e.g. , Lady "Evelyn" from Mr. Rogers) and mispronounces normal words. Amy doesn't like Richard Linklater because his movies are too much from a "dude's" point of view. Social justice ruins this podcast, as it does everything. I enjoy hate-listening to this just for Paul's barely comprehensible perversion of like, you know, the English language. He should sue his English teachers. Amy is allegedly a movie critic but she doesn't know how to say Palme d'Or. Sad!
WrigleyFieldMarshal
1 out of 5 stars
Ditch the Bad Politics
This podcast has some potential but gets marred by the typical liberal tendency to through everything through the distorted lens of the left.
Meha1232332443
3 out of 5 stars
So much potential
As usual Paul is great. I struggle with episodes that have too much Amy. I think this podcast would be five stars if they had a third cohost to temper Amy (who provides great insight sometimes, but can be overwhelming with too much time)
Joesgonepostal
1 out of 5 stars
Really political?
Really be nice if at times you wouldn’t bring politics into reviewing movies. I can go on but I’m not. I’m unsubscribing.
J. Steven
3 out of 5 stars
Enthusiastic
Mistake-ridden and little understanding of history, yet wide-eyed enthusiasm and a fresh take make this podcast worth listening to despite the cringes. quote from one of the hosts: "just like a reese's peanut butter cup, there is no wrong way to view this film." ummm. Full of "like" "you know" and "yeah I mean" filler. 20% shorter podcast if they leave out the verbal filler.
demokat
5 out of 5 stars
Thank you
This is a go to podcast for me. I love the chemistry between the two of you. Thank you for guiding me towards movies I might not otherwise watch.
Christina1832
3 out of 5 stars
Pretty good
I like listening to this pod after watching a movie I’ve never seen before, and will continue to do so. However, I do tire of Amy Nicholson having hot takes for the sake of *unique*. For example, the Goodfellas episode in which she belabors Pesci’s age and the brother ad nauseum. There are tons of other episodes in which this occurs, but it is at its most irritating in that episode.
Robert_Roy
5 out of 5 stars
Best Movie Pod But ...
Incredible to me the films Paul and/or Amy hadn’t seen prior to the watch. (Forget re-watch.) On The Waterfront. The Best Years of Their Lives. The General. Still, it’s a very good movie podcast. The best. So much better than The ReWatchables with its snarky hosts and guests.
AmyNicholsonSucks
1 out of 5 stars
Get Paul a new co-host
Amy Nicholson is inept and out of touch. It’s incredible Paul has so patience with her horrendous takes. Get someone else in here so we can enjoy the films with Paul
Hobes44
5 out of 5 stars
Thoroughly Engaging
Amy and Paul really put a lot of thought and effort into each episode. I don’t always agree with their opinions but their explanations are well reasoned and articulated. It’s just the right length for doing a deep dive (but not too deep) into a single film. I was slightly skeptical on if they could continue after season 1 but their approach to season 2 has been fresh and engaging.
Bleen420
5 out of 5 stars
Great for film lovers
Interesting conversation and they bring up a lot of good points that sometimes are not considered. All with a friendly quality that draws you into the conversation personally. And they have some excellent interviews. It’s inspired my girlfriend and I to go through the list as well, rolling the die for each film. For me it’s a return to movies I haven’t seen in 20 years or more sometimes, for her they’re almost all new. And this podcast ties it together nicely for us both.
Triviawiz3000
1 out of 5 stars
Meh
The girl very cleverly says foxnewsian...over and and over again. Government approved jibber jabber.
cw1520
1 out of 5 stars
Movies not politics
Movies, not politics. Let me say it again. Movies. Not politics. Just one more time, movies, NOT politics
Stuart13342
5 out of 5 stars
One of my favorite movie podcasts
Thorough reviews that provide great context and analysis to amazing films.
Red-haired Hawk
5 out of 5 stars
This podcast has been such a joy since it launched
When I heard Amy Nicholson say on the /Filmcast that she and Paul share were starting this podcast, I knew I had to subscribe immediately. It has been a huge joy these last 2 1/2 years. When the show started there were about 15 of the AFI top 100 movies I have never seen, and it had been many years since I had seen some of them. Thanks to the show, it gave me extra motivation to finally get around to those I had never seen and rewatch son I hadn’t watched in 10 or 20 years. This motivation was especially important for my blind spots, namely silent films. I am the type of person whose friends and family assume has seen just about everything, but even the new season of modern classics is proving there are still plenty that I haven’t gotten around to.
Glamwalls
3 out of 5 stars
Cannot access older episodes
I was trying to work my way through the top 100 but suddenly cannot access anything older. Tried on two different platforms. What gives?
Pizza-Man-2020
5 out of 5 stars
The Movie Pod I’ve Been Waiting For
I love movie podcasts, but most are about Marvel, Star Wars or other big franchises. This podcast really focuses on more artistic and classic films, which is what I’ve been waiting for! Both host have a great balance of opinions and taste. Fantastic movie debate! Can’t recommend this more. Paul Scheer is the podcast king!
RoeLuv
5 out of 5 stars
Awesome
Amy & Paul are so fun to listen to
AFedorov
5 out of 5 stars
If You Love Movies...
Paul and Amy have done a great job breaking down the AFI’s top 100 films of all time in Season 1 of Unspooled. Now in Season 2, they’re exploring a bunch of movies from a variety of genres to see if any should be considered for the top 100. The level of detail and depth they get into around some of the most beloved movies of all time is always fascinating. It’s made me seek out a ton of older movies I might not have seen otherwise and I’m grateful for that.
cassidy525
3 out of 5 stars
It’s good/ok.
I am obsessed with movies and love to hear people discussing them. The FB community is great! The problem is this- Paul is a solid critical thinker. He definitely knows how to take the conversion to a deeper level. Amy misses it somehow. She constantly blows off his insights and can’t seem to make those connections on a deeper analytical level. She can recite facts and tidbits about the productions but doesn’t add any psychological analysis about the meaning of the content in relation to art, the artist, and the world. I think Paul would be matched with a better, more self aware, and insightful host.
RoketZer0
5 out of 5 stars
Two Thumbs Up
Love this podcast so much! Amy and Paul provide incredible insights and analysis into many of my favorite films!
bito4
5 out of 5 stars
Unspooled Rocks!
Just the best! Love making a watchlist based on the movies they talk about that I haven’t yet seen.
jessarama
5 out of 5 stars
Movies
Enjoying this season even more then AFi season . Even when I disagree, I love their pure love of good movies with enthusiasm but no snobbery
produceus
5 out of 5 stars
Fun and Thoughtful
I enjoy Amy and Paul’s style. Creating ranked lists can be weird and arbitrary, but this podcast takes the idea and makes it more about critical appraisal than gatekeeping. Pairing a creator and a critic for this project makes for interesting dialogs in each episode.
All Nicknames Taken227726
3 out of 5 stars
Couldn’t finish the podcast
In theory this should be a podcast that I would love. It’s just that the inflection of Amy Nicholson’s voice was too much to handle. Her commentary was interesting but I’d rather read it.
fourvel
1 out of 5 stars
start with gone with the wind
that’s where i stopped! amy is fully fooled by the confederacy’s PR. paul seems to know better, but can’t find a way to correct her??? i hope that she has come around to the american side by now
DonkBonkers
3 out of 5 stars
Wish I Could Give More Stars
The discussing of whatever movie they are doing is five star work. Going through the list I’ve found movies that I like that I never would have seen before. And I’ve found movies that I love but have learned to appreciate even more. I enjoy the show a lot. However, their constant need to be “woke” and their constant liberal dissertation is just too much. They make way too many Trump jokes and they are always asking about the political correctness of a subject. If they would be a little more impartial or totally omit their politics and their need to be “woke” this podcast would be a five star one-no doubt. I go with three stars just because of all the stuff they ram into their movie discussion.
Atticus25
5 out of 5 stars
An honest, thoughtful take on movies.
Amy & Paul have great chemistry, which results in honest, unpredictable reviews. I don’t always agree with their views (I’m lookin’ mostly at you, Amy), but I always appreciate their perspective. There’s always a healthy amount of trivia, history, and background to keep things interesting. Oh, and the interviews are always fun. Great job, P & A!
kyrojack
3 out of 5 stars
Waning Interest
I loved this show at the start through about episode 75. The endless politically driven comments wore me down. It’s an awesome concept but it’s clear that a lot of the commentary is from a first watch and a quick google search.
Professor Underhill
4 out of 5 stars
Love it!
Great show!
cubanita#1
2 out of 5 stars
Immature
I liked this show at first and then it became clear that their lack of collective knowledge of film is a serious problem. Their diction is lazy and atrocious. “Like” and “sort of” are not acceptable in every other sentence. It’s maddening.
Teej1974
5 out of 5 stars
Great!
Best movie podcast out there
Ella Saint Claire
3 out of 5 stars
The Good, The Bad, and The Unspooled
I really loved this podcast in the early days. As it went on it lost some of its wonder and honesty. The hosts are great and often have differing opinions. But by the end it just kind of fizzled, which was really sad. The King Kong episode and The African Queen are gems. The second season I gave a listen to and sadly, I wasn’t thrilled. I’ll give a few more listens here and there. Overall, listen to the early episodes especially movies you haven’t seen or want to see.
scottt2017
1 out of 5 stars
Lame
They are ignorant. Total leftist. They have zero knowledge of the films the actors they are talking about.
siebricjw
3 out of 5 stars
More Paul less Amy
Paul is fantastic, very positive, and upbeat. Amy has gotten worse as the show has gone on. She is way too pessimistic and makes it way too personal, be a critic and not a troll Amy.
