Lifelong fans of true crime stories Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark tell each other their favorite tales of murder and hear hometown crime stories from friends and fans.
4 Subscribers
Podcast hosts
No host has claimed this podcast yet, if you are the host you can verify ownership by claiming this podcast
© Exactly Right
My Favorite Murder with Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark
4 Subscribers
Reviews
Deacon YoMouf
1 out of 5 stars
Title is misleading not a crime podcast
I’m about 13 minutes in and all they are doing is talking about anything but a crime or murder. It’s a podcast about 2 women talking about TV shows. I’d pass if you are looking for a crime podcast. If you’re looking for an option pop culture show it’s still weak
Danaheysup1569
5 out of 5 stars
Love them
Thanks for having Billy on! I love this podcast and the community of like minded individuals who are apart of it. It’s comedic, interesting, and relatable.
barrelcactus212
5 out of 5 stars
more criminal collabs please!
have loved you guys from the very beginning. especially loved this criminal crossover episode because i also love phoebe! would love to see more of this!!!! PS for the people giving one star reviews because they discuss their opinions on current events. IT’S THEIR PODCAST. YOU CAN SEE YOURSELF OUT THE DOOR. you people are so ignorant and entitled it’s amazing IF YOU DONT LIKE IT STOP LISTENING LIKE ?????? take a step back and ask yourself why you’re so offended by these women and their views. it’s fine to disagree but you don’t have to be so extremely rude about it? please enlighten me if you care to explain
bkrielwjwu
5 out of 5 stars
My comfort podcast
Some of these reviews are so malicious. These ladies are just doing their best! And they’re doing an amazing job of spreading awareness of all sorts of very important topics. If you don’t agree with their political beliefs or the way they host THEIR OWN podcast, then don’t listen! And don’t comment horrible things about the women just doing their job. You’re just hiding behind your screen putting other human beings down. Anyways:) I love this podcast.
CatC23
3 out of 5 stars
Interviews
I enjoy listening to the show, but the interviews are getting old. They have nothing to do with what the content of the show is supposed to be.
Rhpos
1 out of 5 stars
An hour long advertisement for a movie
What happened to the true crime aspect of this podcast? I still get a kick out of the hometowns that are only tangentially related. I enjoy the survival stories. I appreciate looping in podcasts on the Exactly Right. But listening to a synopsis of a comedy movie for an hour with Billy Eichner? Im queer myself, and I’m interested in watching the movie, but c’mon y’all. This was such a waste of breath and airtime.
MJWass
5 out of 5 stars
The Bar
The not only set the bar high, they are the bar. This show and The Murder Squad are what every other true crime podcast aspires to be.
Angeline Em
5 out of 5 stars
The OG murder podcast
This is truly what I see as the original murder comedy podcast. Karen and Georgia are truly master story tellers and comedians. They are always very respectful of the victims while also keeping things light when they can and making the stories so interesting. I also love that they don’t always just do murder and sometimes tell disaster stories or really cool stories of great people in history that died in weird ways. Truly my favorite podcast forever.
Laur McG
2 out of 5 stars
My new bff's
Update: we’ve gone off the rails. Billy Eichner is blaming America for his movie flopping and literally has nothing to say except “if you don’t see my movie you’re homophobic”. How is this relevant to MFM? This was clearly a paid marketing stunt and that’s sad. I’m here for stories and friends bantering, not some Harvey Weinstein type marketing take over. Gross. Why would I go to the theatre to get Covid or get shot when I can watch comfortably from home? Why? And why is my crime podcast talking about a failing movie, wasting an episode? ——- Original Review: I listen asap when new episodes come out and I kinda feel like the ladies are friends (I'll own the creepiness). I love the banter. Stories are so interesting. Love the raw-mess of the girls acknowledging the complexities of being a working adult female just trying to survive. I'm so glad I found this podcast!!
Hrbenard
5 out of 5 stars
Still My Favorite Podcast
I’ve been a loyal listener since the beginning, and it’s been exciting to witness all the great opportunities that have been afforded them. So happy for their success!
jackiejordan68
1 out of 5 stars
I’m a northern living in the south
Karma ladies…GOOD BYE
Gear smear
1 out of 5 stars
Next!
Georgia and Karen constantly blab about how uneducated they are and in the next breath, spew their moronic opinions about politics, religion, the police, and so on and so forth and what have you. I’ve been listening since like 2018 because some of the stories are fun to listen to but no more. Your podcast has turned into the llllaaaaaaammmmmeeeeessssssssstttt one out there. Read a book! Take a class! Watch less television! You’re also too old for TikTok.
i miss monte python
2 out of 5 stars
Enough with the TDS
Now I remember why I unsubscribed in the first place. Can’t get through one episode with sprinkling in some Trump Derangement Syndrome. Preaching love and acceptance, as long as it agrees with them. Enough with the plandemic already. It’s over and never really began. Get as many shots as you like, you can’t stop the manufactured virus. You were duped by your own government and you are still falling for it. Get your true crime elsewhere because this podcast is a has been if it ever was.
3tre
5 out of 5 stars
The luck
I love the luck of two people meeting and making an empire together coupled with hard work and dedication and talent!!!! I am a total fan girl for Karen ! I relate with her story and thought of view. I love the level of her wit!
Brandy0212
5 out of 5 stars
My Favorite Podcast
I just can’t convey how much you ladies have meant to me. I laugh (literally) out loud nearly every episode and even my husband (farmer) listens while he’s mowing the yard! We are from Kansas and laughed so hard about the suggestion that an ice pick was to clean ice off windshields along with the ice spatula!!!
Laurel Beckett
1 out of 5 stars
Confusing
I tried so hard to get into this show. It is so confusing to listen to-half the time I do not even know what they’re talking about-or what story they’re attempting to tell. The episodes are just set up weird-bantering in the beginning with no actual point to the banter. The descriptions tell you nothing about the show, and I would not recommend this show to anyone.
kenziehart2
5 out of 5 stars
Best podcast ever
Honestly, this was the first podcast I ever listened to, and nothing will ever compare to it. It’s the best ❤️
ali.steele
1 out of 5 stars
25 min in and nothing
25 minutes in and they haven’t even got to the topic…..🥱🥱🥱. Just random banter and commercials going on for 25 minutes now. Insane.
indianprideandlove
1 out of 5 stars
Carol Jenkins story
I was very impressed with the show and the way y’all were embracing the story. Very hurt with peoples heartless harm they due to our beautiful children no matter the race or color of skin. Very disappointed once FOX news was brought up. Step back and focus on the human behind the pain and stop pointing fingers on blame!! I stopped listening.
pretty good but has flaws
4 out of 5 stars
Less chit chat
Good show but it would be better if they spent a bit more time telling the true crime story instead of chatting for 20-40 minutes at the beginning.
Sit down Karen
2 out of 5 stars
Stay in Your Lane
I have loved this podcast over the years and I regret to say I can no longer recommend it. It is so tiresome to hear Karen and Georgia continually complain about how hard it is to podcast over Zoom, when not only is this no longer especially necessary, I can’t think of a job less likely to be impacted by the pandemic. Add to that their constant virtue signaling and lack of understanding that despite their woke racism, they cannot get inside the black experience. Sit down, Karen. We do not need you to do explain this for us. Lastly, since the inception of their podcast network and presumably hiring more staff writers, it is missing the spontaneity and comedy of the original podcast. Mostly it is just a dreary recitation of basic historical facts, likely as not to have anything to do with true crime. They have undoubtedly lost their fire and their way. Sorry to say, maybe time is up.
Seacandy
5 out of 5 stars
Fun listening
Enjoy the banter.
e.gr510
1 out of 5 stars
I saw the light
I was a big fan of this podcast for awhile, but over the past year I had to stop listening. I was able to push past certain feelings that some of the things said about the crimes and victims and perpetrators crossed the line, but I truly believe this podcast is unethical now. I understand what they are trying to do, but I don’t think the way they approach the subject comes from a genuine place and isn’t treated with the respect it deserves. I’m honestly disappointed with myself that I listened for so long. If you want true crime, please consider getting it from a more ethical source that this podcast.
HWooDeedoo
5 out of 5 stars
Meow_meow_me_meow
Hello! First time reviewer, listener since episode 1. That’s right. Ep 1 my friends. I’m also a recovering morally injured, burned-out, jobless healthcare provider. All that school for….. (Would not have made it as far as I did without the show). As the show evolves, the organic banter between Karen and Georgia still causes kitten-startling, out loud bursts of laughter. All fun aside, I hope you continue to passionately support the beauty of diversity and shed light and lift up those who have no voice. The worst isn’t over and we need you. And we LOVE you from the bottom of our crime-obsessed hearts. Xoxo Gossip. wait.
Lziod
1 out of 5 stars
Virtuous hypocrites
The ladies have made a successful podcast and benefit from death, violence/story telling, picking off flesh from victim bones to enrich themselves while lecturing us on politics and religion from their mansions. Two wealthy privileged women profiting from victim’s stories and virtue signaling. No thanks.
Tere68
5 out of 5 stars
Las amó
Thank you and the team for everything you do!
L.mskifree
5 out of 5 stars
Favorite gals
This is my favorite podcast and has been for years. I feel I’m catching up with friends and true crime. Thanks ladies!
JaeJ91
5 out of 5 stars
Love it
I love this podcast the girls make it not gruesome and they are funny! I had finished the Love Murder podcast and tried to find another true crime podcast but I couldn’t get into a lot of the ones I tried but I’m really I to this one.
no nick name 2
1 out of 5 stars
Clueless
The latest episode is the last one I’ll listen to. Great to hear that Georgia is aware that psychopaths ruled the world, and they still do. Might want to question the false narrative of electric vehicles being the answer and do a little research into that one…here’s a heads up: the batteries require massive mining efforts to get the raw materials needed: lithium, cobalt, nickel, manganese and graphite. Wait! There’s more! Electric vehicles have been known to explode (in flames!!) while charging. Both of these women live in California, where very recently folks were told to reduce their power usage because the grid was incapable of supplying to the demand. Where do you think the power comes from to charge an E.V? Used to be a fun podcast, now it’s just a display of extremist left self righteous hostility. Right or left, the whole bird is sick. Wake up ladies.
{ system }
2 out of 5 stars
Was Good but….
