Hi, I'm here. Are y'all? And this is the near and far podcast. This podcast is about business Behavior. And the Brain on this show, I do a few things. I read, quick articles, I've written about topics shaping, your behavior, I interview authors and books, I enjoy. And from time to time, I devote episodes answering your question if you want to ask me a question. This is a podcast page on iTunes, go to ratings and reviews and ask me a question by leaving a review. I promise to read it and possibly include your question, a future episode. So please ask me anything. Now, enjoy the episode in for more. You can always visit me at near and far.
Maybe social media isn't making teens depressed after all. And here's what likely is Buy near ale narrated by Johnny Heller,
He's with the covid-19 and lockdowns have revealed about Teen depression.
What do bicycles in social media have in common soon after being adopted each of these Technologies brought on a tsunami of unjustified moral Panic. That start with bikes and bicycle is burst onto the Victorian scene in the eighteen-hundreds. They were a big deal to school Contraption made it possible to travel much further and faster than you can have it. Go on foot better, yet bikes for a lot cheaper than horses. Not to mention simpler to maintain soon, enough bicycles, gained popularity with the group, whose Transportation options, at a stork leben, limited women, at that time, if women wanted to get somewhere with that walking, they typically need someone to take them there in a horse and carriage, usually that would be the patriarch of the household and if he was unavailable or unwilling to fluck her fit or stay home,
With bicycles, women could be more independent than ever the awesome right now. According to those in power instead of celebrating the new found Freedom, the bicycle it brought authorities drummed up a spectacular display of moral Panic. Here are the dangers of the bicycle. According to many other eras. Medical experts bicycles would transform women's, feminine gate into a ghastly ugly, walk characterized by a plunging kind of motion. Women would suffer from bicycle face. A permanent consequence of being exposed to the air at superhuman speeds women's delicate bodies, would break down from the strain of riding bicycles, leading to appendicitis infertility and even psychosis in hindsight. These ideas are ridiculous back then, they were widespread fears and they were Amplified by manipulative. People who wanted women to be docile and dependent.
Is social media. The new bicycle fast forward around 125 years today. Many widespread beliefs about modern technology mirror, the Victorian moral panic over bicycles. For example, every parent knows social media is awful for teenagers mental health, but is it in 2017? The Atlantic published an article by Gene twins called. Have smartphones destroy the generation, the article Enviro because it may terrifying claims including teams has been 3 hours a day or more an electronic devices are 35% more likely to have a risk factor for suicide such as making a suicide plan, although excessive social media usage among teens is correlated with higher self-reported mental health issues. The effect is extremely small. In fact, it's so small that it's almost insignificant as I explained in my recent medium, I'll look at the raw data, discussed in that article reveals that the affair
A social media on teen depression is roughly equivalent to the effect of eating potatoes. Unless potatoes are also destroying a generation. Social media is probably not worth the pain credit twins. Recently published an article that's far more measured and accurate. In fact, it powerfully refutes. The claims she made in the 2017 article, the article is a review of a new survey of 1,500 23 teens, which guys in it, how they been doing? Throughout the quarantine, as it turns out teams have been doing surprisingly. Well, during the quarantine that's been especially true. During the school year, rates of depression dropped dramatically as did rates of loneliness between his new research, paper 27% of teens in 2018 were depressed compared to 17% during 2020 with school in session and 20% in 2020 with school out of session.
That's a dramatic Improvement to put that in perspective. Adults were three times more likely to experience. Mental distress, anxiety, or depression. During quarantine did team's improved depression. Numbers result from decreased social media use. Nope, teams are sending the same amount of time on social media. Now, it's before to be totally accurate. Their average amount of social media time, dropped slightly by about 15 minutes a day. It was replaced by other on-screen activities like watching TV. It appears that a foregone conclusion, in trenches original article, showing that team to spend more time. On devices are more likely to have a risk factor for suicide, like they got the causality Reversed. It appears kids more likely to have risk factors for suicide or also those who seek Escape spending more time on their devices.
Why teens are less depressed during quarantine? The research shows that there are likely to explanations for teens reduced rates of depression. While I'm there getting more sleep and to the spending more time with your parents and siblings, drink covid-19 lockdown, experienced an increase in sleep and family time. These changes were much more dramatic than the 15-minute reduction in Daily social media use and according to twins yourself. These two factors are responsible for the Improvement. Mental health from her new article in the Atlantic teens, who are sleep-deprived are significantly more likely to suffer from depression, in 2018. Only 55% of teens said, they usually slept seven or more hours and night during the pan to make this jump to 84% among those for whom school was still in session.
Scientists have known for many years that teenagers naturally tend to wake up later than adults during quarantine didn't 7 waking up later. Just in time, for virtual classes to start, since sleep is a huge factor in depression, it's no surprise that teens are less depressed under these conditions. The other major factors family time, which is also increased during quarantine according to the article. 68% of teens said, their families have become closer to the pandemic. Family closeness was associated with mental health. Only 15% who said their families have become closer, during the pandemic were depressed compared with 27% of those who did not believe their families have become closer.
As it turns out, they extended, quarantine has served as a groundbreaking natural experiment and results are clear. When our kids get more sleep and family time, they're less depressed. Instead of panicking about teens social media use, what if we focused on sleeping family? In other words, what if we paid attention to the real problems? But we don't because the real problems rarely make viral headlines in the coming years. The moral panic over social media will likely continue to distract us from these more important lesson. Sational problems. After all, even though this 2020 research refutes the very same August 2017 article, the old article will probably continue to get more eyeballs. Are we doomed to repeat history? The Victorian moral panic, over bicyclist was a mistake today, we can all see, but at that time the panic and consequences are prevented many people, especially women from being able to exercise their freedom, they deserve many people who could have benefited from using bicycles,
Ended up worse off because of an irrational panic. Over the new technology, social media is a new technology that has sparked a similarly a rational and moral Panic be coming to that Panda has consequences. As just one example data suggests that social media may help reduce suicidality lgbtq + youth because it's Empower them to connect with supportive people and discover that they're not alone. If we should come to moral Panic about social media, we might harm that group. Like the bicycle social media has many benefits and it's unethical to make sweeping claims about its harmfulness without new ones.
Only did one example which is really the irony of ironies in the social dilemma. A recent documentary film that creates moral Panic around social media. Deleting speaker, Tristan Harris reveals his ignorance of the history of how people have reacted to new technologies. Known got upset with bicycles showed up, Harris proclaims. Now, you know, better than Harris did at that moment. You know that lots of people got upset with bicycle showed up, you know, that the outrage was faceless and you know that the moral Panic a real consequences for real people
This time around. Let's avoid repeating history.
Thanks for listening to this episode of the near and far podcast, you can always find more at my blog near and far. Calm and don't forget if you have a question you like me to explore the future episode? Leave me or question the former review or the podcast on iTunes.