Penny Lane Productions
5 out of 5 stars
Speaks to my heart
Film fanatic and I love all the tidbits of info!
Jess Sayen
5 out of 5 stars
The Citizen Cane of Movie Podcasts!
You guys rock! Loved the first season. I like that you’re not restricted to a formula this time around and are pushing creative boundaries much like the directors that you admire. I can already tell S2 will be better than the original. Just like Aliens and Road Warrior. Thank you Amy and Paul for an epic podcast.
Allaboutkelli
5 out of 5 stars
Fave Movie Pod
I love Unspooled so much and was getting anxiety when the end of the AFI was approaching so thank you so much for giving us a season 2!! Can't wait for more after how good the Mean Girls episode was!!
Combaticus83
2 out of 5 stars
It’s ok
This is a pretty standard review show. Kinda gets old with the woke messages thrown around. Sometimes you just wanna hear a Godzilla review without being preached at by the woke left. Oh well. How did this get made is still a banger.
Chloe from SLC
5 out of 5 stars
So Very Enjoyable
Feels like hanging out with good friends discussing movies. This podcast has been so calming and comforting for me, and Paul and Amy do such a fantastic job covering these films!
Alyson Von
5 out of 5 stars
Love It
Amy Nicholson is my favorite film critic... her podcasts covering the history of Halloween & Quentin Tarantino are also some of my favorites. This podcast is no exception, I can’t wait to hear more.
MichaC23
2 out of 5 stars
The black panther discussion was a yuck for me
I dipped my toe in by listening to the 2018 blockbusters podcast. The Black Panther part and was pretty disappointing. It’s one thing to not like a movie or a genre of movies but to confuse U not liking it with some sort of mass delusion is not it. one of the hosts suggests that BP killed at the box office because audiences want to root for diversity. And that in 4 years we’ll all look back and say it wasn’t that good. Speak for yourself. Black people are not that starved for entertainment that we have to pretend to like things. It was actually a good movie, yeesh. Coogler has made 2 critically acclaimed populist movies in a row and that wasn’t because he took advantage of white guilt etc etc... really annoyed me hearing their discussion dismiss the work because the cgi was bad at the end.
Make it functional
2 out of 5 stars
Seriously? That’s it?
For almost two years we have listened to a podcast that claimed to re-evaluate the afi top 100, and after all of that we got a finale show that covered a few movies and served to make room for the next season of the show. Where is a final discussion of the top 100? The two of you didn’t even use the same system to review the final movies. Paul didn’t even put his in order. Top 10 and bottom 10? On off maybe? I can’t believe you guys phoned in the culmination of two years of work and audience attention. This was the most disappointing final episode I could imagine. You’ve invented season two. Cool. But why didn’t you give the first hundred and respect and due diligence they deserved. You’ve given up on the listener to make this podcast about you, don’t be surprised when we give up too.
JordanMuschler
5 out of 5 stars
Most criticisms of this podcast are very banal
A few reviews in here disparage this show because Amy views watching films from a personal lens. They also act as if the two hosts are overly woke and disparage anything problematic. I strongly disagree with both of these points: Amy’s personal experience with films is exactly what criticism is, and she acknowledges when a film has baggage for her that is mostly unrelated to the film. More than that, her criticisms are often interesting and detailed, well-explained and thought-provoking. It’s so upsetting to me to see that people dismiss this when it’s their favorite film being talked about (most reviews mention Goodfellas). You can still love that film, and any of these other ones; she brings a unique perspective to it that I appreciate. The “overly woke” criticism is just absurd to me as well. We are talking about some films that were made nearly a century ago. They age. Some age better than others. We are allowed to talk about what hasn’t aged nearly as well, and they do so because that should be part of the discussion. If they were being overly woke, they would dismiss Roman Polanski and Charlie Chaplin films immediately, but they go quite in-depth towards what has made these films beloved. I love what they’re doing, and I can’t wait for more.
Thabizness714
2 out of 5 stars
Tried to enjoy it but Amy ruins it
Amy’s political diatribes each episode have worn me down and I’ve unsubscribed. There are some gems of insight in each episode but it is drowned out by the neoliberal lenses that Amy analyzes each movie with - it’s okay to acknowledge these things but it shouldn’t be the basis of your critique.
hyperberry
1 out of 5 stars
Could She Be Any More Condescending?
I guess this woman has figured out the secret to perfect morality and can righteously judge everyone in the world according to her standards. Maybe we should elect her to be the next Pope? Or maybe the next Dalai Lama? Her exhausting pretentious condescension is NOT the experience I want when listening to a podcast about film. Ugh.
SingItBack
5 out of 5 stars
Wonderful
I’m so excited they’re going to keep going after finishing AFI. Paul and Amy are wonderful and they’ve created a fantastic podcast. I’ve loved every episode.
IncTime.
2 out of 5 stars
Amateur Hour
This is clearly discussed and maybe scripted before recording and then they try so hard to make it sound like they’re having a normal conversation. Would be better to just have bullet points and allow the discussion to flow, but everything is mapped out and they have to feign surprise that the other person brought something up. I know a lot of NPR podcasts do it this way but you don't hear it being so stiff.
Dulcinea14tx
5 out of 5 stars
My favorite movie podcast
I love their knowledge of movies, wow! They are a great team, funny and insightful and not afraid to debate the merits of each film
toneE2timz
3 out of 5 stars
Goodfellas
Amy’s arguments for this movie are so maddening her point of views are just plain stupid the whole thing about tommy and the thing about his brother watch the movie 160 times like I have you idiot
Josiesgirrl
4 out of 5 stars
Casablanca
I just wanted to say that I was listening to the last episode and when Paul said he had never seen Casablanca both Amy and I gasped at the same time. Great podcast, have enjoyed listening to them. I am eager to see what they work on next. They can be a little long sometimes.
Christianwalkersd
1 out of 5 stars
Not Good Enough to Overlook Annoying Moments
I like the concept of this show better than the execution. Pick and choose the episodes you listen to, I guess. Some are fun and engaging, even in spite of Amy’s weird personality/annoying tendencies, and Paul’s lack of willingness to go deep on interesting things she brings up. Sometimes her level of insight and his level of charm are able to outshine these flaws. Usually (and especially in the Goodfellas episode) they are not. Stopped following because the hosts’ annoying tendencies just grated on my nerves too much.
Old TAL G
4 out of 5 stars
Insight and fun
Love this podcast. The hosts make me rethink these movies, most of which I’ve seen, from a new perspective. The only disappointing part is the AFI list has no female directed movies and only one movie (?) from a black director. So the list is a mostly complied of films about the Boomer/Gen X heterosexual white American male experience. I’m a Gen X and was surprised how limited the scope of films is. But I’m listening to the entire podcast primarily for the insights of the hosts. I hope they do another pod with the films that they love.
jlo12th
4 out of 5 stars
Goodfellas ep is great
Getting a debate about an overrated classic is what makes this one great. Finally someone brings the truth about this movie. 3rd act is trash!
shanethetoiletpaperking
1 out of 5 stars
Amy Nicholson needs a voice coach
The way she speaks makes it hard to listen and when she makes attempts at humor... that also makes it hard to listen to. Other than that the show is a solid C+
9thWardOJ
1 out of 5 stars
spoiled Lost
Why? Why when Im listening to a movie review that has nothing to do with Lost do you feel the need to spoil the whole series. Ive lost all interest in further episodes. You sir, are a major jerk.
areview2018
4 out of 5 stars
Goodfellas
The Goodfellas episode is poor. I like most episodes but that one is really bad. Skip that one. I am not sure why that is the movie that they picked to analyze every detail of and not the others.
fan o disney
3 out of 5 stars
Mixed Bag - like it sometimes
I can appreciate an actor and a journalist coming together for this podcast. Some episodes I really like “To Kill a Mockingbird’ and some made me a bit annoyed “Philadelphia Story” ( on and on and on about Jimmy Stewart’s “manhood “) yes I’m older, in my 50s but I can’t stand when Amy reviews things with the lens of the 21st century - the films are on the list partly because they are a snapshot in time - I say pick and chose the episodes - some I just skip
Tunbaqc
2 out of 5 stars
AMY BROKE ME
I’ve been a fan and regular listener to this pod since episode one, but the last few months have just worn me down. Maybe Amy should have a separate podcast where she exclusively nitpicks pointless minutiae and complains about ex-boyfriends ruining films and pop culture for her. Then Unspooled can get back to being a podcast about the AFI 100 list? Taking a break, I just can’t anymore.
mcpotter
2 out of 5 stars
Holy mansplaining wow
I tried listening for the first time and started with Bladerunner because it’s one of my favorite movies. I started getting annoyed quickly because it seemed like Paul was more concerned with being “right” in his points and argument than having a nuanced discussion with differing viewpoints about a rather polarizing film. Paul would speak, then Amy would offer her opinion on the same point, but Paul was unable to do the same with Amy. When she would speak, he had to counter, and frequently interrupt, her. She was explaining why she preferred one director’s style over Scott’s and Paul disagreed but could not let it go then derailed the episode because he had to be right. Then when Amy said she thought Deckard was a human and said why, he interrupted her AGAIN and said, “but see that proves me right!” It’s not about being right, this is a podcast with the intention to discuss movies. Amy understands this well; Paul does not.
Yogayoga123
5 out of 5 stars
So smart!
I am so thankful I found this podcast! We have started watching a lot of older movies in quar and we always look forward to listening to Unspooled’s point of view. We always learn something new and it always sparks conversation!
Smalls99
1 out of 5 stars
Get rid of Amy and it would be better
Amy is the worst. Just so bad. And just such a bad understanding of so many films. She ruins the show.