It was a amazing show but then the politics arrived and it no longer feels like a warm and cozy place to listen to true crime without have to worry about politics, war, etc. but now a good 50% of the show is politics come on ladys!
g76132
1 out of 5 stars
Would give 0 stars if I could
They literally talk about random stuff for 30 minutes and then talk about the crime for 10 and then get off topic. Save your time and listen to a different murder podcast unless you care about random unrelated chatter. They need to learn to stay on topic
csutter1963
5 out of 5 stars
Super disappointed
The first podcast I was addicted to. If you really started a podcast for crime/murder, Stay in your lane. Politics are not your forte Sad I have to unfollow
BeeWrite
5 out of 5 stars
MFM is the True Crime Goat
I’ve been listening for literal years and haven’t left a review. So, I owe (at the very least) this to Karen and Georgia for all the A+ content creation. Comedy is on point. I come for the true crime and stay for the commentary. Feels like they are friends. Love their book/ show recommendations. All around best true crime podcast. Love you guys!
mmmkrara
4 out of 5 stars
Georgia stop gasping
It’s ruining Karen’s story
alexbran1
4 out of 5 stars
Enjoyable but some false info
In a recent episode she says something along the lines of “let’s not forget you can go to jail for having a miscarriage in todays times” that’s simply 100% untrue. Other than that false information these two have great storytelling capabilities and keep the listener engaged
Scrabblerunner
5 out of 5 stars
Episode 345. So. Good.
Thanks for focusing on two stories of social justice and the general darkness of societal and corporate systems. You guys outdid yourselves with this episode. 💪
Bunnibuns
5 out of 5 stars
Let the haters hate
6 years later still loving every second of this podcast. Was here from day 1 and am so impressed by the integrity that both of these amazing women have upheld all these years. To all those complaining about politics, go listen to something else then. It’s hypocritical and honestly, all these women ever say is that human life matters and so does our earth. If you can’t get with that, then maybe go read a book or two. Also Murderinos love their banter, it’s nice to hear about the latest news/shows/books and snippets of their lives. We love feeling like we’re part of a conversation amongst best friends.
jkjsmom
5 out of 5 stars
Sooo happy I found you
I am hooked! But I’m so behind. I’m on episode seventeen and love these girls so much. I can’t stop listening every chance I get.
bellemscott
5 out of 5 stars
This podcast changed my life
I love love LOVE mfm. I listen to them any chance I get. Any one star reviews you see are mostly from hateful right wing bigots who don’t like that these lovely ladies are educated, sensitive, and feminist badasses. Part of being a responsible true crime fan nowadays is educate yourself and see the horrible flaws within the system, and these women point them out bravely and donate generously to the right places. Do yourself a favor and listen to Karen and Georgia talk about the best and worst of humanity, while they fill your life up with smiles, belly laughs, and tears. SSDGM
Kerri Bassett
1 out of 5 stars
?
This is my very first time listening to this podcast. I’ve been listening for 15 minutes, and all I’ve heard is chitchat between the ladies about favorite movies they like, who looks like them in the movie, the parties they went to etc. and I haven’t even heard anything about the actual show. I don’t know them, and I’m not interested in all of that chitchat. I decided I don’t want to go through that for every episode so I will not follow them any longer. Don’t even know how the show is I never got that far.
knottyourmama
2 out of 5 stars
Ugh…
Always loved this podcast. It was my #1 go-to no matter what. I’ve had to stop several episodes recently due to political and religious biases. They have every right to their opinion, and despite some differences over the years, I’ve always loved them and listened to every episode—more than once! But I find it harder to listen to them week by week. They don’t want to people to “hate” others over differences but all they do is hate demographics that don’t fit inline with their beliefs. Just disappointed…
Fraggle 44
5 out of 5 stars
If you need a pick me up, listen
I have listened for years based off a recommendation from a friend and honestly I’m upset I didn’t find this podcast sooner. I feel extremely loyal to MFM that I really don’t listen to any other podcasts so thank you Karen and Georgia keep being the erratic, comical, supporting selves! Stay Sexy and don’t listen to any other podcasts
senoritapalomar
5 out of 5 stars
Lovely
Love the pod and the hosts. Great work!
Adepree
5 out of 5 stars
Long time listener, first review though
Loved you then, loved you now. Always have, always will. SSDGM.
YourFathaa
3 out of 5 stars
Stop forcing buried bones!
Love this podcast but I hate that they always go above on marketing for a podcast in their network. it’s a hard no
Kjsalmon
5 out of 5 stars
Love the storytelling format
I’m late to the party here, but loving it. This is the only true-crime podcast I listen to and I love it for the way they tell the story. I don’t walk away feeling freaked out (usually). Both are great storytellers and I love hearing their natural reactions along the way.
Raquelllll
5 out of 5 stars
My favorite podcast!
At first, I was skeptical listening to my first episode, thinking “just get to the murders already!” but I’m glad I stuck around. The witty banter in the beginning is now my favorite part! Not many podcasts can make me laugh especially while also intriguing me!
CPG24J
2 out of 5 stars
Yawner
So many better ones out there
JenEBrooks94
1 out of 5 stars
Boring & Pushing their Political Agenda
I was excited to find another true crime podcast but this isn’t it. Stories aren’t exciting and it takes 20+ minutes to even get into them. Also not sure why you guys feel the need to push your political beliefs. You talk like the majority of America is liberal. You’re chasing off so many listeners.
WilliMia
5 out of 5 stars
Late to the party but loving it!
Second Review: Still loving it 6 months later. I think I’m up to about 125-150 episodes, both old and new. The way they’ve evolved over the years is pretty amazing. I love that they don’t do just murder stories, their banter is still there, and they talk openly about their mental health tribulations and more. And I’ve learned a lot from their stories. Still got lots to finish and looking forward to them all. I will say..they’re not perfect, but then again, no one is, and you’re never going to find that in a podcast. However they’re doing what they love and I love listening to them. First Review: I’ve only been listening for about a week now and am binging as much as possible. I’ve listened to both old and new episodes, plus have read articles, reviews, FB post etc to see why this particular podcast is so blown up. I love the banter (even though initially I didn’t) and appreciate the raw honesty of most of the opinions from K & G. I also how so much has evolved over the episodes (I’ve listened to about 30 already). Unfortunately this topic isn’t a “fun” or “easy” one, and I feel as the banter/opinions help ease the pain of it. Also…it’s their show and they can do what they want with it (that’s aimed at those who complain). SSDGM
Lovemfm
5 out of 5 stars
5 strz
I love them so much and I’m so grateful for them every week. They bring me so much joy & I’ve been listening to them since the beginning.
RicaOvens
1 out of 5 stars
Left a while ago
Was a loyal listener from the beginning, left during election time…. Finally came back to see if the politics were gone since Trump is out of office. Sadly they’re still barfing up politics and I will never listen again unfortunately.
debday111
1 out of 5 stars
I can never get my wasted time back
First time and last time listener. # 344, 20 plus minutes in and they are still talking themselves.
Rebekahbt
3 out of 5 stars
Love this podcast. But...
Third review; I’ve been a listening since day one. And, I’m so happy things have settled into a rythem we can count on. But, always a but, Katen, have you decided you just can’t produce a story that isn’t uplifting? The podcast you started AND sold to Wondery was “My favorite Murder” not my favorite survival story. That’s a different podcast. If that’s what you want? Then do that. But, please stop trying to reinvent a genre you heartily pushed forward. Second Reveiw:4 stars It seems the girls have run out of material. And, I agree it’s difficult in a pandemic to hold your focus but, shorting the full episode to just one case? It seems to cheapen the honor of your first enthusiasm. Good luck but, I hope you’re efforts will bring me bad as the rabid fan I was until recently. First Reveiw: 5 stars These women are strong in opinion and in language. I appreciate the humor and compassion that is constantly on board. It’s very entertaining and you feel like your sitting around with friends talking. It does get frustrating though... 1). I like the hometown Murders better than the 1 1/2 hours of the ladies mispronunciations and swearing. It’s really almost unbearable when Georgia tries to lead you through a case that is it a language other than English. It might be my own fault that I get hung up on whose doing what but, Karen jumps in from a totally different directions and, well ... sometimes I just have to skip to the next ‘home town Murders’ because those are interesting and yet sometimes hit close to home. But, in the end for me I ask God to rest the souls that are spoken about here in this podcast. I’m grateful for the information and entertainment. And, Georgia to learn French. I love you ladies. Thank you for your efforts!
Lobomama
2 out of 5 stars
Love these two!
I came for the murder and stayed for the wonderful hosts. They are hilarious, compassionate and brilliant! Can't wait to see them Live!! Re-review: I haven’t listened in a couple years. It was really great in the beginning. I especially loved Karen’s story telling. But I get it everyone needs time off and has to make money.
raftwoman
5 out of 5 stars
MFM
The OG still is the best
JennyBomb
1 out of 5 stars
The appeal is gone
I have been a long time murderino (since the shows inception). I get the the hosts are growing and changing, and I can respect their need for that. However the show has completely gone in a different direction. We are rarely getting murder content these days and the hosts now have other people doing all of their research. The original years were just so endearing because the hosts seemed so committed and put in the effort. Now they come off as sellouts who have no desire to put in any effort for what we all originally came here for. The original banter is long gone and Georgia’s search for bougie wallpaper seems more important that providing good content. At this point it seems the hosts are just doing this for money and that’s not what the show initially seemed based on. I understand they became popular and found a way to make a living doing this, but partnering with Amazon and ignoring the content we all came here for is rather unfortunate. I sadly am unsubscribing and moving on to better content.
Top Internet Marketer
1 out of 5 stars
Annoying
Annoying hosts who try to be funny but they aren’t off script.
Clamshell614
1 out of 5 stars
The World is Ending
THE WORLD IS ENDING says everyone living in Los Angeles. Liberal hysteria abounds. Georgia Hardstark is an obnoxious, self obsessed idiot. Karen is a lecturing, self righteous, judgemental hypocrite.
unagi17
3 out of 5 stars
Why didn’t I know about this
THIS right here is the most comforting podcast! They make you feel like you are their best friend! They have gotten me over bad times in my life. Soo f’ing funny and great life advice! These are the murders I came for! The comedy along with all the murder one could want! 10/10 have recommended to friends!
MangoTheGoat
1 out of 5 stars
Horrible; blabbing on about nothing
I tried listening for a few minutes but couldn’t go further. Mostly heard the F word, “Like”, “Yeah”, “Right?”, and babble about really dumb crap. When do they get to the information the show is supposed to be about? Who listens to this garbage and how do these girls get sponsors?