DB Cooper 73
1 out of 5 stars
So woke
If you feel guilty about liking old movies, but can’t articulate why, this is the show for you. Every week, Paul and Amy spend the bulk of the show explaining how a so-called “Classic” movie is actually problematic. Often, that’s just because the director isn’t as “representative” as one of the great diverse directors of the 1920s-80s, but that’s a good enough reason to dump on the movie!! The longer the series goes, the dumber the conversation goes. Movies need to be added to the AFI list for their politics, not their artistic merit or cultural impact. Trigger warning: Sometimes the hosts actually like the movie they discuss. Beware.
Anthony Giancola
3 out of 5 stars
How Did This Get Made?
That’s the name of the other podcast everyone keeps referencing. Seeing as how they struggle to type the whole thing out I figured I’d let you know. I’ve listened to a lot of episodes and here is my main criticism. I know we can’t abandon our experiences, but in a critical context it’s frustrating when a film critic brings all their baggage into a movie. I guess it boils down to “what are we talking about” when it comes to the film. Are we analyzing the filmmaking? What the context is? Our relationship to it? It’s a tricky line to tow and I’m not gonna act like there’s any way for film critics to always have a perfect analysis. I don’t want this to be bashing Amy, because I think a lot of detractors are bothered that she doesn’t like their favorite movies. However, there’s a reality to the criticism that she comes into a movie with her slant already with a predisposition to dislike films that are male oriented, politically incorrect, or ones that she has had bad experiences with in the past. And I’m not gonna act like there isn’t something totally valid in that: I’m a guy and I find it a little hard to really access what people like about Steel Magnolias, and I don’t care how good it is, my only memories of Ben Hur are being forced to watch it in class with my teacher running a commentary through it the whole time. But here’s the thing: if I’m asked to give my critical analysis on the films, I’m going to single out the performances, the filmmaking, and the flow of story. Not focus on my lived experiences with it. Paul is far from perfect, I mean sometimes I feel like he wants every film to be either a comedy or an action film. He’s probably one of those people who swears T2 is the most masterful film he’s ever seen. However, even with films he dislikes (Forrest Gump is a good example) he still approaches it from a perspective of “how is this movie as a piece of filmmaking and cinema history” and I just don’t think Amy cares if the movie is not a reinforcement of her worldview.
john bananas
5 out of 5 stars
Awesome!
Love the podcast!! Thank you so much for doing this!!! Amazing journey through film.
Xxdythra
1 out of 5 stars
Pesci is old
We get it. Had to stop listening after she brought it up 8 times. Unfollowed.
Ken.Foster1
2 out of 5 stars
Struggling to still enjoy...
I’ve been tuned in since Ep 1, and I’ve had mixed feelings along the way. Even stopped listening for months because I was losing tolerance. I didn’t want to sound misogynistic & pile on Amy as it seems many male reviewers have. It wasn’t until this Bladerunner chat that the subtext clicked for me: Paul comes at most of these movies anew, or renewed, or with nostalgic enthusiasm and seems to have an open experience. But Amy seems to always approach the films with prejudice, agenda, and disdain. And when she described “all my ex-boyfriends” making her watch Bladerunner (“it’s my favorite movie”) it all clicked. Yes, she’s woke & wants us all to know. Yes, she’s feminist (and I try to be also). And yes, she brings an underlying amount of baggage to each movie - like there’s an axe to grind & she finally has her forum. That, mixed with things like constantly praising the god-awful dreck that is “Titanic” & similar, makes it difficult to listen. I only choose episodes for movies I’ve already seen - not for plot spoilers, but to avoid slant spoilers - and those get harder & harder to sit thru. Still a fan, but waning... Def Team Paul.
@KidNamedCorey
4 out of 5 stars
Paul is great
Just pretend that Amy means the exact opposite of everything she says in this podcast. Then you can listen without losing brain cells.
SSSBJr
1 out of 5 stars
Enough
Love this pod but the Goodfellas episode is very tough to listen to. It’s almost like someone paid her to go on and on about the silliest things. I can’t believe I listened to a 30 minute debate about casting choices that are routinely done in many movies.
Aunt beeee
3 out of 5 stars
Was expecting more
I am working my way through the episodes, but I find myself frustrated with Amy in every one. As a film critic, I’m expecting some knowledge from her. To admit that she’d never seen ANY Fred and Ginger movie made me doubt whether she would have any insight to add on the older movies. And then she went on to bash it for being too “static”. I was hoping for some real tidbits about the casting and making of these movies, and instead I just get Amy talking about things that are “problematic”.
smkandmirrors
1 out of 5 stars
Really want to listen
Great material interesting point of views but annunciation with one of the casters makes me unfollow bummed!
Sarahbobarah78
4 out of 5 stars
Paul’s great
I enjoy listening to this podcast. I love Paul Scheer, but his cohost Amy is annoying, and nitpicks at the most bizarre aspects of movies. She thinks Titanic,(quite possibly the most saccharine of romance movies), is great, but can’t understand the casting of Joe Pesci in Goodfellas.... Amy needs to take an annunciation class, she’s got bad a case of the schmenna schmennas... I wish June was his cohost...
STJW86
5 out of 5 stars
Love This Show
Honestly, the 2007 version of the AFI list changed my life, so this podcast almost feels like I'm completing the loop. I remember watching the TV special where they revealed the 2007 list and being so invested that I started making my way through the entire list, scheduling my life (I was in college at the time) around when these movies would be on TCM, AMC and the like, as well as when I could get them at Blockbuster. I will listen to Paul talk about anything because he can always find the uniqueness. I do think a show like this needs somebody like Amy for it to work. And I think they genuinely enjoy and appreciate each other, which makes me enjoy their approach to these movies even more.
elvisking1
5 out of 5 stars
Best movie podcast
Best movie podcast thanks so much enjoy every episode
AKC2DDM
5 out of 5 stars
Love this podcast SO MUCH
Unspooled is one of my favorite podcasts, and also the podcast I've gotten the most out of. As a lover of films of the last two decades, I was shamefully lacking in film history. I've watched most of these movies for the first time along with the podcast and appreciate the historical context and gossip that our hosts provide. Amy and Paul have enthusiasm to spare. I can't think of two other hosts who I would rather share this journey with.
Ggggggfffffffffucewqk
5 out of 5 stars
Paul and Amy are great
👍🌻yay unspooled
Mad_dog9
1 out of 5 stars
Idea for re-booting the show
They should re-record all the episodes, but replacing the current cohost Amy with June from HDTGM. That would be an awesome podcast. The current version is terrible, don’t even bother with it
bountyhunterbob
1 out of 5 stars
Amy Stinks
Paul is great, but Amy stinks so bad
omarclyde
5 out of 5 stars
Fun and so interesting!
Just loving this podcast! A spectacular diversion from the depressing news and politics surrounding us today. The hosts are engaging and really enjoy what they are doing.
PeaceLover08
1 out of 5 stars
Verbal Diarrhea
The Verbal Diarrhea nitpicking...every...last....single....detail is a turn off. Unsubscribe
Mr. Chavez Ravine
2 out of 5 stars
Brilliant concept....Amy drove me nuts
Paul is fantastic a creative who appreciates the art. Amy is the critic who can find the rainstorm on a sunny day and is too hot “takey” for me. Not everything needs to be social justice’d. Sometime we just like movies and these are good ones. When you can’t like Shawshank and The Godfather, Goodfellas...maybe the movies aren’t the issue....I’ll listen to HDTGM
Snowpenny
5 out of 5 stars
So good!!!
This podcast is the best ever! So much interesting info. Fun to listen too. Love the hosts. Film Noir and old black and white movies are my favorite. I must admit, they can be a little confusing. This podcast explains a lot. Thank you! I just discovered this podcast and started with the Maltese Falcon...a dream come true...Please more, more more!
nickanderhoey
5 out of 5 stars
What a great show
Paul and Amy are so good!
BPatrickT
5 out of 5 stars
One of my favorites
Paul Scheer (How Did This Get Made?) and Amy Nicholson (The Canon) combined forces to tackle the 2007 AFI film list. Insightful analysis and fun discussions about these films and the times they were released.
KansasAmanda
5 out of 5 stars
Fun!
I love movies and have really enjoyed the podcast. I started listening near the beginning but one could definitely catch up and enjoy the early episodes. The hosts definitely have an expansive movie knowledge but don’t get too far in the weeds and certainly enjoy a crowd pleaser as much as more serious works.
Otjbngj
5 out of 5 stars
Love it!
I look forward to listening every week. A little trivia, behind the scenes, and perspective are brought by the hosts. It’s a tour through Hollywood history and great to see the influence of these films on newer ones. I love both hosts and have sought out their other pods as a result. Great stuff!
nicknamegoeshere1799
5 out of 5 stars
Amy and Paul have it all
When I was younger I saw the AFI 1997 list in my video store and would occasionally maybe see a film from it. However, I didn’t fully appreciate it, and when I found this podcast I decided it would be a chance to really work myself to fill in the gaps of my pop culture knowledge Paul and Amy are delightful, funny, and provide terrific insight into film, and I love that Amy works to prevent film (and film fan culture) from fully devolving into a boys club. I may not always agree with their opinions on a film, but I also trust that I can like and discuss a film even if others don’t like it Give this podcast a listen. You won’t regret it.
SharonHorwatt
5 out of 5 stars
Started from the Get-go
I’ve been listening to the podcast from day 1, and I have really enjoyed it. I think that Paul and Amy are a perfect pairing in many ways; Amy has seen many of these movies for her job, while Paul is a little less experienced with some of these other films. This podcast has also had an uncanny ability to make itself and the films on the list relevant, which is very funny.
othervoices
5 out of 5 stars
One of my absolute favorite podcasts
I’ve been listening to Unspooled since the beginning of the podcast. I am a HDTGM fan, and also a movie buff, in general, so this was right up my alley. It’s awesome to revisit old movies, watch ones I never thought I would, and just get some deep conversation and behind the scenes stories about the movies. Amy and Paul have a great rapport! I also love the community that has spawned around it - from the FB group to live viewings of Amy and Paul talking about movies that aren’t on the list on YouTube. It’s really become like family to me and I love being a part of a global gathering of movie fans who are funny, witty and astute, just like the hosts.
LexStark
5 out of 5 stars
A wonderful movie podcast!
I wish I had this podcast when I was a film geek in high school. It’s always a joy to listen and go on this movie journey!
Darbyact
5 out of 5 stars
Great Fun, Great Knowledge, A Classic
It’s the Citizen Kane of Podcasts.
fudgestripe
5 out of 5 stars
Such a fun project
The whole idea of the pod is great. It really motivated me to take a tour back through classic cinema some of which I hadn’t seen and a lot of which I saw when I was young and didn’t really appreciate. For that alone this deserves five stars. Amy and Paul are sort of like personal trainers keeping you motivated to keep going with an episode each week. I personally spread it out and take breaks because it can be exhausting to keep pace but that’s the great thing about this format. This content will always be here for people thanks to them. Kudos
divaddaviddivad13
5 out of 5 stars
Great
I love this podcasts and I love that it’s not afraid to call out how classic movies haven’t aged all that well.
esmeralda169
5 out of 5 stars
This podcast changed my life
Not to be bombastic, but it truly did. I was in a new city, lonely, with only my many podcast hosts as friends. I’ve always loved movies, and was already a fan of Paul scheers, so I gave it a try. Now each week as I watch the next movie, I get so excited to hear if they agree with me and with each other. Although they disagree sometimes, it’s all respectful and in good fun. Amy’s years of experience and her good heartedness and Paul’s exuberance and love of film, make them a delightful duo I’ve developed real life friendships with fellow spoolers that will last long after we’ve completed the AFI list. I’ll follow Paul and Amy wherever they lead.
Mickfly718
5 out of 5 stars
Great Journey Through AFI 100
It’s been a bucket list of mine to get through this list, and I have just 10 left, but by now have forgotten some that I watched long ago. I am so thankful that this podcast exists and is so well-executed. I love the guests - the director of Jackass for the episode on The General? The hosts are entertaining and bring great insight to the film reviews, and I love the bits about having callers guess plots or otherwise weigh in, and the reviews at the end bring some fascinating context. Thank you for this podcast!
Junebugjen
5 out of 5 stars
Look forward to this every week.
This is my favorite podcast of all time, and I listen to quite a few since I work from home. It’s a little bit of a thrill to see it show up in my feed every week. Paul and Amy have fun, thoughtful, accessible discussions on each film on the list. I do have some concerns about what happens when we finish the initial 100. One idea: Start a new thread about the movies that used to be on the list, or the movies that should be on the list. I definitely don’t want it to end. I mean, how many True Crime podcasts can a person hear in one lifetime???!!! 😃
Hobbitses4hire
5 out of 5 stars
Gotta Watch Em All!
I’m really enjoying this pod without having seen most of the movies from the list! I love the charisma and intelligence of the hosts. They seem to really know their stuff!
Cary 0'Filmfan
5 out of 5 stars
One of the best podcasts, anywhere
Unspooled is the perfect podcast. An insider, Paul Scheer, who acts and directs, and an outsider, Amy Nicholson, a professional film critic, watch and discuss some of the greatest movies ever made and share their reactions, usually bringing in a fascinating guest who had something to do with the production. The hosts are funny and insightful and the format gives listeners an education not only into the history of filmmaking, but also what America was going through at the time they were made. What more could you want in a podcast? Two enthusiastic thumbs up for Unspooled.
hbbeastie
5 out of 5 stars
My new favorite podcast
It’s a great happy distraction these days:) thank you
makeupfan123
5 out of 5 stars
Love this podcast
I’ve been reading a few reviews lately that don’t seem to like how the hosts are giving theirs criticism of “classic” movies and honestly? That’s literally the point of the podcast. It’s to examine if these movies actually should be on the AFI list, if they hold up and if they actually should be considered classics. Some movies hold up well, others really don’t and if I see one more review complaining about their politics I might scream. They are reviewing these movie through a contemporary lens and often times that means dealing with harsh realities. Yes movies are political, sorry to break that to some people but that’s what art is. The complaints about Amy are honestly super sexist but I have a feeling since she’s been a critic for so long she’s used to that toxic part of the job. Also those reviewer using word like “woke” and phrases like “can’t we just enjoy movies for what they are” are pretty much showing their colors.
Misfits21
1 out of 5 stars
I listened too long
Love HDTGM and decided to listen to this after hearing the E.T. Episode. Amy just gets worse the longer you listen. I just couldn’t do it anymore. I was trying to hold out for Jaws, but I just can’t stand hearing her politics put into everything anymore. It’s not a podcast about classic movies, it’s a podcast about how Amy is offended by classic movies.
TeeKay_55
5 out of 5 stars
Love Unspooled
Unlike the garbage humans who commented and reviewed before me, I enjoy the personal touch Paul and Amy put into the podcast. I would expect someone with those political leanings to trash something they don’t disagree with, but it’s funny how they go right after Amy first and show their true misogynistic colors. Keep up the great work and impressive film analysis
qewrfdgfcy65y7
1 out of 5 stars
If you’re not WOKE you’re not WELCOME .. stop calling your political opponents Garbage People
Stop the personal politics and the name calling. Just because I’m not woke doesn’t make me a “Garbage Person” I wanted to comment on the movie aspect of this podcast but when they bring their brand of politics into the mix I have to comment on how that ruins the listener experience for those of us on the right who also like moves. Movies and sports and music should be something we can all enjoy together. It should help to bring down the divide. But it seems every episode I listen to she has to make anti-Trump put downs. And he uses derogatory terms about people he doesn’t like such as calling us Garbage People or Fascists. They have the right to their opinions. But when you bring it into the show it is now part of the show and can be included in the entire listener experience. So now I’m commenting on the unspooled movie/ politics podcast. You make us “garbage people” feel unwelcome I even joined the Facebook group and one of the rules was civility. No name calling. I suggest they apply that to themselves. Can’t we just talk about movies?
Pop Culture Savant
1 out of 5 stars
I thought it would be better
I’ve listened to a few podcasts and I feel you do a poor job of holding some of the more classic movies to the same standards of today. Especially when it comes to gender, sexual orientation and POC. You could say things like “using that word would not be acceptable today” or “how he treated that lady would not be acceptable today”, would be ok. However, you skewer movies that so many people love because you feel it’s not represented by today’s standards. I just don’t care for your take on some of these movies.
gregorygob
5 out of 5 stars
Fantastic!
Oh yeah, be sure to keep this up!
childplease34
1 out of 5 stars
It’s gotten so bad
This podcast over time has become insufferable
Visha33
1 out of 5 stars
Amy Nicholson is a terrible person
She is the definition of white neoliberal oppressor who pretends to be woke while utterly spitting in the face of a women-led, racially intersectional working grassroots movement. She makes rich white feminism into an art form. She’s horribly uninformed and smug. She’s not your friend.
FuzzyDunlop1000
5 out of 5 stars
Love the show
Had gotten into older movies over the past 2 years, this podcast is the first thing I look for after I watch another movie on here!
Han-Shoots-First
5 out of 5 stars
Brilliant, fun show, must list for film fans
Sorting through the AFI list, while debating their present-day relevance couldn’t be more charming. You can’t not be drawn in by Paul & Amy’s infectious enthusiasm for film. An absolute must listen for anyone who considers them selves a film buff worth their salt.
BrooklynJMZ
4 out of 5 stars
Film Novice and Expert Duo it is not
So I expected Paul Scheer would be the lesser insightful host, but he actually does his homework and brings a fresh eye to some classics. I was flabbergasted his cohost had never seen the movie for their second episode. Her opinions add nothing to the podcast. The best parts is when they get outside commentaries to provide insight to the topic at hand.
hjlprojections
1 out of 5 stars
Wow Bethany Wow
I really wanted to like this bc I love Paul Scheer but his co- host is unbearable. And I don’t see how you can call yourself a film critic when you do a show about Silence of the Lambs and keep referring to the actor playing Buffalo Bill as “Ted Divine”. Ugh.
tn19177
5 out of 5 stars
Great pod!!
Love Amy and Paul!!! Rly fun and I’ve seen so many new movies because of this pod!!
Conor Holt
5 out of 5 stars
Love it!
Love the podcast. Amy is a great critic, Paul is really funny, and it's fun to dive into the AFI List and think about what does & doesn't belong there. Personally I would love to see more animated films on the list, like Beauty and the Beast or even Who Framed Roger Rabbit, and I think Fargo, Rebel Without A Cause and Fantasia should go back on the list, since they were on the 1998 list.
bagelsnfox
5 out of 5 stars
Go Amy!
This is a great podcast and it’s rad that Amy has upset so many Nazis/Republicans
ChuckBBlazer
4 out of 5 stars
Great listen
Paul is great and unexpectedly knowledgeable about film. Amy is smart and has great insights and brings a wonderful perspective. I sometimes get tired of the predictable role that politics plays in the reviews of films, especially from Amy. If the movie has a female lead she will always praise the movie, the performance etc... She needs to stop using the phrase , “this dark/dystopian/ or whatever message in this movie is more important now than ever” Everything in you life should not be interpreted through the lens of how much you hate Republicans. However, it is entertaining and informative enough that I can get past that (most of the time)
Linddykal
5 out of 5 stars
Balance of hosts
I love this show. Paul is funny and insightful and Amy is incredibly intelligent and knowledgeable about film. They have great chemistry and can respectfully disagree with each other without losing their cool or class. I’ve binged most of the episodes in a month!
chickencutlets
5 out of 5 stars
What’s with the Amy hate?