PNWgal525
5 out of 5 stars
Love MFM
I started listening to MFM when the pandemic hit and I went from working in a large, busy office to working from home. I enjoyed them so much I decided to go back and start from Episode 1. They never disappoint and their rapport is so natural and fun, it’s like hanging out with friends and they always make me laugh. Their advocacy for women’s rights, minority rights and mental health is an added bonus. I highly recommend if you haven’t listened yet!
maverso
1 out of 5 stars
Would live to listen but I’m a Misunderstood Republican
I loved this podcast until they kept bashing Republicans. Im “triggered” (🤪) by the hateful comments about anyone who doesn’t follow their ideology.
daddykrisluvhoes
5 out of 5 stars
My favorite podcast ever
I don’t like listening to podcast. I’m super ADHD which leads me to always turning off podcasts. But this one!!!! I’m always so interested. I tell all my friends and family about this podcast. I hope they continue forever.
82!.jendu
1 out of 5 stars
25 Minutes of Talking at the Beginning???
This podcast would be great if they didn’t spend the first half hour talking about nothing.
babsybell
5 out of 5 stars
MFM fan day 1
Karen and Georgia are so fun and fantastically amazing with their/our murder stories.
your mom's muff
1 out of 5 stars
Oldest fan
I’m a longtime listener and now I only listen when I want to be validated about my life decisions. These chicks have a dream job but they’re just sad, angry, old alcoholics. Thank goodness I quit drinking and had children...listening reminds me of what my life could be like. Also, they legitimately think women that have miscarriages are going to jail. Only a childless hag would believe something so stupid and untrue. I probably should give 5 stars for the public service they provide to young women.
Chelsea467654
5 out of 5 stars
Love + Hurt
Love this podcast and these ladies. Will always support and listen. However the constant negative comments towards Republicans and the unvaccinated are really hurtful and unnecessary. It’s not okay to lump two wide ranging groups and paint them with the same untrue and negative paintbrush. Please do better. It’s 2022. Let’s respect others’ differences.
KristinB1980
1 out of 5 stars
Ignorant politics
Political garbage not true crime.
hgreen83
5 out of 5 stars
BEST EVER!!
My favorite podcast!! 😁 These ladies are hilarious and it’s so satisfying to see the MFM animations on IG. Proud murderino and fan cult member. What did I give my niece before she went to college?? MFM merch
velocitygirl203
1 out of 5 stars
Too political
Came for the crime, left when it got political.
Small Town Girl 44
2 out of 5 stars
Politics
I stopped listening because they started talking politics. You are entitled to your opinion, but I don’t listen to podcasts to hear about them.
Madie2211
5 out of 5 stars
The Best Thing To Ever Happen To Me
Started listening in 2017, haven’t stopped since! I suggest this podcast to anyone and everyone i can. Karen and Georgia feel like the older sisters I never had. SSDGM for ever ❤️❤️❤️
Ali Baba 88
5 out of 5 stars
Entertaining and Informative
So I used to be one of those listeners who skipped “the small talk” and just enjoyed the stories (which are awesome) but now I love hearing what the girls are up to - I especially appreciate the recommendations for various other podcasts, movies, TV shows, books, etc. Karen & Georgia have never steered my wrong. I look forward to hearing them every week - these women brighten my day like nothing else! Keep up the great work, K & G. SSADGM.
EsscentiallyE
5 out of 5 stars
My Favorite !
This podcast keeps me going throughout my day as a mail carrier I continuously scare myself while walking but that’s exactly why I am a fan ! The story telling is amazing , the two of you are beyond entertaining, the commentary is Life ! Thank you ! Your ending tags are my favorite stay sexy & don’t get murdered !! Genius!!!
esk334
1 out of 5 stars
It’s changed but we all know that...
It’s their show, they can do what they want. They’re awesome. I don’t look forward to new episodes anymore, stopped paying for the fan cult and unsubscribed. Karen is hilarious- she’s a great comedian and very witty! Georgia….I’m sure is smart but she comes off as very unintelligent when attempting to be funny.
Bill 1986
1 out of 5 stars
Keep your political views to yourself
Listening to show & out of no where it turned political.
toxicamie
5 out of 5 stars
10 / 10. Would recommend.
This is the only podcast that I love & look forward to listening to every single week. I’ve been a fan / “murderino” ever since the very first episode. This was the very first podcast that I ever listened to, too, & I’ve been loyal to Karen, Georgia, Steven!, & the pets, even up to now. These guys are so funny, entertaining, generous, definitely respected by the amazing community that they’ve created, etc. A1 content. LONG LIVE ELVIS!!! 🍪❤️
mollyleee
5 out of 5 stars
I just love Elvis
If nothing else, I could listen to Elvis every week 🐈
Megan Tuttle
3 out of 5 stars
St. Elmo’s Fire
With no fire
sad123445894
1 out of 5 stars
I miss my girls
Why do you keep putting up podcasts with other people? We want to hear Karen and Georgia. Never Paul holes pls……so boring….fame has gotten to your heads. I miss the OG Karen and Georgia. Also since when is a tornado a murder?
TamiGC
2 out of 5 stars
Too little murder
The podcast OFTEN doesn’t cover murders anymore. They used to occasionally tell a survival or disaster story, but now they often tell non-murder stories. The mini episodes don’t talk about murder at all. I wish it was a different podcast so I could unsubscribe to it. The banter has become only media suggestions (I think because the women work together so much). I’m going stay subscribed for a few more months, but I’m not excited to see them in my feed anymore.
blynn1989
1 out of 5 stars
Why do they talk so much???
Just tried listening to an episode and am 20 minutes in and they haven’t even started the episode…they’re talking about jelly beans?
MadPT17
1 out of 5 stars
Long time listener quickly over it
The early episodes are great but recently it’s been too much chat, self promotion, commercial and business. The focus is off the stores and the jokes they are very removed and it’s not as funny.
NoThanksLadies
1 out of 5 stars
Jumped the shark
I was a loyal listener since the beginning but have fully stopped at this point— I can’t get down with the sellout to Amazon. Karen and Georgia are fully corporate LA at this point, and it’s extremely obvious both in their storytelling and in their business decisions. The worst political mix of being super pro-police/criminal justice/death penalty while pretending to be super woke liberals. No. Their banter and politics never really bothered me (in that it took up a lot of the episode) but good God, mean what you say.
SR-0884-4406
3 out of 5 stars
Problems here
The two hosts are so self aggrandizing - it never gets old. I check in occasionally. Roseanne and what’s her face have a great dynamic and I’m jealous of their success tbh. They’re phoning it in and asking for money from listeners at every corner… . I just listened to their most recent “hometown stories” and they congratulated a writer’s account of being underage, calling 911 before pulling over by an officer despite drunk driving And attempting to drink from an open container simultaneously. Turns out they were about to be abused by an off-duty police officer, but were saved by the good cops, according to the writer. That’s a “lesson” for listeners, according to MFM. Phew.
double R double T
3 out of 5 stars
Sort by old to new
Older episodes were great but it started trending down around summer 2020. Lots of politics, meh interviews instead of stories and just generally stories that aren’t true crime. Why are we listening to stories about tornados? Gave it 3 stars for the first three years of good podcasts.
ctinashort
5 out of 5 stars
Tirle
Reviewed
alexasean
1 out of 5 stars
Long time listener till around 2020
I use to religiously listen to this show and even loved Karen and Georgias banter before the stories. Now this just feels like a platform for to push their political agenda. It’s ironic cause they always talk about they were outcast or didn’t feel accepted yet they let it me known that anyone who doesn’t agree with them politically are idiots and not welcome.
Mirpandakay
2 out of 5 stars
Too much squirreling
They blather on and on, chasing too many squirrels. It feels like an eternity has passed before they get to the actual true crime portion of the podcast.
ValM55
5 out of 5 stars
Intro
Talk as much as you guys want! I love listening to you guys!
Hernandez Alu
5 out of 5 stars
I adore this podcast !
I love the format, and I love you ladies. The witty banter and intriguing stories are the only things that get me through my workday. For everyone whining about politics: Calm down! The idea that politics and entertainment may never intertwine is outdated and silly. (Besides, I think it's noble that they use their platform to talk about issues close to their hearts! It's inane to expect them to keep quiet.)
Kizzdogg
5 out of 5 stars
Fan forever
Two gems on a podcast that doesn’t get old for me.
Nicinny
3 out of 5 stars
Love these gals but…
Can we get back to more murder stories
fdjivdukbiogdstg
5 out of 5 stars
Love since day one
Amazingly real hosts
Killer Kill! B
1 out of 5 stars
Way too much side talk
It was 15 min. Into a episode and they were still talking about random topics. This is supposed to be a podcast about murder and not about what color hair they have.
Sniper1551
1 out of 5 stars
Can we focus on the murder story?
And less on personal sidebar stories please. Guess this kind of podcast is just not my thing.
TanyaMac
1 out of 5 stars
Shameful
These two are absolutely awful with their non-stop babbling about themselves. A couple of problematic, low class valley girls. Tacky merch too. Seriously a “favorite” murder. Sick!
Happy tot
5 out of 5 stars
New forever fan
Love you no banning books stance
Flute girl Izzy
5 out of 5 stars
SSDG AND LISTEN TO THIS PODCAST
Karen and Georgia have cultivated the most important podcast in my life. Not only do they make me laugh even when I feel like crying, the offer advice and commentary that is incredibly poignant and thought provoking. These women convinced me (someone who thought therapy just didn’t work for her) to go back and try again — and I’m so much better for it. I’ve taken so much from them and applied it to my own life and am not only happier, but love myself more. These women do more than tell scary stories of real life monsters, they inspire their listeners to take back their lives and push through what may seem like the darkest times. These two continue to inspire and educate not just me, but millions all over the planet. Whether you like true crime or not, everyone can take something away from an episode of MFM. Thank you, Karen and Georgia, for being the light at the end of the tunnel for so many.
Heiditruecrime71
1 out of 5 stars
Get to the point
23 minutes not even at the story yet and now a commercial… done
TWaradesigns
1 out of 5 stars
When does the story start???
I’m all fine with playful banter and commentary but it takes 20-30 minutes to even introduce the story…I came for true crime I don’t care about your weekend plans and random inside jokes unrelated….