Surprised (kind of) to see so many reviewers complaining about Amy. I feel like they just may not have ever met women who have always been deeply interested in film and are jarred by her lack of fangirling. I think she brings a really unique perspective to things that balance off of Paul, and as a team they always can respect each other’s differences in opinion and discuss it in a way that isn’t about personal bias, but about their experiences and study of film. I will say however that the only thing I am getting tired of with Amy is the use of the same anecdote with the crappy Hollywood apartment with the rats and the milkshake and the steakhouse and the wedge salad and martini and Karina Longworth— girl, we know!!!!! Surely you have more sponsored stories to hawk the dining card!
Virgambers
5 out of 5 stars
so fun!
i really like the deep dives into these classic movies that i feel i should know/know more about. amy and paul bounce off each other nicely and offer perspective and research i definitely wouldn’t have the attention span to seek out myself.
N8kelsey
1 out of 5 stars
Too much negativity
This podcast started as a celebration of film. In recent episodes it has devolved into complaining about everything wrong with current cinema. We shouldn’t have to tear down one film to build another up. Unfortunately, I will be unsubscribing.
CaniePoo
5 out of 5 stars
Into it👍
Huge fan of Paul, new fan of Amy, these two together is a winning combo! No snobbery, just their perspectives, I’m down. Check it and I’m sure you won’t be disappointed.
leedsls12
3 out of 5 stars
I’ve tried on multiple occasions to stay interested
I’ve tried multiple times to listen to this podcast. I love the idea, but as many people in the comments have noted, Amy makes it a difficult listen. Her perspective is so negative and singleminded it makes it a chore to listen to an entire episode. Films are supposed to bring entertainment, reflection, and innovation. Sometimes films miss the mark and/or don’t live up to expectations. That doesn’t mean the film should be dismissed entirely. Amy dismisses other opinions so quickly it makes you feel like she has never really formed her own opinion to begin with. You can tell she has god knowledge of film history, it’s just a shame she doesn’t present her views in an engaging and thoughtful way most of the time. I don’t want this to come off as superficial criticism of the show. I’ll get the impression that both Amy and Paul put in a ton of work to prep for the shows, and it shows from their detailed knowledge Bout the films they discuss. Is just Amy’s negative presentation of her ideas that take away from an enjoyable discussion about film history. I do not want to suggest that people should not listen to this podcast, b/c others might not have the same feeling. I just hope that the hosts review their reviews and take into consideration many of the reviews that express this same general idea. I will continue to try to listen to new episodes with hope that the tone of the discussions gets better.
Dante Biggs
3 out of 5 stars
Paul pick a new partner please
Love the show, formats great however I have to say that Amy gives garbage reviews for truly crap reasons. Sounds to me she just enjoys being a contrarian, she performs a little too much “woke” servicing, and this is coming from a liberal. Sorry Amy I just think your taste is poor, you come off entitled, snobbish and incredibly annoying.
Fredz23
1 out of 5 stars
Sorry Paul
Big fan of Paul’s but I can’t keep listening to Amy, she comes off as entitled and extremely condescending....going back to HDTGM.
ba3311
5 out of 5 stars
Super funny
Love the podcast and sometimes the bad movies are good
Sammycakes99
5 out of 5 stars
Great passion
I love both of your passion for movies. I especially love the new Star Wars episode it was great and would love to see you guys cover more of them. Thank your for everything you guys do.
tretornlady
1 out of 5 stars
Enjoy this so much!
I did not know I needed this in my life...but I do. I just started so I am catching up. Congrats on the wonderful podcast!
mikemeg 2
4 out of 5 stars
I always come back
I really enjoy their musings on these classic films. But I really, really tire of the predictable woke takes. It's become easy to predict when Amy will launch into a side political comment. We get it, Amy... You're progressive! Just say that up front, and we'll be able to fill in all the blanks, and it gives no insight into the films. And that's a shame, because Amy has a ton of actual insightful comments, as does Paul. And they do a lot of background research, greatly increasing my appreciation of the films. I disagree with many of their assessments. I understand how having so many [ boxing/ mob /Scorsese /hoffman] movies can perplex, but at some point you have to consider artistry separately from actor, director, or theme. And they appreciate artistry during their recap, then in the overall rating seem utterly unimpressed by craft. Butt always entertaining, and usually informative.
rsicks
4 out of 5 stars
Pretty Good
Paul is a “lifelong film buff” but had never seen All About Eve or a single Bette Davis film for that matter...yikes. All the facts he read off were just from IMDb. Amy was great though and made up for it
JDCSIX
2 out of 5 stars
Not every movie is political
I’ve enjoyed all your podcasts. Amy can you please stop with all the political references. I get it you do not like President Trump. Amy nice cheap shot at President Reagan on the “Raging Bull” podcast. I look forward to the rest of the list...
Janet2552
3 out of 5 stars
Need better repartee
The discussions are fine, but these two need to do a better job of listening to each other and letting each have his/her say before steamrolling over their comments. This isn’t a debate in a bar, but a discussion in front of a microphone.
i_see_toast
5 out of 5 stars
Perfect For Any Cinema Lover
Paul and Amy are doing important work, examining the uncontested American classics through a modern lens. They always choose fascinating people to interview and I’ve learned so much whilst also feeling validated in some of my personal critiques of these films. I look forward to every episode, whether I’ve seen the film or not. And in some cases, they have made me feel like I don’t need to be a completist about this list.
DrRichardKimbleMD
5 out of 5 stars
Amy’s great, Paul’s great
Negative reviews are weird to see here - one of my favorite podcasts and a nice counterpoint to HDTGM
Huribes
5 out of 5 stars
Pulp Fiction is as good as you remember.
I was born in 2002 and I consider it to be one of the best films of all time.
Twain Bunyan
5 out of 5 stars
Annie Hall
I really think this was the best episode to date. Often I think Paul especially is a little off in some of the discussions they’ve had, but, he is right on, displays his in-depth knowledge of comedy. Amy is great on all episodes. Together they are a top team.
Diablo2000
5 out of 5 stars
Good popcorn podcast
I have enjoyed these very much and have found myself being challenged to watch and rewatch these movies. It’s the only opportunity most people get to engage in discussions about American cinema. Paul is funny and brings a “down to Earth” vibe to his views of the movies. I like that Amy is not afraid to challenge conventional wisdom about the place these movies have in American culture. I do sometimes wish she shared more nuance to her reviews and not just attack these pieces just because she doesn’t like someone or something.
Asg82
4 out of 5 stars
So much potential
Good if you want a breakdown of the top 100 AFI films. Bad if you want a contrast to a critic, either as a comedian or as a an everyman to represent Joe Public.
Jilltobo
4 out of 5 stars
I agree with the other reviewers
I love Paul and I listen to HDTGM often. Amy needs to stop reviewing any movie that came out prior to 1998. Things were different. We are aware. We can’t wave a wand and make them all wholly politically correct nor would I want to because last I understood it, movies, books and art weren’t to be held under those kind of lenses. Overall entertaining but sometimes it irritates the crap out of me (quite frankly) and I have to skip over large sections of it. They don’t allow for “half stars” or I’d give it 3.5 ⭐️
Dra Ngipon
5 out of 5 stars
Fun
Firstly, these are reviewers the age of my kids. Their naïveté is startling at times and irritating at others. Amy talks faster than any East Coast native and begins many statements with, “Yeah, I mean...” But she also treats so gently the interview with Cary Grant’s daughter that I was almost in tears myself. When they get excited, they throw malapropisms around like Yogi Berra but that’s just funny. Altogether grand fun.
Sass80
5 out of 5 stars
Fun times with great flicks
I like a podcast where I can disagree with the hosts or think “no you’re missing the point!” often but still find their opinions interesting and compelling. They do a great job analyzing classic films under the lens of the present and they do it with a great sense of humor and a willingness to be challenged by one another and the listener. They have also forced me to go back and rewatch some great films. Thanks for making my night shifts fly by!
Mr.S.Martin
5 out of 5 stars
Absolutely favorite podcast
Funny, smart, easy and enthusiastic. Colorful, healthy and easy to digest criticisms. Amy & Paul are like peas & carrots.
TASR gamer
5 out of 5 stars
Favorite Movie Podcast
This show is great. Paul and Amy are both smart, funny, and knowledgeable and their chemistry is awesome. I was surprised to see so many reviews hating on Amy but shocker, women can’t ever catch a break especially if they dare to have opinions. Love the premise of going back over the classics and the excuse it gives me to rewatch all these greats. I am dreading the end of the show and I hope they find a way to keep it going - maybe they each pick 10 movies they think should be added to the list and do an episode on each of them? 20 more weeks of awesome content!
Perkcasso
3 out of 5 stars
It’s ok but not great
I have given this show several listens (8 episodes) and have concluded that for me it is just ok. Trying to determine if a film made 20,30 or 40 years ago through a 2018-2019 lens is probably not going to work out well for the movie. I don’t think Paul and Amy really look at films for what they are or the era in which they were made. Both are good hosts but not very fair as critics. I don’t think it’s a bad show but I don’t feel it’s good either. It’s right in the middle making it utterly forgettable. At least to me. Others have reviewed this much more harsh and yet others have lauded much praise; I didn’t connect with it in either way which to me is much worse.
Ouray Lives
3 out of 5 stars
The interruption
A chance to hear a truly knowledgeable cinephile get interrupted by Paul Scheer. And by way, film is political. Talking about it in an apolitical way is irresponsible.
Lucindau
2 out of 5 stars
Correction
Just listened to Some Like It Hot episode. Jack Lemmon did not win the Oscar. He was nominated. He won the Golden Globe.
JJJin LA
5 out of 5 stars
Forrest Dump
Dear Amy, forgive me, the kid actually doing the running in 1994?- That’s Generation X, not millennials. Never fear, only further proof the smarter people are, the more Gumpish tendencies emerge without even knowing it... Oh - and I actually do have webbed toes on my right foot, a genetic gift from my maternal grandfather, one shared with my first cousin. Only she turned out to be an Eileen Ford model while I - am not...
SerialPodcastReviewer
3 out of 5 stars
Paul is good, Amy is not.
When I found Unspooled, I was thrilled to finally find a movie podcast with a female host. I was getting sick of only listening to guys talk about movies. Unfortunately, Amy brings too many politics into the show. Her annoying progressive views get in the way of being a good critic and she dislikes movies simply because their actors hold political views that she doesn’t like. This is a podcast about movies, not a place to express your intolerance of Trump and Republicans. She also lacks some simple, fundamental appreciation for true quality in movies and downplays classic films that are fantastic while praising newer crap simply because new movies are full of woke culture. Paul on the other hand is a good host and keeps politics out of the show. I am so bummed that Amy is a leftist.
HistoryofMatt
1 out of 5 stars
Amy Nicholson is a “film critic” who knows nothing about films and film history
I often heard Paul talk about this podcast on How Did This Get Made and finally decided to give it a try. I’m sorry I did. I expected to find a podcast about a comedian-turned film enthusiast being guided through the AFI’s 100 Best Films by a knowledgable film critic who understands the process of filmmaking and the history of these great movies. What I found instead is a comedian-turned film enthusiast who knows more about these movies than the supposed film critic, Amy Nicholson, whose ignorance is staggering. I should have known something was wrong when in episode 2, “Ben-Hur,” she actually admitted she had never seen this seminal film. How can you be a film critic and not have seen Ben-Hur, one of the greatest films ever made? That’s right, Amy Nicholson isn’t a film critic in the classic sense; trained and schooled. She’s like all of the new media “film critics,” aka ignorant bloggers who fell bass backwards into blogging their inane thoughts about movies through a lens of neo progressive ideology and identity politics. I then listened to the episode about Unforgiven, a classic Western, rich with heavy themes revolving around revenge, forgiveness, honor, and loyalty, and all Amy Nicholson could do was talk about how much she didn’t like Clint Eastwood (because she doesn’t like his politics… like that has ANYTHING to do with the movies he makes), and then said the film shouldn’t be on the AFI’s 100 Best Films list, again, not because she made an intelligent argument as to why the film is lacking, but because she doesn’t like Clint Eastwood’s politics. Save your time. If you’re a passionate film fan who is tired of terrible bloggers with ignorant opinions posing as film critics that inject their inanely shallow political bias into everything they write as opposed to offering actual criticism about films involving writing, acting, directing, scoring, or anything about filmmaking, then you should avoid this tedious podcast. What a shame. Had Paul paired himself with an film critic with a passion for filmmaking and knowledge of film history, someone like Drew McWeeny, this could have been so much better. It should have been better.
GrittyStrikesBack
1 out of 5 stars
Identity politics at its worst
Unlistenable thanks to Paul’s cohost. Truly difficult to believe that some people only view the world as oppressor vs oppressed. This could have been good if they simply talked about if the films were good or not.
JBNJ007
3 out of 5 stars
Great concept. Meh execution
Great idea. Paul is great and lots of energy. Amy I think has changed. Less interested and mostly negative. They’d generally like to take their anti 70s films and simply replace them with their formative films from their youth. Still live the Early show.
Kyle Chaney
1 out of 5 stars
Liked it until it became the "I hate New Hollywood" podcast.
It was interesting until it just became a slog of them not liking or connecting with 70's cinema and the "New Hollywood" era of directors. The "Gone With The Wind" episode and "On the Waterfront" are so engaging and full of fun information but man is it getting old just hearing them dump on Scorsese and Spielberg.
Capt. Sav-A-Ho
3 out of 5 stars
Stole AFI bit from Classy Clarke Wolfe
Other-wise I’ll give it time
Disone72
5 out of 5 stars
Love it!
Amazing commentary and discussion. Paul and Amy work off each other well. Whether or not you agree with their take, it’s an interesting ride.
Blurgh
5 out of 5 stars
I love it
I look forward to each new episode. Unlike many film podcasts, Amy and Paul talk about the film; there are no sad attempts at comedy, no dull recounts of their exciting weekends, etc. It’s a tight, well produced podcast, and they keep it interesting, and under three hours.
HowDidThisGetReviewed
3 out of 5 stars
This podcast should be fun.
Amy is eager to share a “woke” take. If the film does not fit cleanly into a 2019 narrative then it will inevitably be described as misogynistic or uninspired. Many of the films, film-makers and actors are from a different era. It feels arrogant to judge the cast and crew through modern standards. Her focus is less on the material and more on political correctness. It makes the conversations about the films odd and disjointed. This podcast should be fun. Paul is funny and pleasant. Amy is simply bad at this.
@JRoessner22
2 out of 5 stars
Lord of The Rings
She just compared the ring wraiths and Sauron who are supposed to be an embodiment of evil to Mitch McConnell in a completely serious manner...
Nervespark101
3 out of 5 stars
Over It
Some really good episodes, even for films I have not seen. Been lukewarm about it for a while, and after the lame conversation regarding Joker/Taxi Driver, I’m good for now. I understand playing two potential sides of an argument, but it really felt like the majority of criticisms (against the only recent release they’ve discussed) that could be leveled were a result of really lazy viewing and an unwillingness to meet the creators at their own goals with the film, which was disappointing and uncharacteristic.
S. T. Coleridge
5 out of 5 stars
Love It
Unspooled is the best! I am looking forward to watching all the films and hearing all 100 podcasts. Great concept. Great guides. Great podcast. Thank you both! “I do a lot of cocaine.” -Amy during the NbNW episode Update: I watched all 100 films on the list!
Rackham337
1 out of 5 stars
Amy is awful
Amy is unable to leave her extreme left views at home and just talk about great films.
Hi-line
5 out of 5 stars
Important and Deeply Entertaining
This is the best way I have learned about film. Two film experts, humorous and intelligent, discuss the American Film Institute top 100 films. Film by film. Take your time. Watch the films. Listen to their history tidbits and discussion of the film. And, best yet, you get to disagree or agree. Some compelling shticks like (is there a Simpsons gag about the film in discussion) or should the film be on AFI’s list and where should it fall? If you love film, this is a must-listen that you’ll not regret spending time with. Enjoy.
Slim1525
1 out of 5 stars
Meh
As time has gone on the show has become less and less interesting. Not much research about each weeks film is done, especially those they don’t like, outside of what can be found on Wikipedia. Also it’s tiring that everything comes back to a comparison to Once Upon a Time in Hollywood
ArcherNova
1 out of 5 stars
Reviewers admit they haven’t seen most of classics
Frustrating to listen to so-called critics who routinely admit they haven’t seen a lot of the top 100 films. This is a big tell they also haven’t watched a lot of other films from prior eras as well, which reflects they lack a depth of knowledge of our country’s rich film history. Biased toward movies they saw while growing up. And routinely dismissing films from glory days of Hollywood. Should be call millennials whining. The female host seems to hate with some bizarre feminist bent any movies involving men. I tried with this podcast. I really tried. Listened to a number of them. Do not recommend. They should instead stop their podcast and dedicate the next ten years of their lives studying films of our country’s history so they can offer informed opinions more than ... insert valley girl voice ... this movie is toooo looooong. CAN WE PLEASE HAVE MIKE CHADWAY AKA GERARD BUTLER FROM THE UGLY TRUTH JUMP IN AND EXPLAIN WHY MOVIES WITH MALE LEADS ARE VERY BELOVED!? STOP WITH THE MAN HATING PLEASE!
Beckkkkkkkkky
5 out of 5 stars
So smart and well done!
So smart and well done! Once this podcast is done I hope Amy and Paul do another one together
Bahskoh
1 out of 5 stars
Skip it
I’ve never heard such a meandering, useless podcast (that isn’t supposed to be) in my life. The two hosts of the show make no effort to look at the films through a critical lens. It’s all reactionary triflings about how the film stands up under selective scrutiny in today’s world. I would have enjoyed this podcast if either of the hosts knew anything about the technical side of making a film, but it is more like an objective look at whether the movie can offend anybody today. I don’t know. I just think it would benefit from having people that knew why these movies are important in the first place, other than getting their selective knowledge of the film from Wikipedia and then diving in head first. Professionalism would help this show a ton.
tommylee49
5 out of 5 stars
Perfect for movie lovers
My favorite podcast. The hosts are great. Very insightful. I never miss a new episode. 👍🏼👍🏼
clifwith1f
5 out of 5 stars
The Stanley Kubrick of Podcasts
Amy Nicholson and Paul Scheer have crafted a podcast that is deserving of the great movies they discuss. A perfect blend of insight and humor without pretension. If (when) the future gives us an American Podcast Institute, Unspooled will reign supreme.
RonnieWasTaken
5 out of 5 stars
Jason was wrong
This podcast is amazing!
Buck2323
5 out of 5 stars
Outstanding!
Outstanding dives into some of the greatest films ever made. And questions about some of the films that are perceived as great; but perhaps, not so much! Highly recommended.