Hamlair
5 out of 5 stars
truly the best
these ladies have kept me company for the past 5 years and i can’t thank them enough
ingting
1 out of 5 stars
Dumb
This podcast is truly appalling . Completely unprofessional and beyond simply dumb
Lututu2
5 out of 5 stars
My decompress ladies
I truly would listen to Karen read the phone book. These two make me laugh Sometimes I wish for a follow to something they maybe said 100 episodes ago and why they think now. But I don’t listen in any order so I probably wouldn’t hear it anyway. My favorite podcast !
bkemdano72
5 out of 5 stars
What a witty duo!
My partner turned me onto this recently and I am now addicted Now all other podcasts pale in comparison. These two are so quick witted and play off each others humor perfectly. Thanks for making me belly laugh and have other commuters questioning my sanity on the daily.
yawNhairdresser
5 out of 5 stars
Theory
The intro music clip like brings the heavy pandemic vibe, just observation. Love the show.
gracekobe
5 out of 5 stars
The best of the best
Listened for 4 years now, loved it then, love it now. Amazing.
Pro Assasin
5 out of 5 stars
Hauntingly Hilarious
Funny and intelligent woman who provide a new perspective on murder story telling. It’s like having a conversation with friends over margs. 10/10 recommend
Meaningful Spaces
2 out of 5 stars
Narrow minded but think they aren’t
At the end of episode #341 hosts act so upset about people being forced to do something that is wrong and harmful. All the while spending the last two years encouraging people to do just that. Do something new and experimental that didn’t sit right with them. And now that being proven to be scientifically accurate! Hmmmm imagine. I do enjoy the story telling but hate them adding their politics to most shows in such a judgemental way. But it’s there show.
Seaquito
5 out of 5 stars
GOAT
The GREATEST podcast of all time…my absolute favorite! Karen and Georgia are quite the dynamic duo that never cease to get me to laugh out loud - no matter where I am listening! Love their support towards taking care of your mental health. ❤️
lisa happy cat
5 out of 5 stars
Love!
Love you guys! Banter is so funny, new besties!
heatherbc911
5 out of 5 stars
Messy
Calm down Ladies, we are all messy!
Make it Magical Pod
5 out of 5 stars
Still One of the Best!
I have been listening to MFM since the very beginning and I can easily say that this still continues to be one of my favorite podcasts! Keep up the amazing work Karen and Georgia!
stchavez12
1 out of 5 stars
It’s a No for me
25 minutes before they get to the actual story, that’s not gonna work for me.
Roma Lou
1 out of 5 stars
No longer #1
After starting they’re own network and growing they’re platform, MFM has become so political. It’s no longer a true crime podcast that I look forward to hearing. If you fast forward beyond the political banter, the stories are ok.
yhas crime junkie gals!
5 out of 5 stars
Still Going Strong
These ladies are still killing it. I enjoy listening today as much as I did day one. I personally love their beginning banter and updates. Keep going and PLEASE tour soon! 💖
Candra1
5 out of 5 stars
Amazing content from 2016 to present
I have always enjoyed listening to their banter. Now that they have ventured out into including interviews, it’s gives us all a chance to listen to new voices and also gain important information. True crime and murder will always be political and I’m so proud of Karen and Georgia for not shying away from that. They are fully aware of their outreach and how to use their voices, now bringing on expert voices, it’s a great comfort. I’ve been a listener since summer 2020, while I was studying for my boards exam. The show has only gotten better and I can’t wait to see them in person one day.
Emily.M92
1 out of 5 stars
Used to love this Pod
I really used to love this podcast and listened religiously every week from the beginning. However over the years they have become what they claimed to hate: Judgmental and intolerant of anyone who does agree with their beliefs and politics. The podcast has become increasingly political in a really negative way and it’s hardly about true crime anymore. Makes me sad!
0812!
1 out of 5 stars
I wanted to like this
Too much banter. The few episodes I tried to listen to the beginning conversations lasted 10-30 minutes. I was quite annoyed. And it’s hard to follow stories when there’s side conversations/input constantly happening.
jomf780
4 out of 5 stars
Take your breaks!
I think summer breaks are valuable to the show. The bonus content over the summer was interesting, fresh and entertaining. Even more important, Karen and Georgia just seem so much more relaxed and interested in the stories when they return. The shows since returning from the break have been great. Can’t wait for the return of live shows!
meason33
5 out of 5 stars
Five stars
Love!!!!
4nogoodreason
1 out of 5 stars
Run Paul, Run...
Run Paul Holes.... these people have perverse moral compasses and are blind to it...
London_A_93
1 out of 5 stars
Said Goodbye in 2020
I stopped listening in 2020 after being a loyal listener since the beginning. The conversation strayed from true crime with funny banter and became way too political. I loved listening originally because it was an escape from the everyday stresses of the world. Karen & Georgia used their platform to push their agenda & political ideology while putting down those who didn’t agree with them which also meant they talked down on their listeners who didn’t have the same views as them. I have not come back to listen as it left a bad taste in my mouth from their blatant disrespect for those with differing views and the pull away from enjoyable, lighthearted humor. I will likely never listen again but am choosing to leave a review so people know what they will be in for of they do listen.
whitneyv05
2 out of 5 stars
All good things must come to an end
After last summer’s burned out and disgruntled break where they only played repeat or live episodes, I was excited to hear Georgia and Karen back at it it. However, as time went on the intro banter got longer, the burnout and disdain became more apparent, and they’ve taken another break to be filled with only interviews and listener stories. I think it’s safe to say the show has come to a natural end. Listening is like being in someone’s house where there’s that uncomfortable feeling that you’re not wanted there. I recommend Small Town Murder where their content has only gotten better and more frequent as the years have gone on, their research is top notch, and they’re still enthusiastic about their podcast.
Queen-la-tiffa
2 out of 5 stars
Next
14 minutes into the show and no sign of an actual story is anywhere in sight. Way too much of two friends talking and not enough true crime.
zobeatron014
1 out of 5 stars
Filled with Misandry and emotional opinions presented as fact.
It’s beyond sad to hear these women ruin true crime stories filling grey space with emotional opinions presented as fact accompanied by misandry. Ruined the entire experience.
meegdc
1 out of 5 stars
Quintessential Hollywood liberals
Telling everyone in America what they should feel bad about and what they should care about and what they need to cancelHow would all of us good people know how to behave without guidance from experts like these two hosts ? It’s a one two punch -First they’re gonna apologize for 15 minutes for something that they said… not because they had an epiphany .. but because it’s issue X is trending on social media and / or person or persons have targeted them directly to let them know how indenture they are -A word they used… A word they didn’t use… A word they should’ve used last year but definitely shouldn’t have used this year… It’s sad.
bkwhite7
5 out of 5 stars
Ervil Labaron
Just listened for the first time. Learned so much about Ervil Labaron and his murder spree. My dad was actually Rulon Allred’s body guard and came to pick him up from his office. Rulon wasn’t ready to leave and so my dad walked around the block. By the time he came back to the office, Rulon was dead.
gtoaaahh
5 out of 5 stars
One of my Fav Podcasts!
I love that you have a balance between friendly, upbeat banter and true crime. I feel like I’m listening in with a talk with my best friends. Without the banter, the true crime would feel overwhelming to me so I’m glad there’s a good mix :) Been my favorite podcast for years and still continues to be my favorite
lesliearuiz
5 out of 5 stars
My absolute favorites
My absolute favorite podcast ever. Karen and Georgia are the best. I’m so sad that I’ve caught up to real time. Now I’m going to join the fan cult because I can’t get enough! Edited: I’m going on 3 times of restarting from the beginning!
ashley_twig
5 out of 5 stars
Not Just Murder!
I love this show. I always feel like I’m just catching up with friends and hearing crazy stories (in the best way)! This team handles true crime in a way that is so considerate and thoughtful. They confront injustices to minorities as well as mental health, all while using humor to survive & thrive. I’ve been listening for years now and will probably continue even after they stop making new episodes. Stay sexy & listen to this podcast!!
fayyyyy..
1 out of 5 stars
so bad
just so bad
GinGin501
2 out of 5 stars
Talk extremely too much…
I rally want to like this podcast, but they talk extremely too much about their personal lives. This is a supposed to be a crime podcasts.
kenny01918171
1 out of 5 stars
To long of an intro
I don’t want to wait 20 minutes to you to get to the point. I want crime.
SniffelBug
5 out of 5 stars
🎈
Love you two!
jkmkkm
2 out of 5 stars
Too much extemporaneous chatter
Just do the show. I don’t need to know about your family playing Trivial Pursuit.
Melanie Melugin
2 out of 5 stars
Ugh
Way too much talking - not enough of the crime drama. I tried. I really did. But this most recent episode, they talked over 10 minutes about nothing. Cue the F bombs.
krp1993
1 out of 5 stars
Drop the politics
This was my favorite podcast for the longest time. Now it’s 40 mins of small talk and so much putting down people who think differently. Trust me we know your political beliefs and we’re glad you have them but my gosh not everyone agrees with you! I took a year off from listening hoping to come back to a better podcast but it’s worse. Sad because they used to be such good crime stories but why would I listen when I have to hear how awful of a person I am for some of my beliefs for 20 mins every darn episode
cmmmm56
2 out of 5 stars
Stick to the crime
I listened to this podcast as an escape. Now it’s too political and judgmental. I love hearing different opinions and different ways of thinking don’t get me wrong, but the way they ridicule and talk down about different beliefs is too far. It’s like I’m being personally judged for thinking or believing a different way. I will miss Karen and Georgia, but can’t deal with the ill humored political talk. I wish they would just stick to the crime talk.
Christinedo53
5 out of 5 stars
Love it!
One of my favorite podcast! I’ve been listening through all the episodes. I’ll soon be completely caught up. I like the casual conversations these ladies have along with the true crime stories. It’s entertaining.
bweight71
1 out of 5 stars
Not what it was…
Use to love this podcast but then it’s like they peaked at year 2-3 and now 👎🏼. We are so inundated with politics everywhere, the last thing we needs is a very one sided opinion spewed at you on every episode when all we want is to escape it! This is were most people who find fame go wrong. They don’t stay in their lane. Way too much talking and less and less true crime. I unsubscribed and unfollowed these two on all social media. It’s too bad. You guys use to be awesome.
caitlin4257
2 out of 5 stars
It used to be great
This is the first podcast that really stuck for me, and I listened avidly for four years, but I just can’t anymore. I’m so tired of constant advertisements for their network, cross-promotion, I miss just listening to stories. I can’t support this podcast anymore.