Surf2Die4
3 out of 5 stars
The vocal fry
is really rough and distracting. Karina Longworth presumably listened to the complaints and changed so perhaps there’s hope. It’s different from the usual 80s “valley” speak, although Amy does say “like” way too often. This and the ridiculous hyperbole she trots out, a lot (this movie would be a thousand times a million gazillion percent better if fill-in-the-blank) are the hardest to take. Paul is Paul, so few issues, there.
Rusty Rebar
5 out of 5 stars
Fun pod
Nice podcast of two young film lovers viewing classics and giving their opinions. If Amy could just pronounce BIO-PIC (bio, NOT biah!!!) it would be flawless.
SammyLovesDavis
5 out of 5 stars
Wonderful Stuff
Great Hosts, fun discussion. If you don’t think you already know everything, enjoy. A great podcast to parallel “you must remember this”. So thankful to Paul and Amy.
Lucho Blanco
5 out of 5 stars
Amy kills it
She’s gotta be the best, coolest, smartest movie critic outthere. Hands down. And that voice! Please! I’m just a fan. But having said that (cliche, cliche) Amy and her cohost really bring on the art of loving and talking about films. A bit too long tho, but excellent nonetheless. So, pick a film on the list, grab a beer, sit back, listen and enjoy. This is the best podcast on classic film reviewing in podcastlandia (not withstanding KPCC’s Filmweek, where Amy also shines). If u love classic movies, make sure to listen and subscribe. Amy will do the rest. LB
MichelleM19
3 out of 5 stars
Interesting but
Amy is rude a lot and talks about herself far too much.
Blue NPR
5 out of 5 stars
Good concept, Amy needs improvement
Amy comes across as self-indulgent and a show-off because many things she says are actually about her first and the movie second. ("I was just in Cairo and blah blah blah" "I grew up in Texas so blah blah blah" "please follow my quirky stream of consciousness but blah blah blah" "maybe my brain works in crazy ways because of all of the director I've met but blah blah blah" - always followed by interesting facts or analysis not related to the unnecessary, self-referencing preamble). Paul does a better job using a unique style and personality to present the material in an entertaining way while not putting himself in the foreground. Maybe this is what Amy is trying for. Here is an example from the Sophie's Choice episode about the Riesling diet: "It's an old diet I've always wanted to try. But I've never had the courage. You [describes diet - this is the interesting part]. I came across it in old diet books because I think those are really funny. I've always kinda wanted to try it." (Quotes not exact but capture the sense) Amy, we don't need all these facts about yourself. A sprinkling would be charming, but instead we get a torrential outpouring of autobiographical facts. It's distracting.
Supertexaschick
2 out of 5 stars
Great Concept, Muddled Execution
On paper, I would love this podcast. I love lists and I love movies. Paul is funny but seems put on. Amy is overly judgmental. I am a pretty liberal person but holy crap. Getting onto Shawshank for not having any female parts. It is about an all male prison! Feels like Amy is after hot takes so much that it ruins her cinema experience.
Podcast information
- Amount of episodes
- 282
- Subscribers
- 61
- Verified
- No
- Website
- Explicit content
- Yes
- Episode type
- episodic
- Podcast link
- https://podvine.com/link/..
- Last upload date
- March 23, 2023
- Last fetch date
- March 24, 2023 1:11 AM
- Upload range
- WEEKLY
- Author
- Earwolf, Paul Scheer & Amy Nicholson
- Copyright
- 2021 Earwolf, Paul Scheer & Amy Nicholson
susbcribers
- John WickAmy & Paul arm up for 2014’s revitalizing Keanu Reeves action film John Wick! They ask whether we’re supposed to care about Wick as a character, praise the careful world building of directors Chad Stahelski and David Leitch, and debate the best fight in the series. Plus: What would you do if someone killed your pet in front of you? Next week, tune in as we discuss In Bruges! You can join the conversation for this series on Paul’s Discord at https://discord.gg/ZwtygZGTa6. Learn more about the show at unspooledpod.com, follow us on Twitter @unspooled and Instagram @unspooledpod, and don’t forget to rate, review & subscribe to us on Apple Podcasts, Stitcher and Spotify.0 comments0
- Bonus Reel: Creed III, Magic Mike’s Last Dance and Scream VIIn this bonus Unspooled, Paul & Amy weigh in on the latest franchise entries following our recent episodes, including discussions of how Jonathan Majors fits into the Creed universe, whether Steven Soderbergh got the tone of the third Magic Mike right, and how Hayden Panettiere fares in her return to Scream.0 comments0
- Unspooled Mar 16 · 1h 20m CreedAmy & Paul go toe to toe with 2015's hit pugilist lega-sequel Creed! They learn how Sylvester Stallone agreed to pass the torch of his most famous franchise to Ryan Coogler and Michael B. Jordan, explore Jordan's relationship with Tessa Thompson, and ask if Rocky's final fate in the film was earned. Plus: Some Rocky-inspired thoughts on aging. Next week, tune in as we discuss John Wick! You can join the conversation for this series on Paul’s Discord at https://discord.gg/ZwtygZGTa6. Learn more about the show at unspooledpod.com, follow us on Twitter @unspooled and Instagram @unspooledpod, and don’t forget to rate, review & subscribe to us on Apple Podcasts, Stitcher and Spotify.0 comments0
- Best of 2022 & Oscars PreviewPaul & Amy look back on their favorite films of 2022 and get ready for the Academy Awards this weekend! They'll discuss each of the Best Picture nominees, share their thoughts on the year in blockbusters and streaming films, and ask the big question - are the movies back? Plus: A high stakes Oscar wager. Next week, tune in as we discuss Creed! You can join the conversation for this series on Paul’s Discord at https://discord.gg/ZwtygZGTa6. Learn more about the show at unspooledpod.com, follow us on Twitter @unspooled and Instagram @unspooledpod, and don’t forget to rate, review & subscribe to us on Apple Podcasts, Stitcher and Spotify.0 comments0
- Scream (Re-release)In honor of Scream VI's release in theaters this weekend, we're re-releasing last year's discussion of the original Scream - tomorrow we'll be back with a brand new episode! Paul & Amy don't follow the rules for 1996's Wes Craven meta-horror-comedy Scream! They learn Craven's secret to making horror films that resonate, argue that the iconic Ghostface mask works better than a more distinctive look, and unpack the archetype of the "Final Girl." Plus: Henry Winkler and the movie's best in-joke.0 comments0
- Hollywood ShufflePaul & Amy enjoy a Winky Dinky Dog and watch 1987's audacious sketch satire Hollywood Shuffle! They explore the multifaceted career of star and director Robert Townsend, put the film in context of black cinema in the 80s, and ask why Townsend's critiques of Hollywood are relevant 35 years later. Plus: Eddie Murphy's surprising reaction to the film's Eddie Murphy sketch. Next week, we look back at the films of 2022 and preview the Oscars! You can join the conversation for this series on Paul’s Discord at https://discord.gg/ZwtygZGTa6. Learn more about the show at unspooledpod.com, follow us on Twitter @unspooled and Instagram @unspooledpod, and don’t forget to rate, review & subscribe to us on Apple Podcasts, Stitcher and Spotify.0 comments0
- Top 3: Chapo Trap HouseWill Menaker and Matt Christman of Chapo Trap House join Paul & Amy on this week's crossover Unspooled! Matt shares three films to watch before listening to his new history miniseries Hell On Earth, including a Puritan horror folktale and a medieval breakthrough from a master satirist. Will announces his own upcoming miniseries and highlights three films on rails to help get into "movie mindset." Listen to both shows at patreon.com/chapotraphouse. Next week, tune in as we discuss Hollywood Shuffle! You can join the conversation for this series on Paul’s Discord at https://discord.gg/ZwtygZGTa6. Learn more about the show at unspooledpod.com, follow us on Twitter @unspooled and Instagram @unspooledpod, and don’t forget to rate, review & subscribe to us on Apple Podcasts, Stitcher and Spotify.0 comments0
- Magic MikePaul & Amy slip a five dollar bill to 2012's male stripper megahit Magic Mike! They discuss why Steven Soderbergh's film is about money as much or more than sex, ask who the franchise's hottest character is, and explore what makes Channing Tatum such a generational talent. Plus: plenty of love for the super-sized follow up, Magic Mike XXL. Next week, tune in for a Top 3 crossover episode... You can join the conversation for this series on the Unspooled Facebook Group at https://www.facebook.com/groups/unspooledpodcast, and on Paul’s Discord at https://discord.gg/ZwtygZGTa6. Learn more about the show at unspooledpod.com, follow us on Twitter @unspooled and Instagram @unspooledpod, and don’t forget to rate, review & subscribe to us on Apple Podcasts, Stitcher and Spotify. You can also listen to our Stitcher Premium game show Screen Test right now at https://www.stitcher.com/show/unspooled-screen-test and apply to be a contestant at unspooledpod@gmail.com!0 comments0
- Unspooled Feb 14 · 30m Top 3: Smriti MundhraSmriti Mundhra (Indian Matchmaking, The Romantics) talks to Paul and Amy about her three favorite Hindi-language romantic films, how romance became a blockbuster genre in India, and how she feels about the term ‘Bollywood.’ Watch The Romantics on Netflix, out today!0 comments0