Mrstashab
5 out of 5 stars
The best podcast
MFM is indeed my favorite podcast of all the podcasts to which I listen. <3
Nikkohusky
1 out of 5 stars
PURE BANTER
After 30 minutes and they were still babbling about nonsense. And the giggling to fill in the time is awful. This podcast is done
Rush + L
1 out of 5 stars
Please stop getting so political!
I loved this show and the banter between Georgia and Karen, it has gotten me through so many long car rides and hard days. Lately, however, it has just gotten way too political. Don’t get me wrong, I respect your beliefs but it makes me feel alienated and hated as a listener just because I have different views from you politically. It makes me sad every time y’all prong up politics because I know you will say something uncalled for and so rude and hurtful of anyone who votes differently than you or has different views from you and it’s just not worth it anymore. Listen to Morbid or Wife of Crime instead, far less political and hateful.
CandaceEP
1 out of 5 stars
Tacky
I tried to listen to My Favorite Murder and couldn’t get halfway through the first episode because their humor was gross to me. They were talking about how sad Adam Walsh’s murder was but in the same breath said that was why they were going to have five kids…in case one kid was murdered. I was done.
PaigeA12345
1 out of 5 stars
Just no
Had to fast forward THIRTY minutes to get to the story. Just to listen to someone read off a poorly researched script and be unnecessarily interrupted every 2 minutes.
Arizzona
5 out of 5 stars
Reiteration of my favs 🫶🏻
Karen and Georgia really always make ME feel like I came back from a vacay when they come back strong with episodes like this! This episode felt like one of the older ones in the way that it was so casually funny and entertaining. The way they tell incredible stories - while including Steven! - is so easy to listen to. So thankful to be a part of this fan base of nice girls.. glad you are back, K&G 🫶🏻
lazebradeb
2 out of 5 stars
Ehh
It’s all chit chat
steph benford
1 out of 5 stars
Way too political
All I want to do is listen to True Crime. These women are super liberal and constantly want bash Republicans. On top of that, now they’re criticizing the Christian and Catholic faith. Absolutely disgusting trash. Can’t listen anymore.
deannakk
5 out of 5 stars
Thank you!
Thank you for your show. Still love it.
Harmakis7
2 out of 5 stars
Meh. Too much banter for me
The mini episodes are great. If and when the hosts get to the stories in their main episodes it’s great. But it can be 30 or more mins of banter I have no desire to listen to. I tried to enjoy this show but I just could not deal with the banter. Maybe good for others but I have too many to listen too and not enough time for nonsense.
12235567443568
1 out of 5 stars
👎🏻
Enough with the politics good lord
jrtpage
1 out of 5 stars
Somerton man
Talking about food preferences for 20 plus minutes was inane and caused me to unsubscribe. What a pathetic podcast
hjsnzjdj
1 out of 5 stars
When does the true crime podcast start?!!
15 min in and you’re still talking about TacoBell. NNNEEEEXXXXTTTTTTT
SadieKen
2 out of 5 stars
Umm
You guys talk like democrats are blameless… how about stick to true crime.
grbrya01
1 out of 5 stars
Banter banter banter
These ladies just talk WAY too much. Just get to the point already! 30 minutes into the episode and they’re still talking about people not wearing masks at JFK. Who cares?!
Kphelvie
5 out of 5 stars
Alaska earthquake episode
Just an fyi - the capitol is Juneau, not Anchorage. Nice review of the 64 quake. Couldn’t figure out how to send this feedback to the show directly.
tunatune17
4 out of 5 stars
Great podcast!
Love it!
njutes jouhncst
5 out of 5 stars
⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️
The Alaskan earthquake story has me crying at work
Daffg16
3 out of 5 stars
You forgot democrats are in power
You blame the republicans, but democrats are ruling.
Ro Chula
5 out of 5 stars
Thru 2020 and Beyond!
I first encountered these lovely true crime retelling during the pandemic and could not have been more pleased with the company. I appreciate the way that the victims are brought to life so that we can pay respects as well as learn about the real world experiences that we might be experiencing. Thank you for being with me during quarantine and now my replacement for music at work - and far more entertaining. Love love love this podcast!
angry ol salmon
5 out of 5 stars
Conservatives mommy bloggers beware
If the fact that Karen and Georgia are politically outspoken on their podcast that covers SA, murder, geopolitics, etc triggers you, you might not be cut out for true crime. They talk about heavy topics and have every right to use their platform to advocate for causes they believe in. Murders and other serious crimes are political. Get over it.
Sj Riley
3 out of 5 stars
Missing the Old Days
Love the show but I miss the original concept…TRUE CRIME! The crossover episodes and interviews are fine every once in a while, but it seems like they’re the norm these days. Bring back the old format…..K&G telling stories about true crime.
This guy, that guy
5 out of 5 stars
Still a great show
The show is great, always has been. Everyone recently is complaining about the interviews. They clearly missed the announcement that Georgia and Karen are on vacation and recorded a bunch of interviews to fill slots til they come back. Don’t like it? Erase the interviews. The format hasn’t changed. Come back in a week or 2 when they return. Except doubleomommy. You can stay away. They don’t like your politics and for good reason. Everyone else, chill. The murder gals will be back soon. Keep up the hard work Georgia, Karen and crew.
sidekick not side chick
1 out of 5 stars
officially a has-been
I’ve slowly phased this podcast out of my life and feed. Unlike most former listeners, the banter and political opinions don’t bother me! I actually just think the show lost its dna that I, and many others, were drawn to. I started listening when I was 16 (im 23 now). I remember there was a time I couldn’t imagine how I’d feel if they stopped making episodes, but I find myself saying “They’re still at it…” There are definitely great episodes, but the newer stuff is just hard to listen to. SSDGM.
🤟🏼💩
3 out of 5 stars
Great Podcast, But Has It’s Flaws
I enjoy listening to this podcast as a true crime and comedy lover! These girls truly give me a good laugh every time I listen but I do find it very frustrating that there are such long ads in so many different spots while listening. The other thing that really bothers me is that they talk about politics NONSTOP. I go to my podcasts to get away from it and it seems like every episode they’re talking about it. I don’t care what side of politics your on, I come to your podcast to listen to true crime and comedy, not to listen to you bashing republicans
Dgsjsuducnsh
3 out of 5 stars
Minisodes are just ads
I love this podcast and always will but am starting to stop listening to the minisodes because they are just one giant ad after ad. Disappointing.
CiaLM
5 out of 5 stars
First Time
I’ve never listened to a podcast before and MFM came up on suggestions when I stumbled upon the podcast app and I’m hooked! I listen everywhere and I tell everyone! Murderinos forever, SSDGM!
jen_unsubsribed
1 out of 5 stars
So disappointed
I lOVED this podcast in the beginning! I couldn’t want until Thursday! I am not one to write reviews, but what happened???? It’s terrible now. It’s like they are doing the bare minimum now. So sad.
krearle
3 out of 5 stars
Understand, but too much.
Look, I get these gals need a break. I get they still want to give us content and that’s why they do these guest episodes. The problem is, they go on longer than they say they will. Like they said the month of July in the last podcast of June. Now, it’s almost mid august and we still have guests. I too miss the old MFM and find myself only Listening to minisodes because at least they are interesting. Though the guests are important, most of the true followers know about these orgs or people because they Talk about them or they have their own thing. I hate to say it… but maybe it’s time to end it. Karen is what’s holding it together. Georgia seems to be derailed most shows.
purifh53
5 out of 5 stars
Absolutely still here
I’ve noticed a lot of unhappy reviews of people who are disappointed in the switch to interviews and a lack of true crime. I just want to be a voice saying I’m still here and loving it. Considering the interview with Kara Robinson, I completely see why MFM might be changing tracks a little bit. I would too if I were in their position. Anyway, I’m here, I’m with you, I’m not going anywhere.
doubleomommy
1 out of 5 stars
You ever have that one friend...?
who self-sabotages every good thing in her life? These are those women. They are uneducated, childless, and arguably have very little going for themselves. Somehow though, they miraculously struck gold with this podcast. Now...it must die. These two seem incapable of sticking to the formula that first made them a success. In their tiny little minds: “Orange Man Bad” so they CAN’T shut up about it. I’m out. A lot of us are out. When you quit listening like I did, make sure you unsubscribe. I would hate to see these two monetize former fans who they not only don’t care about, but openly revile. ETA: Small Town Murder is a great podcast that embodies the vibe that MFM had for about 200 episodes.
cora siebert
5 out of 5 stars
My Favorite True Crime Podcast
I absolutely love Karen and Georgia!! MFM was the very first true crime podcast I came across and I have been obsessed ever since. 🖤🖤
Dcannon1
4 out of 5 stars
Sad that it’s changed so much
Loved the podcast for so long and I do still like the occasional episode as well as the minisodes, but it seems like most of the Thursday episodes are cross promotions or guest interviews which just isn’t what got me into the show. I don’t mind the ads or cross promoting other Exactly Right shows here and there and I’m genuinely happy for Georgia and Karen’s success, but I just seem to be listening less and less.
Problems but fun
1 out of 5 stars
Seems like they’ve sold out
I regrettably have to say this is no longer one of my favorite podcasts. For 5 years I have loved this podcast but lately the content has been severely lacking. Too many ads, too many interviews, and lackluster social commentary leaves much to be desired. I’ll be searching elsewhere for my true crime needs.
2TacosDeAsada
1 out of 5 stars
Not what it once was
This show use to be good now its lost its meaning
Britknee00
2 out of 5 stars
Used to be a great podcast
This used to be one of my favorite podcasts but recently there’s just more chit chat than actual story. I also think while this show has definitely opened up talks about mental health which is great, the hosts are starting to make comments/give advice when they have no formal training or educational background in psychology or therapy. Having many years of your own experience in therapy doesn’t give you a degree. Hope they get back to the show format of previous episodes. Update: so now we are basically getting episodes with no true crime story just interviewing a guest??? need to go back to what made them successful in the beginning.
KelseyKay327
1 out of 5 stars
I listened everyday!
Editing previous review after learning about the SA at this network by Billy Jensen. Instead of addressing the horrific oversight K&G have turned to pushing extra ads and merch before they inevitably cancel.
S_mitty
5 out of 5 stars
Early episodes great- but sold out
I loved the dynamic, concept and scope of their stories. Latest episodes are a different idea- more interviews, cross overs and reaches for content. Completely different podcast as of late. Not to mention the sell out to Amazon. Kind of lost the dazzle when they sold out.
ana3725
2 out of 5 stars
No more guests please
My favorite podcast until recently when they started having so many guests & other podcasters. If I wanted to hear other podcasts I would… please go back to just you two.
brenbrenbrennnnn
2 out of 5 stars
Miss the old MFM
I really miss looking forward to a traditional MFM style story each Thursday. Recently I feel that there are more guest episodes than there are regular episodes.