- The NotebookAmy & Paul open up 2004's decades-spanning romance The Notebook! They praise the effortless chemistry of Ryan Gosling and Rachel McAdams, learn how James Garner prepared (or didn't prepare) for his role, and ask why we don't see more pure romances like this. Plus: Did Gosling and McAdams really fall in love on set? Next week, tune in as we cover Magic Mike! You can join the conversation for this series on the Unspooled Facebook Group at https://www.facebook.com/groups/unspooledpodcast, and on Paul’s Discord at https://discord.gg/ZwtygZGTa6. Learn more about the show at unspooledpod.com, follow us on Twitter @unspooled and Instagram @unspooledpod, and don’t forget to rate, review & subscribe to us on Apple Podcasts, Stitcher and Spotify. You can also listen to our Stitcher Premium game show Screen Test right now at https://www.stitcher.com/show/unspooled-screen-test and apply to be a contestant at unspooledpod@gmail.com!0 comments0
- CrashPaul & Amy swerve into 2004's Oscar-winning race-in-LA melodrama Crash! They take a close look at how the film's attitudes on race and racism have aged, learn about the incident that happened to director Paul Haggis that inspired the film, and revisit the short-lived Crash TV series. Plus: Should Brokeback Mountain have won Best Picture instead? Next week, tune in as we cover Magic Mike! You can join the conversation for this series on the Unspooled Facebook Group at https://www.facebook.com/groups/unspooledpodcast, and on Paul’s Discord at https://discord.gg/ZwtygZGTa6. Learn more about the show at unspooledpod.com, follow us on Twitter @unspooled and Instagram @unspooledpod, and don’t forget to rate, review & subscribe to us on Apple Podcasts, Stitcher and Spotify. You can also listen to our Stitcher Premium game show Screen Test right now at https://www.stitcher.com/show/unspooled-screen-test and apply to be a contestant at unspooledpod@gmail.com!0 comments0
- Star Wars: The Last JediPaul & Amy force-project into Rian Johnson's galaxy-brained Star Wars entry The Last Jedi! They dissect the disputes between Mark Hamill and Johnson on the fate of Luke Skywalker, praise the film's illustrations of the nature of heroism, and ask if this is up there with the very best of Star Wars. Plus: The origins of porgs. Next week, tune in as we cover 2004's Crash! You can join the conversation for this series on the Unspooled Facebook Group at https://www.facebook.com/groups/unspooledpodcast, and on Paul’s Discord at https://discord.gg/ZwtygZGTa6. Learn more about the show at unspooledpod.com, follow us on Twitter @unspooled and Instagram @unspooledpod, and don’t forget to rate, review & subscribe to us on Apple Podcasts, Stitcher and Spotify. You can also listen to our Stitcher Premium game show Screen Test right now at https://www.stitcher.com/show/unspooled-screen-test and apply to be a contestant at unspooledpod@gmail.com!0 comments0
- Blue VelvetPaul & Amy send a love letter to David Lynch's uncanny 1986 noir Blue Velvet! They learn what Lynch thinks of his "Jimmy Stewart from Mars" image, discuss the film's many connections to The Wizard Of Oz, and ask why we're collectively obsessed with the dark underbelly of everyday life. Plus: What Dennis Hopper role was a 'spiritual sequel' to Frank Booth? Next week, tune in as we cover The Last Jedi! You can join the conversation for this series on the Unspooled Facebook Group at https://www.facebook.com/groups/unspooledpodcast, and on Paul’s Discord at https://discord.gg/ZwtygZGTa6. Learn more about the show at unspooledpod.com, follow us on Twitter @unspooled and Instagram @unspooledpod, and don’t forget to rate, review & subscribe to us on Apple Podcasts, Stitcher and Spotify. You can also listen to our Stitcher Premium game show Screen Test right now at https://www.stitcher.com/show/unspooled-screen-test and apply to be a contestant at unspooledpod@gmail.com!0 comments0
- Unspooled Jan 12 · 1h 17m Jeanne Dielman, 23 quai du Commerce, 1080 BruxellesAmy & Paul peel the layers of Chantal Akerman’s minimalist homebound masterwork Jeanne Dielman! They praise the way Akerman trains her audience to pay attention to tiny details, debate whether the controversial ending was necessary, and ask what the film’s recent ascendancy to the top of Sight & Sound’s greatest films list says about how we live today. Plus: The truth about Tony Orlando and Dawn. Next week, tune in as we discuss Blue Velvet! You can join the conversation for this series on the Unspooled Facebook Group at https://www.facebook.com/groups/unspooledpodcast, and on Paul’s Discord at https://discord.gg/ZwtygZGTa6. Learn more about the show at unspooledpod.com, follow us on Twitter @unspooled and Instagram @unspooledpod, and don’t forget to rate, review & subscribe to us on Apple Podcasts, Stitcher and Spotify. You can also listen to our Stitcher Premium game show Screen Test right now at https://www.stitcher.com/show/unspooled-screen-test and apply to be a contestant at unspooledpod@gmail.com!0 comments0
- Love Actually (re-release)Unspooled will return with new episodes 1/13 - be sure to catch up with "Jeanne Dielman" before we kick off Jeanne-uary, until then enjoy one of our favorite holiday episodes! Paul & Amy cross the pond for 2003’s Christmas romantic comedy smash Love Actually! They dissect director Richard Curtis’s curious understanding of love, learn the fates of each character in the 2017 sequel short, and watch deleted scenes that would have introduced even more plots into the film. Plus: Lindy West discusses her essay “Shit Actually” that kicked off a critical re-evaluation of this movie. You can join the conversation on the Unspooled Facebook Group at https://www.facebook.com/groups/unspooledpodcast, and on Paul’s Discord at https://discord.gg/ZwtygZGTa6. Learn more about the show at unspooledpod.com, follow us on Twitter @unspooled and Instagram @unspooledpod, and don’t forget to rate, review & subscribe to us on Apple Podcasts, Stitcher and Spotify. You can also listen to our Stitcher Premium game show Screen Test right now at https://www.stitcher.com/show/unspooled-screen-test and apply to be a contestant at unspooledpod@gmail.com!0 comments0
- A Christmas Story (re-release)Unspooled will return with new episodes 1/13 - be sure to catch up with "Jeanne Dielman" before we kick off Jeanne-uary, until then enjoy one of our favorite holiday episodes! Paul & Amy unwrap 1983’s holiday nostalgia trip A Christmas Story! They learn about the life of the film’s inspiration Jean Shepherd, discover how the flagpole scene was shot, and ask if a film like this can still hold the attention of kids today. Plus: Michael Dowse, director of “8-Bit Christmas,” tells us about the Christmas films that inspired him. You can join the conversation on the Unspooled Facebook Group at https://www.facebook.com/groups/unspooledpodcast, and on Paul’s Discord at https://discord.gg/ZwtygZGTa6. Learn more about the show at unspooledpod.com, follow us on Twitter @unspooled and Instagram @unspooledpod, and don’t forget to rate, review & subscribe to us on Apple Podcasts, Stitcher and Spotify. You can also listen to our Stitcher Premium game show Screen Test right now at https://www.stitcher.com/show/unspooled-screen-test and apply to be a contestant at unspooledpod@gmail.com!0 comments0
- Die HardPaul & Amy walk across broken glass for 1988's definitive Bruce Willis action film Die Hard! They ask whether Hans Gruber is the true protagonist of the film, learn why Frank Sinatra was originally considered to play John McClane, and explore why this film succeeds where legions of imitators have failed. Plus: we settle the "Christmas movie" debate once and for all. Next week, tune in as we discuss Die Hard! You can join the conversation for this series on the Unspooled Facebook Group at https://www.facebook.com/groups/unspooledpodcast, and on Paul’s Discord at https://discord.gg/ZwtygZGTa6. Learn more about the show at unspooledpod.com, follow us on Twitter @unspooled and Instagram @unspooledpod, and don’t forget to rate, review & subscribe to us on Apple Podcasts, Stitcher and Spotify. You can also listen to our Stitcher Premium game show Screen Test right now at https://www.stitcher.com/show/unspooled-screen-test and apply to be a contestant at unspooledpod@gmail.com!0 comments0
- AvatarAmy & Paul upload their consciousness into 2009’s otherworldly sci-fi spectacle Avatar! They confirm the concept of ‘unobtanium’ wasn’t invented by the film, learn which movie stars were up for the role of Jake Sully, and ask themselves why they feel protective of director James Cameron. Plus: did Cameron really insist the Na’Vi need to have breasts? Next week, tune in as we discuss Die Hard! You can join the conversation for this series on the Unspooled Facebook Group at https://www.facebook.com/groups/unspooledpodcast, and on Paul’s Discord at https://discord.gg/ZwtygZGTa6. Learn more about the show at unspooledpod.com, follow us on Twitter @unspooled and Instagram @unspooledpod, and don’t forget to rate, review & subscribe to us on Apple Podcasts, Stitcher and Spotify. You can also listen to our Stitcher Premium game show Screen Test right now at https://www.stitcher.com/show/unspooled-screen-test and apply to be a contestant at unspooledpod@gmail.com!0 comments0
- Black SwanAmy & Paul reconcile their duality with 2010's Darren Aronofsky ballet thriller Black Swan! They dissect Natalie Portman's full-bodied transformative performance, praise the subtly stunning visual effects, and float three theories for what really happens at the film's end. Plus: What does a swan really sound like? Next week, tune in as we cover the original Avatar! You can join the conversation for this series on the Unspooled Facebook Group at https://www.facebook.com/groups/unspooledpodcast, and on Paul’s Discord at https://discord.gg/ZwtygZGTa6. Learn more about the show at unspooledpod.com, follow us on Twitter @unspooled and Instagram @unspooledpod, and don’t forget to rate, review & subscribe to us on Apple Podcasts, Stitcher and Spotify. You can also listen to our Stitcher Premium game show Screen Test right now at https://www.stitcher.com/show/unspooled-screen-test and apply to be a contestant at unspooledpod@gmail.com!0 comments0