Bgirlgagaspears930
3 out of 5 stars
So many interviews:/
I’ve been a huge fan for a while. I honestly love the chit chat, the stories, and even the politics but it seems like the format is changing so much. It’s felt like majority of the episodes are now all interviews and I just really miss all the new stories:( I’de rather there be a separate podcast for all the non-story related episodes
Maggiewest87
5 out of 5 stars
Dark best friends
I’ve been listening to Karen and Georgia for about 5 years now- they are my comfort podcast and when I’m lonely I put them on and it feels like my best friends are in the room. They’re hilarious, they’re respectful, and I enjoy hearing them discuss dark things with a sense of humor.
Tkittyh
1 out of 5 stars
I miss the original schedule for stories
I really want to plug in my headphones and listen to them banter and then each tell a story 😩 it’s now WEEKS in between the episodes like this & if I want to listen to someone from another podcast, I’d go and listen to that podcast! I have to find a new weekly listen & I'm super bummed.
meggieTR
1 out of 5 stars
Bummed
I used to love this show, was my favorite. Now they’ve clearly sold out, don’t seem to do their own research, too many guests, so many ads. There are so many other good true crime podcasts out there, so I stopped listening to Georgia and Karen. I’d happily listen again if they went back to what made them successful. Ugh
hmmmm was great
1 out of 5 stars
Hmmm was great
Adverts now in the middle of a sentence? You’ve sold out. I’m out.
paula deen33
5 out of 5 stars
This podcast rocks!!!
Thank you for giving something to laugh and freak out about at the same time!! And help me get through my work day.
sportymom67
5 out of 5 stars
LOVE
I am new to this podcast, started listening on my arizona to washington state drive and am currently listening to episode 30 I LOVE YOU GUYS THIS IS SO INTERESTING!!!!!
amybishop2021
5 out of 5 stars
It used to be a ton better…
My favorite murder is what got me into podcasts, and the early episodes are absolutely fantastic. However over the years it’s basically turned into a political opinion podcast with the murder portion being 10 minutes long. It’s not even that I don’t agree with most of the opinions, but in a world where you can never escape the news I don’t turn on a murder podcast to hear more about politics. They don’t do their own research anymore and it seems like they just run through the murders quickly without truly giving a crap. It’s sad, this used to be a favorite of mine.
Hootagain
1 out of 5 stars
Talking about nothing that involves a crime.
Too much talk about nothing relevant about a “favorite murder”. Horrible, when there are so many other true crime podcasts to listen to. Not what I was expecting at all.
Jekaa79
4 out of 5 stars
Love the older podcast
I loved this show for so long and I am changing my review. They use to have such fun banter, stories and seem to do the research themselves so you felt their enjoyment for the true crime. I know they’ve gotten bigger and popular but they just don’t seem/sound as happy as they use to and their format for podcast are changing and seem less enjoyable. It’s a more serious tone, it doesn’t seem as genuine. I really hope they can go back to their older podcast style. I no longer look forward to their shows, it seems like they’re just going through the motions and you can hear it through their episodes.
hailey kenniston
1 out of 5 stars
Split Podcast/Disrespectful
The first half of the podcast is them playing valley girls. Second half is a poorly researched recounting of murder. The podcast needs to be split into two different shows. One for the valley girls act, one for the murder. Combining the two, along with the half hearted attempt to research the murders, is disrespectful to the victims stories that you profit from.
92!,&3/
1 out of 5 stars
Listened from the Beginning but Stopped with Amazon Merger
Not much to say. These women sold out. The very companies that they would have disdain for they don’t care about as long as they get their bag. I think the most disgusting thing was that Karen addressed it by saying “People think that they are going to have to start paying for something”. No Karen people are upset that y’all sold out. But they don’t want to have that conversation. Also don’t want to talk about how they hired a predator.
Mama_Hess541
5 out of 5 stars
My Favorite Murder
Staying sexy and not getting murdered! Love you two, the therapy sesh’s are the best, I love how you tell the the stories of crime. Informed, sensitive to victims/survivors and theirs families♥️
whitney bitney
5 out of 5 stars
John Wayne Gacy
Hi my name is Whitney, I love your podcast and I have a story you should podcast John Wayne Gacy. He was nicknamed “Killer Clown” because of his job attending children’s birthday parties and charitable events as “Pogo the Clown.” His job gave him easy access to potential victims. Gacy was convicted of raping, torturing, and murdering 33 teenage boys over a six-year period. He would lure them to his home, kill them via either strangulation or asphyxiation, then bury them on his property. Gacy was executed in 1994. If you want to learn more check out Netflix’s Conversations with a Killer: The John Wayne Gacy Tapes Hope you enjoy it ✌🏻
sarahes_
5 out of 5 stars
So I would probably never write a review
But here I am, just to say, thank you so much for having this moment with Kara Robinson Chamberlain. It’s insane when everything one persona words just clicks. She made my morning, she made me think, and really made sense to me. I just am very appreciate for how sensible and wise her words were and yours together, so thank you.
RawDog420
2 out of 5 stars
Tell the story first
Please tell the story and then talk about it. Your episodes tend to start with 15 minutes of banter about a story that hasn’t been told yet. Assume your listeners are brand new to the subject matter and want to be educated about the case. Interject your thoughts along the way, but please start the story within the first five minutes.
twinklr14
2 out of 5 stars
So much garbage to get through
I just wish they didn’t babble mindlessly for half the episode. They really barely talk about the cases.
MaceKohl
5 out of 5 stars
Huge fan
I’ve been a fan of this podcast for years. Love the banter, stories, and minisodes
chibi girl chan
5 out of 5 stars
GREAT MURDER PODCAST sorry got excited
Hello and welcome to my review I love the show it’s funny and touches on great topics and I don’t really listen to the interviews but I still love them dearly and if you read this karen and Georgia you guys say hello to STEAVEN for me love a girl who loves mfm
MJ-1919
1 out of 5 stars
What was that
My first episode (333) will also be my last. It kicked off with 20 minutes of inane and irrelevant conversation and plentiful ads; presented a slightly interesting unsolved disappearance, then an actually interesting recent crime spree, all dispensed with unbearable stream-of-consciousness reactions. Noo thank you.
berijw
1 out of 5 stars
Too Many Guests
Not enough stories!
Cmzella
3 out of 5 stars
I miss the chit chat and laughs.
I love this show and listen every week, but I miss the fun chit chat and the stories. While the interviews are good, I am a little disappointed to see them for the last three weeks. I would have preferred mixing them in with real eps every couple weeks. Unlike other reviewers, I don't mind the politics. I believe that you cannot talk about true crime and the laws that govern where those crimes take place, without discussing politics. Please keep giving us your true and authentic selves, because it does nobody any good when you don't. ❤️
Kelseyh22
5 out of 5 stars
Huge murderino
Love these two. LOVE the banter at the top of full length episodes. They’ve turned me on to shows & podcasts I wouldn’t have heard otherwise. Hope they never stop. Also - STEPHEN!!!
allighQ
3 out of 5 stars
Please don’t bring murdering BABIES into this. Abortion IS MURDER.
This is a great show. Please don’t ruin it with your political agenda.
Mor25!
1 out of 5 stars
Not a fan
I listened to this podcast for a bit and as time went on I just started feeling more and more bothered by it. I listen to true crime a lot, I also listen to true crime that has comedy in it. But I only feel okay with it when the comedy is separate from the crime or targeted toward the perpetrator. I don’t know if it’s how peppy they are when talking about crime or congratulating each other at the end of the story? Like the wow, great job, that was amazing, etc that they say to each other after sharing about a brutal murder. It just rubs me the wrong way. Maybe it’s also the live shows they do? I guess that involves the fans as well. When they say the story today is about xyz murder case and the crowd cheers it just feels gross.
Samson Simpson
1 out of 5 stars
So bad
Don’t want to hear these garbage interviews. Too many commercials and just awful. So many better podcasts out there. Don’t waste your time with this trash.
Amanda J in Tx
5 out of 5 stars
love❤️❤️❤️
Have loved these women since 2018!
p7a1r1
5 out of 5 stars
My favorite podcast!
It’s the best! Karen & Georgia are the best! If you don’t like funny women talking about true crime.. you’re tacky and I hate you.
NotValidUsername
1 out of 5 stars
Ohhhh
My goddddd do they ever talk about the murder or just pop culture politics! Shut up! You’re annoying!
marialovesbooks
5 out of 5 stars
Jerri!
I resisted listening to this episode because I wanted to hear a murder story. But last night I was taking care of my plants and listened to you all discuss crime and dang!!!!! Great episode! Intelligent and witty conversation. I especially loved the thought provoking questions coming from Karen and Georgia. Jerri gave me a different kind of respect for the FBI. Kudos!
JCKW_
5 out of 5 stars
Love them!!
The Best!
Freddymich218
1 out of 5 stars
This podcast has totally gone downhill
My sister and I used to love this podcast and now we neither listen anymore. The hosts seem completely uninterested in the podcast anymore and half the time the episode will come out and instead of being it’s usual format, it’ll be a celebrity interview or something else. Most podcast do those are episodes on other days of week, not for their main episode! It’s too bad that it’s just fallen apart.
nicknamesnomore
4 out of 5 stars
Too many commercials
Ugh! Have listened for so many years but three long add breaks during a 20 minute minisode? The greed may be out running the quality content at this point. Too bad.
HappyMusic:)
4 out of 5 stars
Too Many Guests?
I used to love this podcast, and still love the regular episodes, but so many of the “new” eps from the past 2 years have been replays/clips of past episodes and live shows or interviews with guests instead of the actual premise of the hosts telling stories. Def a fan of Karen & Georgia but with all the tie-ins & guests it’s just not the same podcast.
Kymora29999
5 out of 5 stars
Please have Geri back!!!
We need more
FlamingoBlanket
5 out of 5 stars
Used to love it
So is this just a show where the new episodes are just other people’s shows and annoying ads?
TwinMommy-J
1 out of 5 stars
Very Political 😬😬😬
Yikes!!
snoriejo
5 out of 5 stars
Love it
You all are hilarious! Thanks for the laughs and crime. I enjoy all the chit chat.
JodeeGA
1 out of 5 stars
What a downer!
I wanted to be entertained…not preached to. I’m so disappointed
apeirce
1 out of 5 stars
I used to love this podcast!
So many adds, hosts less relatable all the time.
CEJP
5 out of 5 stars
Sooo late to the this party
I recently started listening to MFM about a month ago and have been frantically trying to catch up to the current episodes. It is amazing to hear Karen and Georgia talk about some unsolved murders/crimes from the earlier episodes that in more recent months has been solved (AKA Golden State Killer & Sherri Papini). I’m pretty sure that listening to 2 to 3 episodes a day has my husband very worried. But he’s sexy, so he won’t get murdered!
zimber1
1 out of 5 stars
Politics
I was looking for a new true crime podcast because my old one dove into political chats. It seems this one does too. I haven’t even listen to one episode but went straight to the comments section and there are many stating “leave politics out of it”. My search continues. I just want to forget about news not hear it while being entertained.
Madilyn Mitchell
5 out of 5 stars
Great binge
Incredibly smart women! Love both the stories and their banter, have been bingeing (is that a word?) since I found them!
Orchard650
2 out of 5 stars
Alienation
It’s baffling to me when wildly successful people decide to alienate half the people that had once admired and supported them, by injecting their politics where it need not be. There’s a time and place for everything. It’s your show, so you can do what you want, but it’s a shame to disappoint so needlessly, particularly when you consider the benefit you’re getting by doing so. Kind of shooting yourself in the foot.
ssdgm baddie .:
5 out of 5 stars
Great podcast!
It’s an absolutely great podcast, the minisodes are my personal favorites! They make you feel apart of their friend group just talking about murders, it’s great! To the people who leave bad and 1 star reviews about this podcast becoming political, your entitled to your own opinion but your opinion is wrong. Ok byeeeeee!
manda dr
5 out of 5 stars
Love love love love
Love the pod. Love the network. Love the friendships. Love the use of your platform for the greater good and the marginalized communities. Love the donations you make. Will always support you and your team.
syd7217
5 out of 5 stars
Love!
Love love love!
Blue NPR
5 out of 5 stars
Consistent relatable and awesome
Some reviewers here are apparently too sensitive to hear differing viewpoints! What jerks. Anyway, these two are vulnerable and charming and so so funny. Thanks for all you do! Really distracting and fun when you need a break.
Melissa HG
1 out of 5 stars
Too political
If I wanted to hear political views, I would seek out a podcast about politics. Every episode I attempted to listen to always went to pushing the agenda of the week, which wasn’t part of the crime being covered. A complete let down. Heading off to listen to true crime podcasts that leave out political opinions and stick to the story their covering.
SRW1!
1 out of 5 stars
Shifted
This show WAS great however the increase in political discussion is a put-off. One-sided views with unsupported facts to back it up. Understand if you have a public platform that you want to use it but isn’t this a true crime Podcast? That type of discussion is everywhere and this Pod used to be a great escape from it, not anymore. Go back to the Pod’s roots.
DachshundDad
1 out of 5 stars
Say something about Billy
I love this podcast but I can’t continue listening knowing you’ve been silent about the sexual misconduct that happened within your company. It’s not the politics- I’m fine with those- you need to acknowledge what happened. I won’t be listening in the meantime.
987654321why
5 out of 5 stars
When did y’all become a political forum?
I listen to MFM for entertainment. I seek news and serious issues on other podcasts. This week’s topic is of vital importance and needs addressing, just wonder if this is the new direction for MFM?
krud1
1 out of 5 stars
Wierd
So annoying! Wow these people love to hear themselves talk!!!
onitca
5 out of 5 stars
Can’t please everybody. Don’t want to.
I like the political talk. I like how they created their own network. Good job Role Models.
crazytalk101
1 out of 5 stars
Not entertaining
You will never get the hours spent listening to this podcast back in your life so move on. There are so many better podcasts try Going West instead.
linderrrman
5 out of 5 stars
I hope y’all see this
Your minisodes are my ADHD timer. I get SO much done with you. Thank youuuu!!!
BorgKir
5 out of 5 stars
Lunch Lady Eats Up this Podcast
Seriously funny yet courteous to the somberness of true crime. Don’t think that because these two are openly opposed to Republicans that you can’t take away fantastic views and messages that can alter your hard core thinking. I’m never going to be swayed from my right leaning beliefs but I honestly appreciate their outlook on current events. I listen to this while cooking for 539 kids every day (lunch lady life) and thankfully I work alone like a slave for next to nothing because I burst into giggles and laughter often. A gem of a podcast.
Lyndsy Lanie Carter1234
1 out of 5 stars
Disappointed
I’ve been a fan since the beginning, gone to several live shows and all that, and I never thought I would unfollow this podcast, but here we are. Y’all gonna make a statement about what’s going on with Billy? Your handling of this shows little integrity. Be human first, business people second. We all trusted him and YOU TWO. He tricked us all, would you please just acknowledge something. Like one sentence. “We fired billy for inappropriate behavior, we stand with our staff” like it’s not too much.
Xo.aiden
5 out of 5 stars
Love these women, love the politics
10/10 thank you for all you do, thank you for speaking up. To all those saying to stop mentioning our rights being taken away, or the importance of vaccines, and get right to the murder, you sound like nuts.
madsoverlads
5 out of 5 stars
Love love love
I have been watching them for years and love their approach to every episode! What hilarious and intelligent females, I love how they have begun to incorporate information about Roe vs. Wade being overturned as basic human rights were stripped away This is NOT a political stand, if you don’t agree they probably don’t care for your view anyways. XOXO madi
Awkwardly Social Podcast
5 out of 5 stars
Summer Break
Have a nice summer see you next semester! Keep in touch!
CecileT
1 out of 5 stars
Not A Comedy True Crime Podcast
It’s more of an excuse to air their political beliefs. A podcast is definitely a way to do that, but these ladies seem to do so manipulatively. Like, hey do you like true crime and comedy? You’ll get twenty minutes of that while the other 3/4s of the episode is a political soapbox. Kinda of like Sword and Scale, except in S&S at least the majority of the episode is the actual telling of someone’s real story— you know, giving the victim an actual voice? MFM does the exact opposite and uses people’s tragedy as an in to get their own agenda out there. And people pay them to do so. Real classy. I listen to other true crime comedies who do share their opinions, but they don’t do so narcissistically.
ovsandy
5 out of 5 stars
Consistently my favorite
I have been listening to this podcasts for years and I have never stopped loving it. They are so funny, so real, and feel like the aunts that’ll keep your secrets when you don’t want your mom to know. I look forward to listening to them every week.
Tessa__O
5 out of 5 stars
Love this
My daughter got me hooked on this in January 2022 and I listen whenever I get a chance. I am up to March 2020 already, so I will be sad when I can’t binge endlessly when I am all caught up.
Emma__V
5 out of 5 stars
My favorite podcast
I love love love this podcast! Karen and Georgia hilariously recount both true crime classics and lesser known stories that deserve more attention. I love their banter at the beginning of episodes and that they are not silent on important current events and the events surrounding the murders. 10/10 recommend :)
Ka27272
1 out of 5 stars
Fun till they get political
I stopped listening to a bunch of their other pod casts for the same thing. I love listening them cry about it though. Edit seven months later looks like this podcast is falling down along with a lot of their other shows. Maybe next time don’t be so hateful
Dyanthis
5 out of 5 stars
It’s okay to talk about it
I don’t always agree with your politics and yes sometimes I cringe. I have been on either side and in between of the political spectrum. (I can change my mind. Right? Lol). I feel you can have your opinion and be steadfast. Most everyone else does too right? Which is why they’re leaving. I love it when you talk about your personal lives and thoughts. I’ve lost a couple of friends because they felt so strongly about their position and decided I was scum or something. I really try to have thoughtful, sympathetic conversations. Not, “I don’t agree with you so eff off!” Lol Anyway, loved you guys from day one and you’ll always be my podcast friends. 😊 SSDGM!
ShelbyMootz
5 out of 5 stars
Love these gals
Karen and Georgia do an amazing job and they have an amazing support staff. If you are into true crime and want two more bffs this podcast is for you.
jmom7
3 out of 5 stars
Love the stories but wish they would leave certain topics out of it.
I love the way the girls tell the stories but wish I didn’t have to listen to the 10 minutes of their beliefs on certain subjects, that many of Their listeners may have different views on. I just don’t feel that it even needs mentioned. I respect that they are showing their support to the listeners that do feel the same way but 100 percent of their listeners don’t feel that way.
anabelle1308
5 out of 5 stars
Love this podcast so much
I only started listening to this podcast a few weeks ago but it is one of then best podcasts I’ve listened to so far. I appreciate your opinions and statements on the overturning of Roe vs. Wade and am happy you guys recognize that this is something that is dire need of change. Everyone deserves a choice of what they can do with their own body.
LizzyYow
4 out of 5 stars
Freaking out!
My husband never listens to podcasts but today, we were sitting on our back patio on a beautiful afternoon and I started listening to 2000 pounds of Soap. We both loved the story but especially all the Chicago references. We met and married in Chicago but now live in Marin County. At the end of your story you mention the building that was turned into condos in the late ‘90’s. That was our first condo we lived in when we had our first baby!!!! My husband remembered that our building had been a sausage factory and confirmed it online! We are so freaked out!! Thanks for giving us a story to talk about!!
Arob1
1 out of 5 stars
Stay focused
I don’t share your political views but I put it aside in the past. Y’all have chosen to continue to “educate” us with your personal opinions. I just unfollowed after many years of listening. I listen to podcasts to entertain and lighten my life, not to listen to your darkness. I choose other places to educate myself about laws and my rights. Goodbye
naomi grant podcaster DSY
1 out of 5 stars
Too political
You don’t know if all
#never Viking
2 out of 5 stars
Too political
Did not appreciate these two nasty girls calling the Supreme Court judges fascists. I guess they never read the ruling sending the decision on abortion back to the states where it belongs. Wanted to be entertained not lectured to by nitwits. They are free to have abortions if they want and they know it.
_saralew_
2 out of 5 stars
Trying to Stick Around
Few podcasts have made me laugh as much as this one- I LOVE your dry wit and conversational skill. Thoroughly appreciate everything about this, though I’ve simply shelved some differing politics opinions. I don’t mind disagreeing with people- I just listen here for entertainment anyway. But lately, we’re all getting it from all sides and your podcast is not an escape anymore. It’s almost felt as if you’re pushing those with differing beliefs away, and don’t want us enjoying your jokes and storytelling if we disagree with your politics or views on covid. This is simply my feedback- If you want to run a true crime podcast with the amount of politics it currently contains, then that is your right to do so. But people like me might have to (very sadly) unsubscribe.
virginella
2 out of 5 stars
Inane chit chat
Each show begins with way too much mind numbing chit chat. Have always fallen asleep before they finally get to the crime.
schmidty252
5 out of 5 stars
Fun podcast about murder
Love everything about this! Got a very late start to this podcast and listening through it.
karibell2
5 out of 5 stars
Love you guys
Just found the podcast and love you guys thank you girls for doing what you do. Love you guys. Kari
Sgvlgtbk
5 out of 5 stars
The best
What can I say that hasn’t been said before. This is literally the best podcast out there.
Sara_berry
1 out of 5 stars
Disappointed Fan
I loved listening in the past, but the last few months the weekly Th show seems more like a chore to them. They don’t seem to be into true crime as much as they used to be. With all the political frustrations we are bombarded with daily, I wish they would keep off their soapboxes. Not everyone agrees with their far left views and they seem to be alienating their more moderate listeners who come here to listen as an escape from the daily garbage we are faced with. Please get back to your true crime roots and save you political rants for another podcast or forum.
f4mILYjules
1 out of 5 stars
You Guys Aren’t Funny
Oh my goddd. Shut.up. And just get.to.the story. I thought this was MFM. If I wanted to listen to 2 middle aged liberal women talk about nonsense all day, I would have turned on The View. 40 minutes into the podcast and you’re still talking about everything and anything, while talking about nothing of importance at the same time. You used to be the highlight of my week. Now, I can hardly stand you two.
pergola lady
5 out of 5 stars
We won’t go back. Keep keepin on!
Thank you for highlighting the current horrible state of womens rights, specifically reproductive rights.
K.J. Sharp-Knife
1 out of 5 stars
Yikes!
I usually like it but the latest one was so full of anger over abortion and Christians and people not taking the ineffective vaccine that I had to turn it off. It almost ruined my day.
CrimeNextDoor
5 out of 5 stars
Linda Ronstadt
Not a biggie, but Linda Ronstadt practically forced The Eagles to become their own band. It never once was “we don’t want to be in a girl band.” They have always credited her and paid homage to her for them becoming the Eagles because of the opportunity she gave them. She knew Glenn Fry and Don Henley prior and they also knew each other prior to playing in her band as backup. She told them they need to form a band and go off on their own, not the situation you’re describing.
JUJ127
1 out of 5 stars
Trash
Tried listening after a friend recommended the show to me. In the opening seconds they reference the recent Supreme Court decision to overturn Roe. Not going to listen to a show where women advocate for murdering their own children. Garbage.
Jesssssssssskkka
1 out of 5 stars
Used to listen - never again
I loved this podcast and listened frequently until the girls made some really gross comments about religion. Especially in this day and age of (some, not all) people trying so hard to come together and accept each other, fighting for rights and tolerance, you girls are part of the problem by talking badly about something you clearly know nothing about. If I were you I’d keep my personal ill informed opinions about religion to myself and focus on telling true crime stories instead.
StoneyPanda93
1 out of 5 stars
Forever a fan.
I have been a fan since 4 years ago. Recently the vibe doesn’t feel the same. I don’t feel the goofyness, or the banter doesn’t feel the same. It’s a shame because this was my first true crime podcast and I have migrated to Morbid now. I hope you gals get your magic back…
wineruino
5 out of 5 stars
Episode 333 is classic MFM
I just loved episode 333, it was classic MFM, fun banter, anecdotes, great LA knowledges/info, great jokes, and compelling well told stories. Loved it. But also, Georgia definitely said “FLESH-light”
newjoysey
2 out of 5 stars
So disappointing!
I’ve been a regular listener since they started in 2016, but their choice to remain silent about sexual misconduct and harassment that occurred within their company has made it morally impossible for me to continue listening and supporting them. Very saddened by it.
podtownreview
5 out of 5 stars
The best
To anyone complaining about politics: true crime, politics, and our realities are interwoven. You’re airing your frustration in the wrong place. And if you can’t stand 30 sec of opinions you don’t agree with, best of luck out there… Probably my favorite podcast since the beginning. Thanks for the many years of genuine content. Can’t wait for another live show!
Mich0515
5 out of 5 stars
My Favorite Podcast
I love these two ladies so much! Thank you for all you do!
Nichacolie
2 out of 5 stars
Has become too political
I have been an MFM listener for 6 years or so. I love Georgia and Karen but their political rants are just too much. We're all exhausted with politics, can we go back to true crime ladies?
spygold
1 out of 5 stars
Unsubscribed
Just unsubscribed…your commentary on the recent Dobbs case and the Supreme Court ruling should have been kept to yourself. I can no longer support or listen to your podcast.
As honest as they can get!
3 out of 5 stars
Wonderful podcast, few observations.
Been listening for a minute and I just as several listeners appreciate the light hearted banter. I think it is important however that Karen and Georgia recognize sensitive and triggering points in a story and resist from side bar-ing. They could probably have the jokes and Banter before and after the horrific stories because in as much as we all love these stories they are actual peoples LIVES. This is not fiction, at the very least respect the lives of the victims by NOT cracking jokes in the middle of retelling their (and every sane persons)worst nightmare. I do appreciate Karen’s bold take on current political issues and the podcasts generosity to several wonderful initiatives.
its_just_meeeeeeeeéeeeee
3 out of 5 stars
Not my favorite anymore.
I used to love MFM and listened religiously l, but the last year just doesn’t seem like their hearts are really in it any more and it falls short. Wine and Crime is way better.
GoldilocksSF
5 out of 5 stars
Thank you for the Roe V Wade talk
So important to come together right now!
Leakey3
5 out of 5 stars
Vocal fry
Caricature of empathy &intelligence. Oh who am I kidding, I am just uncomfortable with Powerful women. Five stars for the podcast, for myself, I need to work on some things.
cherrio65
1 out of 5 stars
Political Platform
True crime isn’t the place to voice your political views. Smart people don’t alienate their audience over political bias. I won’t be listening.
SkyAnn.wv.usa
5 out of 5 stars
Thank you
Learn how to, Stay Sexy and Don’t Get Murdered. It’s a wonderful experience 😉
puxzled
1 out of 5 stars
Bye Bye
Not my favorite anymore…sorry to go but, just can’t stand the politics and cancel culture
Boredinthemodwest
1 out of 5 stars
Political views
I only listen for the stories… Not your political views!
Hawaii_Life
5 out of 5 stars
Bravo for Karen and Georgia!!!
Not only have I been a regular listener of your podcast for years, but I really admire both of you for vocalizing your beliefs! You don’t just provide us with amazing podcasts, but you stand up for beliefs which protect, encourage and support basic principles of human rights. Most recently your support of a woman’s right to make decisions about abortion! I’m almost 70 yrs old, and for years I have fought for equal rights for women and against racism! Thank you!!!
Georgiaclay
1 out of 5 stars
Profit > Actually respecting victims and their stories
Imagine profiting off stories of victims and survivors to turn around and fully support an abuser/predator by not saying anything or speaking up. all of your words mean nothing now and i’m glad i stopped listening a while ago.
Smacky80
5 out of 5 stars
Excellent
Probably the podcast I’ve listened to the longest and my love has never waned! Great mix of true crime and humor with a healthy dose of banter. Love hearing their perspectives on myriad issues and it’s a podcast that honors the victims which isn’t always the case in this genre. Keep it up, ladies!
locabean
1 out of 5 stars
Long time listener, but no more.
Your silence speaks VOLUMES.
bethedesigner
1 out of 5 stars
Too political
The hosts assume everyone who listens to their shows are progressive liberals and agrees with everything they believe.
Hi334488
5 out of 5 stars
My favorite part is them catching up
Karen and Georgia are my role models for being an authentic human. I love listening to them just catch up with each other. My favorite podcast!
Podcast information
- Amount of episodes
- 726
- Subscribers
- 4
- Verified
- No
- Website
- Explicit content
- Yes
- Episode type
- episodic
- Podcast link
- https://podvine.com/link/..
- Last upload date
- March 23, 2023
- Last fetch date
- March 24, 2023 7:17 AM
- Upload range
- WEEKLY
- Author
- Exactly Right
- Copyright
- © Exactly Right
susbcribers
- My Favorite Murder with Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark Mar 16 · 1h 14m 370 - Necessary YellingThis week, Georgia covers "The Bandit Queen" Pearl Hart and Karen tells the Mount St. Helens eruption survival story of Dave Crockett. For our sources and show notes, visit www.myfavoritemurder.com/episodes.0 comments0
- My Favorite Murder with Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark Feb 23 · 58m 367 - High-Fives With Both HandsThis week, Karen covers the missing persons case of Donald Boardman and Georgia tells the story of the "Missing Boy of Somosierra,” Juan Pedro Martínez Gómez. For our sources and show notes, visit www.myfavoritemurder.com/episodes.0 comments0
- Wondery Presents: Frozen HeadHosted by Ash Kelley and Alaina Urquhart from the hit show Morbid. When 90-year-old Laurence Pilgeram drops dead on the sidewalk outside his condo, you might think that’s the end of his story. But, really, it’s just the beginning. Because Laurence and others like him have signed up to be frozen and brought back to life in the future. And that belief will pull multiple generations of the Pilgeram family into a cryonics soap opera filled with dead pets, gold coins, grenades, fist fights, mysterious packages, family feuds, Hall of Fame baseball legends, and frozen heads — lots of frozen heads. From Wondery, comes a story about life, death, and what comes next. Follow Frozen Head on Amazon Music or wherever you get your podcasts. Binge early and ad-free by subscribing to Wondery+ in Apple Podcasts or the Wondery App. Listen to Frozen Head: Wondery.fm/FH_MyFM0 comments0
- 361 - The OpportunistOn today's episode, Georgia and Karen are joined by Hannah Smith, the host of the podcast The Opportunist, to tell the story of Sandra Anderson and her dog, Eagle. Note: The book Karen mentioned in today's episode is "Finder: The True Story of a Private Investigator" by Marilyn Greene and Gary Provost.0 comments0
Podcast hosts
No host has claimed this podcast yet, if you are the host you can verify ownership by claiming this podcast
© Exactly Right
